Syria, Jordan, US: false friends for PLO
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-07-03Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
On a recent visit to Britain, Abu Sami, a member the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, spoke at a meeting organised by the Labour Movement Campaign for Palestine. Clive Bradley asked him about the current situation in Lebanon, in the occupAnd anyway It Is not syria s the ralestinian bourgeoisle are or Amal's task to carry out that having a lot of influence on the fight, and not by military means. Central Committee of al-Fateh. Arafat's right wing political They need some kind of accom-leadership should be combatted modation with imperialism to by trying to convince his follow- end the Palestinian struggle. Bit ers of the dangers into which by bit they are surrendering the he is leading the Palestinian very basic rights of the PalesTHE militas of Amal are trying to disarm the Palestinians in the refugee camps round Beirut. They have a green light from Syria.
Syria wants to rearrange Lebanon its own way - which falls far short of the demands of the national democratic Lebanese forces. Syria couldn't do this themselves, they needed allies.
Amal is one of the Lebanese forces whose aims now coincide with those of Syria. That's why the Syrians gave the green light to Amal, who have their own reasons for trying to disarm the Palestinians.
Their logic is that the Palestinian presence in Lebanon has caused Israeli attacks: so they must prevent the Palestians using Lebanon as a base.
Does this mean that the Syrians are involved with the Americans or the Israelis in some kind of plot? We believe not.
The Syrians have miscalculated. They thought that it would take one or two days to defeat the Palestinians. It didn't. We have information that Nabih Berri, the leader of Amal, told Syria it would take Amal six hours to do the job. ied territories, and in the PLO.
The Syrians want to eliminate any opposition forces - in the first place the Palestinians, but also the Lebanese Communist Party, the Syrian Social Nationalist Party - who aren't fascists, the name is misleading -to a certain extent the Lebanese branch of the Ba'ath Party, and, to a certain extent the ProgrescivA Sonialict Party of Walia sive Jumblat. These forces want a political rather than a confessional solution.
The attack on the camps by amal is, they claim, a fight against the pro-Arafat groups, which is wrong. Only a minority of the people in the camps are loyal to Arafat. revolution.
All the Palestinians in the camps, of whatever political colour, are resisting. It's not a battle against Arafat, that's just a pretext.
After the siege of Beirut in 1982, Arafat concluded that it was useless for the PLO. to remain an anti-imperialist movement. So he insists on alliances with Jordan, Egypt, Iraq. He's ambiguous oyer the Reagan Plan.
Rights
These things follow from the class perspective of the PLO leadership. The upper strata of tinian people — the right to have an independent state of their own, the right of return to their homes, and the right of the PLO to be the sole legitimate representative of the Palestinians.
The PLO leadership has begun practical involvement in the American plan for the region: some combination of the Reagan Plan, Resolution 242, Camp David, we can't forecast exactly. But we can be sure of what will not come out of this - no Palestinian independent state.
Opposition
The opposition in Fateh (known in the Western press as the Abu Musa group), the Popular Front for the Liberation of Palestine, the PFLP-General Command, the Palestinian Struggle Front, the Palestine Liberation Front, al-Saiga, which is pro-Svria, have all formed a bloc in the PLO, called the National Salvation Front. Its aim is to win the PLO back to an anti-imperialist stand, and to maintain the PLO as the sole legitimate representative of the Palestinians.
This entails abrogating the Amman agreement, and removing the present leadership. But we want to be part of the PLO. We don't want to have two PLOs. We are trying to push Arafat aside, without giving him the PLO. It's not his PLO.
Resistance in the occupied territories has escalated, despite the attitudes of the right-wing PLO leadership. This can be seen in terms of military activity against the occupation forces, mass political activity, mass organisations making petitions against the Amman Agreement.
Small We are not against cooperation with every democratic anti-Zionist force in Israel, so long as we do not have to surrender our right to struggle for an independent Palestinian state. We have contacts with the Israeli Communist Party, with the Matzpen [revolutionary left] fragments; we are ready to cooperate with any Israeli Jewish anti-Zionists. At present these forces are small, but we regard them as potential allies.ands of intellectuals were harassed but not executed in the 'hundred flowers" period before the Great Leap Forward Three bad harvests combined with the Sino-Soviet split resulted in a severe dislocation of agriculture and industry in the early sixties. But "millions" did not perish.
The world, she do run in funny ways. Way back on October 4 1984, your publication ran a review by one Gerry BenNoah, of my books, Zionism in the Age of the Dictators and The Iron Wall.
Now Ben-Noah is forced to admit that "Mosi of the events he (Brenner) refers to," meaning my charges that various Zionist factions collaborated with the Hitlerites, "are real" However, "This is not to say that a sizeable catalogue of inaccuracies and contradictions within Brenner's corpus could not be assembled"
Well said, except that he then kind of forgot to tell us about even one specific inaccuracy.
After wasting a page with unsubstantiated charges about my alleged errors, Ben-Noah sagely counseled us that Marxists would be better off turning to Nathan Weinstock's Zionism: False Messiah" • An excellent choice, especially as Weinstock has been kind enough to write me that my book is "a fine piece of work, " and that he has tried to get it translated into French!
Ben-Noah had the audacity to call me a "paranoid". Why? Because of the suggestion that rich Jews control the US Democratic Party and thus American foreign policy"
Except that since the Democrats don't control Washington, not even a paranoid like me can think that any Democrat, Jewish or otherwise, runs Reagan's ORGANISER each door by post.
Name • Address Please sen d me.... months' sub. I enclose £ ..
To: Socia namese, Khmer Rouge and Cuban regimes are all "members of the Stalinist family" But no insight is gained about either the Khmer Rouge's "bizarre and barbarous experiment in social engineering" or about Maoist China by loosely linking the two.
CHEUNG SIU MING curacies foreign policy.
However, crazy guy that I am, I do not 'suggest", I insist that rich Jews - not rich Albanians - are the single most important financial factor in the Democratic Party, and that therefore that party will stick with Zionism to the end.
But would you believe it, I'm not the only lunatic on the set. Certainly most American scholars would acknowledge G. William Domhoff as the great specialist on the country's rich. That sociologist wrote, in his Fat Cats and Democrats, that:
"Since the gentile financial community is almost exclusively Republican, however, it is the Jewish financiers who by default provide the Democrats with their handful of essential money raisers among the super-wealthy ...Jewish investment bankers combined with other Jews...to provide the financial leadership major nom-Southern city every Boston."
There is no need to go on, it is obvious that when Ben-Noah is not libelous he is ignorant, and when not ignorant he is libelous. All that needs to be further said is that it is evident that Zionism is in deep trouble over my charges if the Jewish Chronicle had to stoop to trying to utilise Ben-Noah's frothings to defend itself. LENNI BRENNER • We invite both Gerry BenNoah and Lenni Brenner to continue the debate in the pages of months' sub. i enclose E miser, 214 Sickert Court, London Socialist Organiser no. 234 July 3 1985 Page
Scan page 10
laking flight GERRY BYRNE'S Clive Bradley reviews 'Birdy', directed by Alan Parker, which is now showing at the Odeon Haymarket,