Jewish Question
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-07-10Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
Theodor Heral. founder of the Zionist morement, with his mother was selectively strengthened by the conversion and assimilation of those of its members who did not carry on the economic jobs of the majority. No trace remains, as distinct groups, of the preIslamic Jewish farmers of North Africa, of the Jewish landed proprietors of 4thcentury Germany, or of the Jewish warrior tribes of Arabia It is probable, ironically, that there are more physical descendants of the Palestine Jews of Bar Kochbar's time in the Arab refugee camps than amongst the "returning' Jews of Israel. alone. As various sources of money developed, this too lost its essential relevance. Hostility to the moneylender, held in check by the need of him, broke bounds when this need disappeared. From the 12th century to the 14th century, Jews were hounded and burned, accused of ritual murder and of poisoning wells.
In 1190, for example, hundreds of Jews besieged in York Castle committed mass suicide rather than surrender to the excesses of the Crusader knights outside. governments. Christian churches, and police forces. Artisans, shopkeepers and many workers remembered how their peasant fathers had hated the Jewish moneylender and landlord's agent. There followed pogroms, persecutions and witch trials on the model of the Middle Ages - as, for example, the Bayliss trial in Russia in 1911.
A second mass migratory wave reversed the movement of the 13th and 14th centuries. By the 1920s millions had left. most to Germany and America. was inflicting on the mass of the people.
Thus it was not capitalism as such which ruined and starved the people — but an undefinable section of it, "Jewish capital' — which also, mysteriously, in its other guise of 'Jewish Bolshevism' was the all-malevolent force behind the workers® parties and the labour unions which were rousing the ire and jealousy of the terrified shopkeepers, yet offered little or nothing to the semi-worker, the lumpen-proletarian.
All ills could be traced to their source in the many-headed, anti-national 'Jewanti-capitalist consciousness of masses into a form that antedates cup talism and which no longer exists excep in a vestigial state In this situation Zionism, beginning as a small movement at the end of the last century, gained mass influence among Jews. It wanted to escape from the redundant people-class position and from crisis-ridden capitalism by a simple physical removal to Palestine. It remained a minority outlook among Jews until the Nazi holocaust.
Its predominance among Jews today is one of the results of that most tragic defeat in the history of the people-class - a defeat it was powerless to prevent, and which could only have been prevented by the revolutionary victory of the international working class. That victory was prevented or betrayed by the Socialist and Stalinist political organisations (and, incidentally, to a minor degree, by the Zionist diversion from the class struggle).