Background to the scab breakaway
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-07-10Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 2
Roy Lynk's move to get a breakaway union in Notts has been long prepared. John Bloxam outlines the
Roy Ly has k eel histo ry
JUNE. With some strikers ONE OF the main differences between the 1984-5 strike in Notts, and the 1926 strike, is that at no time in 1984-5 were there more than 50% of the Area's 28,000 miners on strike.
In addition, this time a key section of the officials openly encouraged scabbing from the start. By June 1984 they had captured the official machinery of the Area.
All the indications are that these people had the clear intention, from an early stage. of organising a breakaway company union in the area.
These are the key events and the crucial stages in their campaign to turn the solid support for scabbing in the area into a base to break out of the NUM.
MARCH-APRIL 1984: The Notts Area voted 20188 to 7285 against taking strike action. But two things were decisive in determining that a majority went from voting against a strike - South Wales voted the same way — to scabbing, was the vacillation of Richardson and Chadburn, the two main area officials, during the the first month of the strike, and the success of the police in walling off the coalfield from the majority of the pickets.
The number of strikers reached its high point (between 12 and 14 thousand) in the month after the Area Council made the strike official on April 20.
But the scab leaders were organising openly to change this decision and to undercut the strike's support.
MAY. On May Ist, with the help of the police and the Coal Board, the scab leaders organised an anti-strike demonstration of 7000 outside the Area HQ at Berry Hill, Mansfield.
By the end of the month they had won a High Court injunction overturning the official strike call, and they openly declared the formation of the *Notts Working Miners Committee.
This Committee was closely liniked to the NCB. MacGregor had even put them in touch with union-busting lawyers.
police harassing to stop them voting, the anti-strike slate pur forward by the Working Miners Committee' swept the board in the branch elections. Now the courts ruled the strike unofficial, and the numbers out steadily declined.
By August, 80% of Notts miners were scabbing.
JULY-AUGUST. The NUM leaders introduced, and the delegate conference carried, the longprepared and scheduled new disciplinary rule 51. The scab leadership in Notts, with plenty of help from the media, screamed that it was aimed against them.
The NUM leaders said it wasn't, and in fact they never used this Rule against the scab organisers.
Shortly after the NCB started sacking strikers, the 'National Working Miners Committee: was set up on August 17 with the help of David Hart, a businessman and an associate of Margaret Thatcher.
DECEMBER. The Area Executive recommended a series of rule changeds in Notts, which was overwhelmingly endorsed. by the Area Council on December 20. They rejected calls for an Area ballot on the changes, Drawn up with the help of lawyers, these changes deleted all reference to the Area rules being subordinate to the national rules. It was a decisive move in breaking with the national union.
JANUARY 1985. In response to the Notts rule changes, the NEC began proceedings to expel the Notts area at its meeting on January 10. At the left caucus meeting before the NEC, Arthur Scargill is reported to have argued for suspension rather than expulsion. South Wales argued strongly for expulsion, and Scargill was in the minority.
The NEC decision was followed up by a campaign in the Area by the strikers to recruit rank and file scabs back into the NUM.
Two Notts branches, Linby and Moor Green, voted to stay in the NUM. Pye Hill branch voted to drop its delegate and voted, against the insistence of its branch delegate, leading Become a supporter of the Socialist Organiser Alliance - groups are estab lished in most large towns. We ask £5 scab organiser Colin Clarke, to invite Arthur Scargill to address the branch. Clarke and other scabs then walked out of the meeting.
Later in the month, strikers distributed thousands of national NUM leaflets entitled, 'No return to Spencerism; stay with the NUM Outside Notts the scab leaders also suffered setbacks. Forms for Lynk's company union were rejected even by scabs in other areas, despite help from the police.
On January 23 the TUC publicly declared that it would not recognise a breakaway, the Labour Party NEC likewise (despite assurances to the scabs from Mansfield MP Don Concannon).
But the campaign in Notts, aimed at the rank and file scabs. petered out when the NUM deleembracing the membership"
added).
FEBRUARY. The scab leaders in Notts voted to suspend Henry Richardson, threatening to sack him for the 'crime' of supporting the strike. They started a campaign against the overtime ban in Notts, despite the fact that the ban was a democratically binding decision taken by a delegate conference 16 months earlier.
They continued to boycott all the delegate conferences being held during the strike.
The strikers in the area, with national NUM support, organised a 'Keep Notts National" campaign.
The press reported that scab leaders were pressing the NCB to remain intransigent and to drag the strike out, to give them more time to organise.
MARCH. The scab leaders sacked Henry Richardson and kicked out all those at Area HQ who had supported the strike. It refused to take part in the national ballot on the 50p levy for sacked miners, and it unilaterally lifted the overtime ban.
They established links with the tiny breakaway union formed in the North-East (the Colliery Trades and Allied Workers Association) and established the 'Democratic Alliance' within the NUM with South Derbyshire. Leicestershire. and the clerical section COSA.
They still publicly claimed that they had no intention of breaking away, and Lynk said he would stand against Mick MeGahey for NUM vice-president entire NUM (emphasis 60:
FOR THE Votts strikers. Photo: John Harris At the East Midlands regional Labour Party conference, Lynk refused the Notts NUM delegation the right to vote on their attitude to a resolution moved by SO supporter Steve Battlemuch, sharply denouncing and dissociating the Labour Party from the scabs. The resolution was defeated two to one.
APRIL. With the agreement of the scab leaders, the NCB started moving prominent scabs from other coalfields into Notts. It was announced that arch-MacGregorite Albert Wheeler, the former Scottish area director. would take over as director of North and South Notts in July.
Harassment of the ex-strikers in the coalfield was stepped up. with the ruling that they were 'unfinancial' — which means barred from union business -until they paid back subs for the period of the strike.
They were being fined for supporting the national strike!
At the beginning of April the NEC announced a proposed new rule book, to be put to the July delegate conference.
They argued that its purpose was to tidy up the rules and protect the union from further legal attack. The Notts scab leaders seize the issue with both hands: they start an immediate campaign, virulently denouncing the proposals as 'dictatorship"
They focused on the proposal to drop NUM president Arthur Scargill's casting vote, a proposal designed to avoid having an unscheduled election imposed on the union under the Tories" anti-union legislation.
The Notts leaders announced an area ballot on the changes for May 13.
Arthur Scargill went to Durham to persuade miners there to halt expulsions and "stop driving scabs into the arms" of the breakaway TAWA.
MAY. The scab leaders took the move towards a breakaway a significant step further when they put the tollowing question to an area ballot: "Do you support your Notts Executive Committee in opposing the new national rule changes even if this means being expelled from the NUM or leaving the National Union of Mineworkers?" The ballot was taken before any chance to discuss the details of the rule-changes or even consider amendments.
Ex-strikers and others campaign for a 'no' vote, with a new paper, "The Notts Collier", published by the Notts Miners Forum. Pit management frequently harassed miners distributing the Collier.
The scab leaders won a major victory in the ballot — 15,000 to 6,500. It was a clear indication of a secure base for a breakaway.
But tactically they kept stringing the process out, hoping all the time to provoke their expulsion.
Right-winger Greatorex won the ballot for a new area official;
ex-striker Geoff Peace came a respectable third.
At the end of the month the High Court overturned the attempt to fine and thereby exclude the ex-strikers. It ordered that the money be paid back.
JUNE. The NEC summoned Lynk and Prendergast to hear charges about openly organising against the NUM; the NEC recommended that the July conference should sack Lynk as a full-time official and reprimand Prendergast.
Lynk, Prendergast and Chadburn took out new contracts of employment with the Notts area.
In the branch elections, the ex-strikers won some significant victories — gaining a majority on the Ollerton committee, and kıckıng out super-scab Liptrot at Sherwood - but the area was still overwhelmingly controlled by the old scab leadership.
JULY. The Notts delegation arrived at the NUM conference every day in a bus with police outriders. They announced they would vote against everythingSome even voted against a resolution condemning apartheid.
On the Monday they tried to condemn the national leaders for their handling of the strike, and couldn't even get a seconder. On Tuesday they voted against supporting sacked miners. On Wednesday, after a seven-hour closed session, both Lynk and Prendergast were sacked as full-time officials. They remained on the NEC.
On Thursday the Notts scab leaders voted against a resolution bringing in the new rulebook. When they lost, they walked out.
On Friday night the Area EC voted to recommend a breakaway. An area delegate conference on Saturday approved it by 228 votes to 20.
On Monday July 8 they took the name 'Nottinghamshire Union of Mineworkers , and that same night got a written undertaking from area director Wheeler that they would be recognised.
The NCB knows its own.
----- pull-quotes -----
NOTTS • NOR THE
ESTRIK BIE