Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Socialist Worker al

Socialist Organiser no. 235, 10 July 1985 · scan p. 6 · about 884 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 6

Since the miners' strike the SWP has made a turn to the Labour Left and proposed a merger with Militant. What's going on? Clive Socialist Worker's current appeal to Militant for a 'united organisation' shows quite clearly a lot of the problems with the SWP's basic politics.

The SWP says that the main problem with Militant is that it's in the Labour Party.

The renewed witch-hunt poses for Socialist Worker the basic problem of the Labour Party very sharply. As last week's Socialist Worker (6 July) put it:

"Socialists in the Labour Party face a clear choice. Either stop rocking the boat, stop taking up 'fringe issues' and drop your principles, or get out"

And Socialist Worker concludes bluntly: "socialists must be prepared to get out and build an independent, fighting socialist party.

For Militant - which the SWP believes has grown because it appeared to offer hard, Marxist politics to the Labour left - that choice is posed particularly starkly. Since the only principled choice to make will result in expulsion, Socialist Worker concludes that Militant must join with them to build "a real and visible revolutionary alternative" (SW, May 11). Bradley reports.

cated about the inevitability of such things. Only now, after five years of major battles by the Labour left, the split that created the SDP, the offensive of the Kinnockites and the development of the witch-hunt, are the SWP taking it seriously.

So what has changed? Why does Socialist Worker appeal to Militant now, while it didn't throughout 1982-3, when the witch-hunt was much more ferocious and hysterical — and the left wing resistance to it broader and bolder?

The simple answer is that the SWP has suddenly panicked at the discover that — as a result of the witch-hunt — Militant is now the bigger of the two groups. Socialist Worker has realised that most good socialists are in or around the Labour Party, and has readjusted its sights.

Apart from that, nothing has changed since 1982-3. So if Socialist Worker is right now, rationally the SWP should have been in the Labour Party in 19823, or even in 1976.

But then how would Socialist Worker deal with Militant's line on Ireland? On the police? On the possibility of a 'peaceful road to socialism'? Either the SWP would forget a lot of their present politics, or they would find themselves in sharp conflict with Militant on every major political question. The common terrain would only highlight the issues of political programme.

Today Socialist Worker can declare with self-conscious naivety: "Of course, in such a united organisation there would be differences of opinion on many matters, but they could be argued out democratically as we fought together against the Tores and the right wing inside the movement" (SW, June 28 1985). But the SWP's insistence that this is a sincere and honest proposal is hard to swallow. It is plainly a catchpenny gimmick to try to recruit a few Militant supporters.

Underlying the whole business is something yet more basic to the SWP's idea of politics, and of Marxist organisation. The SWP has a fundamentally organisational conception of the revolutionary party: it is about linking militants together; and it is defined crucially by its organisational independence. The basic way that they relate to Militant therefore is mainly by conterposing organisational separation from the Labour Party to membership of it, rather than arguing about what socialism is, and about socialist answers to living struggles. This is. in fact, characteristic of the main way the SWP takes on the Labour left as whole.

For revolutionary Marxism — chat is Bolshevism — politics come first. Organisational issues are secondary, and should be decided on the basis of maximum tactical flexibility.

A Marxist organisation is defined above all by its political programme, by independent working class politics, not just by where it chooses to fight for those politics.

For the SWP on the other hand, organisational questions come first and politics second. Organisational separation from the Labour Party is proclaimed as the basic principle, and political issues are subordinated to the task of organising militants"

So for example, in August 1969 the SWP (then IS) dropped the call Troops Out of Ireland for a while after the troops were deployed in the streets. In June 1971 it abandoned its internationalist position on the EEC - that it makes no difference to workers whether they are in a capitalist Britain or a capitalist 'Europe' — for the sake of joining in an anti-EEC campaign to "win support".

And so their arguments about the Labour Party are fundamentally apolitical, concentrating on the need to build an 'independent' party without clear definitions of what distinguishes Marxist politics. The difference between themselves and Labour is defined primarily in terms of orientation: where the SWP focuses on strikes and immediate struggles, Labour focuses exclusively on elections. "The SWP looks after strikes, Labour looks after the rest" Ted Grant of Militant: my tendency is this necessarily counterposed to working class action.

The Bolsheviks made great efforts to get representatives elected to the Duma — the parliament in Tsarist Russia. The Communist International, when it was still revolutionary, took electoral activity very serious - not just to make propaganda, though that was central, but with the intention of winning elections.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 235

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →