Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

[(photo: John Harris) reality quite different to the…]

Socialist Organiser no. 235, 10 July 1985 · scan p. 7 · about 1,411 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

(photo: John Harris)

reality quite different to the present one. Yet we have to start from present day reality. The Labour Party exists; it is enormously powerful; it structures, shapes and profoundly affects and limits the class struggle; and a real alternative to Labourism cannot be built just by putting out an appeal for it. ideologically sharp enough to fight the pressures to accommodation; to integrate individual activists into that tendency rather than leaving them as individuals.

The SWP's perspective lacks a real strategy for working class power. Essentially, they can provide no link Labour's record in office.

The SWP's apparently very leftwing and revolutionary attitude to elections — that they are a reformist business. to be shunned by true Marxists — ends up being quite right wing in practice.

They abandon whole spheres of polities to the Labour leaders.

Marxists should be interested in elections — not because we think there is a Parliamentary road to socialism. but because elections are a major part of politics for the working class now ur have lots orsmall strikes parare no answer at all to the question in most - dIC HU workers' minds: what can we replace the Tories with?

it to the Editorial Boards of Tribune, Militant, Labour Herald, and to the Labour Coordinating Committee.

They proposed:

: "(i) joint meetings of our editorial boards to discuss what can be done to build solidarity with the miners (such as) spreading the network of miners' support committees...collecting money •preparing for.. solidarity action...

2) Joint meetings of our supporters ...to discuss strengthening miners' support committees...

3) Joint meetings...to LETTER torial board of Malan Comrades, It is not these arguments that are persaisite in themselves, It is the situation in which they are put. Gien the Thatcher the miners* strike has demonstrated government's policies and the defeat of the heyond doubt that the rightward swing of miners (although at immense cost to the the Labour Party is getting stronger bosses" class). a large and increasing Many on the left had thought that Neil number of workers are inclined to vote for Kinnock's disgracgful performance during the Kinnock Labour Party as 'the lesser evil"

the strike would hurt him and strengthen Votes are the main thing for the Labour their position, It hasn't worked out like leaders, and anything that rocks the electoral that prospect-like socialist ideas—is out.

Despite the disgust many mintants What should be the attitude of reroundoubtedly have, the bulk of the Labour Tutionary socialists, of Marxists, towards left has been drawn closer to Kinnock. just these motes? Workers who abstained or 1s Kinhock has moved more and more voted SDP or even Tory in the last clection epenly rightwards. are moving forwards when they consider The rapid collapse of so many Labour voting Labour But this also strengthens left' councils on rate-capping is a striking Kinnock demonstration. Kinnock's 'stay within the The more the polls show Labour leads. law' position is winning hands down. Ken the greater the pull on the Labour left Livingstone's somersault in London set the towards 'unity —a unity on Kinnockpattern. Hattersiey terms The compulsory re-selection process is The obsession with elections, the illusion going strongly in Kinnock's favour too. In that another Labour government will be the 70-odd re-selections to date only one basically different from the Thatcher sitting MP (excluding rebrements) has been Tories in deeds (as opposed to words—the replaced-and that was Reg Freeson, re- rhetoric will certainly be different) all placed by Ken Livingstone. Kinnock was strengthen the right wing. quick to congratulate the ex-'Red Ken".

I would be happy to work with him in parliament. There is no problem there. I think Mr Livingstone has considerably enhanced his reputation in recent months when taking realistic stands on a number of issues..! Labour government. Not because we And, as you will know better than believe it will be a government in the interanyone, there has been a systematic line up ests of workers—it won't—but precisely to of former "lefts' and the right wing to keep test in practice again the reformist road. out candidates associated with Militant. We believe a future Labour government Then there is the increasing isolation of will not act in the interests of the working Tony Benn and Dennis Skinner on the class. On the contrary, it will act like every Labour Party NEC. Former Bennites, like previous Labour government-in the Blunkett, Meacher and Sawyer, are more interests of the bosses' class. and more supporting the Kinnock- And. since the crisis of British capitalism Hattersley line. The vote on opposition to is deeper now than in the seventies, a new NATO--an ABC issue for socialists—is a Labour government will be more vicious. case in point wild more reactionary, than the WilsonIn the 'Campaign group of MPs there is Callaghan governments-the first since a growing trend towards reconciliation 1945 to succeed in cutting wages, while with the rightward moving Tribune increasing unemployment and savaging the group-see the notonous New Year welfare state Tribune editorial. In short, the real left in Se what should revolutionaries do the Labour Party are increasingly out on a now? We all know from experience that limb. previous Labour governments have proOf course, supporters of Militan have duced demoralisation in the working class fought hard against these trends. But with less and less success. Why? The arguments of the rightward shifting ex-lefts are pretty contemptible. They are a rehash of what their predecessors said in 1963-4 (leading tol the election of the 1964-70 Wilson govern pull you to the right? There is no reason at all why a Marxist organisation, with firm principles and clear heads, need be dragged to the right just by being in the Labour Party. It says something about the SWP that they have so little confidence in their own principles that they think (and probably correctly) this would happen to them.

The problem of Militant as it presents itself to the SWP is this: Militant have outdone them at their own game — sect-building. They have done so despite dreadful politics because they have at least taken the Labour Party seriously: they are in the right place. The task for socialists is to have the right politics in the right place. That is what Socialist Organiser tries to do.

as well as enlightenment cored minority.

We have had all manner of differences in the past. and will. no doubt. continuc todo so. But all this pales before the tasks and opportunities we now face and visible revolutionary alternative is available. Is not building such an alternative common ground between us? If it is. then we must get together to work out the best means of developing the revolutionars alternative nota If it is not. the elfect of the mevitable Labour sellouts will be as before. Just as Heath benefitted in 1970, and Tharcher in 1979. in the future it will be whatever night wing bourgeois leader emerges.

The real surge to the left in the Labour Party in 1979-81 is now far behind us. Militant supporters are, to our sorrow, very much on the defensive in the Labour Party.

This is not a matter of, optimism' of "pessimism', but of facing the facts.

The danger that faces Marxists in the Labour Party at the moment is either to mute their criticism of the leadership or face increasing isolation.

The working class has the power to change society. The question is how to build the leadership in the class that can change that potential into a reality. The Labour Party is. and always has been, a conservative workers' party (Lenin called it a bourgeois party. although composed of workers').

We understand the arguments advanced by Militant supporters about the need to work in the Labour Party-although we have disagreed with them. But now. with the Tories on the offensive and the Labour Party galloping to the right, there is a new situation It is a staton not only fraught with danger for workers and socialists, but also ripe with opportunity for building an alternative revolutionary current in the working class. We and yourselves are the two biggest groupings on the left of the labour movement. We believe there is a basis for working together to build a viable socialist alternative. Do you agree?

----- pull-quotes -----

Last October, Socialist Worker put out 'an appeal to the organisations of the Labour left' to 'build united sup- port for the miners. They addressed

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 235

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →