[Constance Lever reviews Abram Leon's classic Marxist attempt…]
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-07-10Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
Constance Lever reviews Abram Leon's classic Marxist attempt to explain the history of the Jewish people, and why for 2000 years without a country of their own they retained a separate identity. The article first appeared in the paper 'Workers' Fight', February 5 1972.
['The Jewish Question', by Abram Leon: Pathfinder Press].
IN 1944 Abram Leon was murdered in the gas chambers of Auschwitz. But unlike most of the millions who died there too, he understood the force that destroyed him, and he had devoted himOrange parade: an assertion of bigotry self, up to his arrest a few months before, to the fight against it.
A leading Belgian Trotskyist, Leon had directed his party' 's socialist propaganda work amongst the working-class conscript soldiers of the occupying German army, helped organise meetings of underground factory committees in the metal plants of Liege, and travelled secretly to occupied France to re-establish the international links of the revolutionary workers' movement.
Paddy Dollard recent events These actions were not only those of a socialist-internationalist, but of a Jew who understood that decaying capitalism had no place for the Jews whom it had evicted from their traditional class posiual greatness lay in their holding together, despite aispersal and persecution, united by a belief in one god and in their national destiny; and the myth that their problem could be solved and their destiny realised by a return to "their' land, of 2000 years ago.
Leon argued that the Jews were a "people-class': a historically and culturally distinct people, bound together by a common class position. They were mainly involved in trade, beginning in the ancient world in which their land straddled the crosspoints of the trade routes between the centres of the ancient civilisations. It was not the Roman soldiers, but their own jobs as traders which scattered them through the ancient world: the mass dispersal of Jews outside Palestine had already become a fact before the final fall of Jerusalem. It was not despite the dispersal but because of it and of the common class position that accompanied it, that they survived as a distinct people.
Class And now, in the modern world, it was not essentially as a national minority, but as an unpopular, increasingly irrelevant and therefore powerless class that they faced anti-semitism. It was, argued Leon, by the destruction of capitalism, not by the establishment of a client state of imperialism - Israel - that the survival and freedom of 18 million Jews around the world could be assured.
Centuries before the Romans destroyed the Temple more than three quarters of the Jews lived outside Palestine, scattered around the ancient world.
With the decline of Roman society, the eclipse of towns and the shrinking of trade and their replacement by a local rural economy producing use-values, ruled by local landowners, the Jews remained as more or less the only traders and, after the coming of Islam, the only links between east and west. On the other hand, in time those Jews not engaged in trade and finance stopped being Jews, assimilated by conversion to Christianity or Islam. The job of trading shaped Judaism and led to its survival. Being born a Jew prepared and destined a child to the commercial class.
Again and again throughout its history, the unity of the Jewish people-class