Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

1945: the victory that failed LABOUR

Socialist Organiser no. 235, 10 July 1985 · scan p. 5 · Martin Thomas · about 1,000 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 5

Many spoke of the period as a socialist country are selfish, depraved, dissolute revolution. Yet obviously it wasn't that. and decadent"

The Tories, ruling for 13 years after Such talk alarmed the Labour leaders. 1951, preserved most of Labour's All except Aneurin Bevan had been reforms, de-nationalising only iron and members of the wartime coalition under steel. The nationalised industries have Churchill. Clement Attlee, the prime been state-capitalist rather than social- minister from 1945 to '51, recalled ist; indeed, nationalised-industry mana- "very pleasant memories of working gers like lan MacGregor have often been with my colleagues in the [coalition) govOnly now, after world capitalism has Party issue arose to divide us... suffered slowdown and crises for 15 From the Tory-led coalition Labour years, are the Tories making a serious inherited intact a deeply conservative victory.

It got a 146-seat majority in the July 1945 general election.

In the next three years the new government nationalised the Bank of England, coal, gas, electricity, railways, part of inland transport, and cable and wireless. It set up the National Health Service, expanded social security, and ran a major house-building programme. It gave independence to india, for nearly Empears the keystone of the British In 1951 it nationalised iron and steel.

The main leaders of the Labour Party were nervous about such radicalism.

At the December 1944 Labour Party conference they had fought, unsuccessfully, against committing a Labour government to any nationalisation. The electorate would never support socialist principles; as Herbert Morrison put it in May 1945, "it is no good saying that we are going to socialise electricity, fuel and power because it is in accordance with Labour Party principles.. you must spend substantial time in arguing the case for the socialisation of these industries on the merits of their specific cases.

*That is how the British mind works. It does not work in a vacuum or in abstract theories"

In fact that Labour government did better electorally than the other, more timid, Labour administrations. It went out, in October 1951, with 48.8% of the vote - more than the 48% it came in with in 1945. The Tories got a parliamentary majority in 1951 thanks to quirks of the electoral system and the collapse of the Liberal vote.

Labour Party individual membership rose to over one million in 1952; Labour Party trade union affiliations rose from 2.5 million in 1945 to 5 million in 1951.

Revolution in the forefront of bosses' offensives.

Of all Labour governments in history, only one is looked bacl at with some satisfaction -1945-51. It brought major reforms. Yet it also sent troops against strikers and waged a colonial war in Malaya. Martin Thomas examines story.

effort to roll back Labour's reforms.

Why did the 1945 Labour government do so much more than other Labour governments? Why did it still fail to defeat capitalism?

At the end of World War 2, as at the end of World War 1, workers wanted radical change. Strikes increased. Although Labour refused to contest by-elections, a maverick left-wing movement, Common Wealth, opposed Tories with some success.

For the activists these were heady times. The young Denis Healey, no less, told the May 1945 Labour Party conference that "the crucial principle of our foreign policy should be to protect, assist, encourage and aid in every way [the] Socialist revolution wherever it appears... The upper classes in every ernment. It was very seldom that any

corps of top state officials; closely linked to that "selfish, deprived, dissolute and decadent" upper class. The Labour leaders, 'respectable' and 'practical' people, were much more responsive to those officials than to the Labour rank and file. Even the King's complaints that they were "going too fast in the new nationalising legislation" had weight with them.

The Labour leaders were aghast and astonished at their own success in July

1945. But they had millions of unruly workers behind them, and an economic system in manifest chaos in front of them.

So they pressed ahead. They were amazed at their own daring; but for a while, despite all rhetoric, the Tories and the ruling class gave them leeway.

As the 'Economist' magazine put it in November 1945: "an avowedly Socialist government, with a clear Parliamentary majority, might well have been expected to go several steps further... If there is to be a Labour government, the programme now stated is the least it can do without violating its election pledges controlled industry in Britain, even if it were on the whole desirable"

When the permanent state machine laid down the line, it could control the Labour government. Lord Montgomery, then chief of the armed forces, paid "tribute to the courage of the Labour government in introducing National Service in peace-time in the face of great opposition within its own party. Attlee and Bevin pushed it through for us".

In 1947 the government proposed 18 months' conscription. 72 Labour backbenchers voted against it, and the government agreed to make it 12 months.

Then the top commanders of the army threatened to resign en block if they got any less than 18 months. The government backtracked. 18 months it was.

LABOUR where oil production ing fast.

The Labour government installed 100,000 troops in Palestine — which then had about the same population as Northern Ireland today. When that failed to restore stable British rule, it cut its losses and withdrew to let the Zionists and the Arabs fight it out.

The Labour government tailed behind the US in the Korean war, which started in June 1950. And, closer to home, this would-be radical government did nothing about the Tory-Orange state in Northern Ireland except to bolster its position by legislating the 'Unionist veto' (the Northern Ireland Act 1949, stating that the constitutional position would not be changed except with the approval of a majority in the Six Counties).

And so the broad, strong mass work-

----- pull-quotes -----

THIS IS OUR CHANCE TO... BOU FOR H VOTE LABOUR AND WIN THE PEACE!

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 235

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →