[The basic problem with Labour is much deeper…]
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-07-10Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
The basic problem with Labour is much deeper. The Labour Party is controlled by a bureaucratic apparatus closely entwined with the trade union bureaucracy. And the central feature of this overall labour bureaucracy is its accommodation to, and dependence upon, the capitalist state. Labour governments have rested upon the capitalist state; and what has crucially distinguished them from Tory governments is the greater degree of collaboration between the state and the trade union bureaucracy that they have been able to organise. A future Labour government would draw much of its strength, as a government, from its ability to draw the trade union bureaucracy back into 'the corridors of power' from which they have more recently been so unceremoniously booted. It is this relationship between the Labour bureaucracy and the state that makes Labour a reformist party, not the fact that it wants to win elections!
The question for revolutionary socialists, therefore, is this: how can we break the labour movement as a whole from its reliance on the state? Of course, as the SWP argues a focus on direct working class struggles, and a fight to give those struggles direction, is irreplaceable for socialists. Any Marxist organisation worthy of the name sees those struggles as the central arena of its work. But just to build an organisation that promotes those struggles is not an answer to the problem of a labour movement fundamentally compromised with the capitlaist state.
Merely. to put the argument *socialists need a Party quite different to the Labour Party" (SW, September 29) begs the question. We need a