[SW argues that the basic problem with Labour…]
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-07-10Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
SW argues that the basic problem with Labour is that its desire to win elections necessarily means abandoning any commitment to socialism in order to 'win the middle ground'. Trying to win elections necessarily cuts across an orientation towards direct action struggles, because the audience for socialist ideas is only ever the "militant minority'. Serious socialists in the Labour Party, therefore, should orient towards this 'militant minority' rather than try to win elections.
"Once it is seen that politics arise from the everyday struggles in the workplaces, that it is here rather than in elections that workers begin to question the prevailing ideas of capitalism, then you can see that the road to socialism is quite different to that taken by the Labour Party." (September 29, 1984).
"Since the left were as committed to electoral politics as the right, they did not know how to argue back when the right said socialist policies had to be jettisoned so as to regain votes." (SW, June 29).
This is a very odd view of the basic problem with reformism - indeed of what reformism is.
The problem with the 'parliamentary road to socialism' is not the wish to win elections. It is the inevitability of violent ruling class resistence if an elected left government seriously tries to fight for its programme. The problem with Allende in Chile is not that he ran for election, but that he did not go on from election victory to move decisively against the old ruling class.
Do left policies lose votes for Labour? Sometimes they do - when the Labour leadership sabotages the election campaign by denouncing the Party's policies, and by engaging in a witch-hunt. If the Labour leaders say Labour's policy is ultra-left lunacy, no wonder voters agree.
The Labour left replies that we need a Labour leadership that will fight for Labour policies. A real campaign by Labour for socialist policies would gain votes. But the SWP accepts the basic terms of reference of the Labour right about how to win elections: that 'winning the middle ground' means "being moderate"