Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

On the Index

Socialist Organiser no. 238, 24 July 1985 · scan pp. 4–5 · about 1,111 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

executed.

RB: Whom was Marx Square named after?

A very old female voice: Well, wasn't he that great German philosopher? No? Marx, Engels Lenin? No? (The radio reporters then went to Engels Square):

RB: Do you know whom Engels Square was named after? Passer-by: After Engels. RB: And who was Engels? A: He was an Englishman and he screwed around with communism.

Turkey remains widespread anc Turkey remains widespread and systematic, according to a nev systematic, according to a new Amnesty International report Amnacts International report. Turkey: Testimony on Torture. The report pointed out tha detailed information on tortur related mostly to politica received over many year strongly suggests that tortur of criminal suspects is als routine in Turkish polic stations.

The Amnesty Report carrie accounts by seven wome and six men who desribe ho they were tortured. Tr The methods included: electr shocks, falaka (beating on tr soles of the feet), burning wi In the most spectacular incident so far of the current rash of witch-hunting against Militant, the Labour Party's Wales Executive Committee has excluded an elected member from its first meeting.

Chris Peace, a Militant supporter who topped the poll in the election for the South Wales cigarettes, hanging from the ceiling for prolonged periods. punching, kicking, beating and assaults with truncheons, sticks and iron rods on all parts of the body, including the sexual organs.

Tens of thousands of people have been detained since the military takeover of Septem ber 1980. Turkish press report: last year suggested that nearly 180,000 people had been held a some stage since then.

Amnesty International ha: testimony frore a lawyer detain ed last March at Istanbul polic headquarters and the Selimiy military prison who was hung ul by his hands, given elec tric shocks and hosed with hig pressure cold water. constituency section of the EC, was evicted from the meeting on the proposal of Ray Powell, MP for Ogmore, and TGWU official George Wright.

Miners' representative Terry Thomas protested, and even the full-time party regional organiser objected.

Powell and Wright demanded that Peace not only stop selling or contributing to Militant, but also stop reading it!

If Wright and Powell get away with this monstrous exclusion, il will make the Labour Party about as democratic as the Catholic Church. Few other organisations in the modern world ban their members from even reading 'dangerous" material.

The Catholic Church has a pope and cardinals to read dubious literature and judge whether their flock can safely b allowed to read it. Who do Wright and Powell propose as the censor to identify what might corrupt the minds of the innocent Labour faithful?

Send letters of protest to Anita Gale, Wales Labour Parl regional organiser, Transport House, 1 Cathedral Road.

Cardiff, with copies to Chris Peace, 21 Manor St, Heath, Cardiff.

The choice is now stark: industrial action to thwart the Government's plans, or the dole queue.

But GLC leader Ken Livingstone isn't letting all that worry him. After all, he's got a new job fixed up, as MP for Brent East.

In a long interview in Tribune of July 19, he says that the fight against abolition is definitely over. Not a word does he say about the workers facing the sack, but he does have a lot of self-congratulation about how good the campaign was. "My personal popularity rating in London was 18 per cent after six months of a Labour GLC... Now it is up to 61"

And how was it done? Tell us Ken, what is the secret of the new, realigned, participatory left politics?

"İt is a question of imagination and style.. , says Livingstone: ". ... the cynical soft-sell approach that we have adopted with a lot of our campaigning"

The brand-new 'participatory left' sounds rather like run-ofthe-mill US showbiz politics. And in concluding perhaps Ken does have a word for those GLC workers: don't be so 'oppositional' *I think we have it in our hands to take power in Britain for a generation if we can grow out of the oppositional state of mind which the isolation of the British Left has inevitably created over the last 50 years the labour movement that they couldn't handle. Intimidated by the right's threat of a split, the official left ran away in confusion.

The Gaitskellites had the interests of the ruling class and its state system to relate to and preserve. They knew where they stood and were in no doubt where the base line was beyond which they could not move without betraying their own cause.

By contrast the official left was utterly confused, only half-understanding the meaning and implications of the policy they had won the Labour Party to at Scarborough. When the right wing brutally spelled it out for them and told them it wasn't on, they crumbled. Against the hard bourgeois right wing - the future SDP - the left had no serious programme.

The programme of class struggle and working-class socialism was not adhered to by the mainstream unilateralists, who were at best utopians and frequently conscious left-fakers like Crossman.

Hence it was more than a question of the personal character of the lefts. Foot's record before 1960 was not contemptible. It was fundamentally a question of their left reformist politics and their characteristic failure to think things through to the end and to draw the necession". In fact it became a symbol for the inconsequentiality of the Labour left and of its dismal incapacity to do other than make oppositionist' noises.

As early as December 1960 Tribune had tried to give Gaitskell lessons in how to fake if he wanted to lead them gently by the nose. He didn't. He wanted to smash and humiliate them. But soon enough they got Wilson as leader, and he didn't need any lessons on the arts of faking and bamboozle.

Gaitskell followed up his victory at Blackpool in October 1961 with an anti-EEC campaign that largely disarmed the left. Wilson, succeeding Gaitskell at the beginning of 1963, proceeded to disarm them completely. A former 'career leftist', he knew how to throw them inconsequential sops.

The Labour left counted for nothing throughout the 1960s, and until well into the seventies.

No defeat is so demoralising as a craven capitulation without struggle. The tendency that suffers it must inevitably have its belief in itself sapped and undermined.

The Bevanite/Tribune left never recovered. It was a new left that grew in the 70s.

Next issue: part 2 - the reac tions of the Marxist left

Scan page 5

Organiser 238

----- pull-quotes -----

Turkey Torture of political detainees in Torture of political detainees ir

prisoners in incommunicad detention. But informatio

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 238

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →