Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

[What's wrong with Labour is not that it…]

Socialist Organiser no. 235, 10 July 1985 · scan pp. 6–7 · about 642 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 6

What's wrong with Labour is not that it tries to win votes. You have to win votes even to go on strike. You would have to win votes indeed - not a Parliamentary election perhaps, but votes all the same, in workers' councils for example — to make a revolution.

And the basic fault of the Labour left is neither a failure to get involved in strikes, nor that it doesn't know how to answer the arguments about winning elections. It answers the vote-catching arguments rather better than the SWP does. Many ordinary Labour Party members do get involved in strikes -many, indeed, run them. The SWP knows about Labour Party members" involvement in the miners' strike. Of course, the Labour Party does function primarily as an electoral machine, and this is a serious problem with it. But electoral activity is not

Scan page 7

id the Labour left Labour Party. And this was to be done on the basis of demands which "are reformist in form but transitional in content." (ibid), The SWP has criticised. this wrong assessment more recently, but failed to draw any conclusions. Despite the SWP's perspective, back in the real world the actual political product of the mass struggles against Heath was the Labour government of 1974-9.

Just before the 1979 election that brought the Tories into office, Paul Foot commented in the Daily Mirror: "For the next three weeks I shall be a very strong Labour supporter'. In practice. the SWP had nothing to say but 'vote Labour because the Tories are worse' • Socialist Organiser on the other hand, organised an alternative clection campaign to 'vote Labour and prepare to fight': we tried to organise the left to fight the Labour leadership even through the course of the election and prepare for battles to come -whether against the Tories or Labour. Where the SWP focussed exclusively on how bad the Tories would be, we focused also on sharp criticisms of all working class solution — automatic wage rises in line with a workers' cost of living index.

Marxists have to carry out a political struggle to convince workers of these solutions. Part of that struggle is demanding of the existing Labour leaders that they support struggles now; fighting them if they don't; and fighting for our overall political solutions throughout the labour movement.

The SWP's one-sidedness leads them to low-level concentration on 'basics' - workplace organisation -at the expense ot giving general political answers. During the miners' strike for example, it led to ultrapessimism, and a failure to argue for the necessary class-wide solidarity action.

Now they conclude that workplace militancy is off the agenda for a period, and that they can do nothing much but fish among the Labour left.

But they prove as unable to assess the Labour left accurately as they were to assess the miners' struggle. collection of money.." (SW, October 20, 1984).

Very good - except that neither Tribune, Militant, Labour Herald nor LCC were visible as organised forces in the miners' support committees.

Most support committee activists were non-aligned Labour Party members. If the SWP had really wanted to address the main organised groups active in the committees, they would have written to Socialist Organiser, Socialist Action and Labour Briefing. They didn't because it would not have suited their purposes of catchpenny opportunism.

The SWP can maintain itself only by denying that it is possible to be in the Labour Party for any period and to remain a serious socialist. But their own current tactic gives them the lie. How come there are any good socialists in the Labour Party for SW to send open letters to? Why have they not had their brains rotted? After all, many of them have been in the Labour Party for Hally come thev mary yearn to Perhaps the are Labour Party doesn't automatically

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 235

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →