Labour, TUC: isolate the scabs!
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-07-24Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
Channel Four TV last week showed a bare 50% of Notts miners supporting the decision by their area general secretary Roy Lynk to split from the NUM.
46 per cent disapproved. When the question was put differently, only 40% said that they wished to have a separate Notts union, and 56% would prefer to be in the NUM.
A strong campaign by the NUM could possibly deny Lynk a majority in the ballot on the breakaway which he will probably call in the second week of September. Many Notts miners who scabbed in the 1984-5 strike - because of the pressures on them and the weakness or sabotage of the area leaders - still don't want a breakaway.
But the NUM has a difficult job on its hands. Lynk has powerful forces on his side which give him a good chance of success in the ballot.
As John Lloyd reported in the Financial Times, "Mr lan MacGregor, the Coal Board's chairman, has been in constant touch with the working miners groups in Nottinghamshire and elsewhere; at the end of last month, he held talks in Doncaster with the leaders of the breakaway faction in Durham.
"He is an enthusiast for the split."
The NCB offered recognition to Lynk as soon as he said he was splitting from the NUM, and is willing to pay high bonus money in Notts in order to solidate a scab union.
Lynk has support from the whole ruling class, the government, and the media.
On July 15 the South Derbyshire NUM executive voted to "explore the possibility" of joining with Lynk. Jack Jones, secretary of Leicestershire -which also scabbed almost solidly during the strike — says that his area will do the same.
Federation
These moves have enabled Lynk to run his ballot on the breakaway in the form of a vote on federating with the small scab areas - which needs only a 50% majority, rather than the two-thirds required for a straight breakaway decision. Even if the NUM fails to deny Lynk his 50%, it will obviously be a blow to him if his majority is kept below two-thirds.
Notts had a breakaway bosses' union before, led by George Spencer, between 1926 and 1937. In the end Spencer failed. The breakaway was reunited with the official North Notts Miners' Association. But that was only after 11 grim years.
in those years the Spencer union was the only recognised union in Notts. Supporters of the genuine union, the Notts Miners" Association, were hounded and victimised. There was mass non-unionism. away recruited only small minorities outside Notts. But it was a major struggle to contain those small minorities and stop them spreading. In South Wales, for example the breakaway recruited no. more than 5% of miners even at its strongest. But the struggle against it dominated the coalfield. Some pits staged stay-down strikes as the only way to oust scab unionism.
The Spencer union was defeated. After a big strike at Harworth, in North Notts, and a massive national vote for strike action in solidarity, the Spencer union was merged with the Notts Miners' Association. But even then only 350 of the 1000 strikers at Harworth got their jobs back after the strike, and Spencer became the president of the merged union.
How does 1984-5 compare with 1926-7? Then as now the miners had just been defeated in an epic strike. Then as now the labour movement generally was depressed, on the defensive, emphasising class collaborationism ('Mondism' then, 'new realism' now).
The accumulated defeats then were worse than now: even before 1926 trade union membership had fallen much more drastically than it had in recent years. It was easier then for the bosses to create regional breakaways in the coal industry: instead of one national employer were hundreds of private coalowners and area miners' unions only loosely linked in the Miners' Federation of Great Britain.
Bad though the current victimisations of miners are, the purge of militants from the pits after 1926 was much more sweeping.
But Lynk has some advantages that Spencer did not have. Lynk has been organising for this breakaway since the beginning of the 1984 strike. In 1926 Notts started out 100% on strike, and Spencer himself called on waverers to strike. As a result Lynk has much more solid rank-and-file support than Spencer had. In 1928 a TUCorganised ballot in Notts showed 32,000 for the Notts Miners' Association against two and a half thousand for the Spencer union.
Merger
Lynk says that he has not ruled out" merger with other unions outside the coal industry. The Notts area NUM is a member of Mainstream, a rightwing group also including the AUEW and the EETPU. Spencer also had support from other right wing unions — in his case. the National Union of Seamen, then virtually a junior partner of the shipowners.
But Lynk is given options that Spencer did not have by the rise of the SDP. A full political split ment, and the creation of an alternative SDP-oriented TUC, is still some way off, but it is not inconceivable.
What happened after 1926 depended not only on the general social circumstances, but also, to. a. large extent, on what the Left and the militants, did. The same principle holds today. • It is easier to be wise after the event than to see clearly in the maelstrom, but the sober fact is that the NUM leaders have se far not dealt very well with the Notts breakaway drive. A case could be madé either for brisk and sharp action against the scab leaders, or for a policy of minimum action and attempted conciliation. The NUM has had the worst of both worlds.
The NUM leaders have made threatening gestures, which alarmed the Notts scabs and rallied them round Lynk, and then retreated. They could have postponed any rule changes or they could have proposed rule changes which radically extended NUM democracy and thus undercut Lynk's hypocritical propaganda. In fact they. introduced rule changes, many of which could plausibly be presented as strengthening bureaucratic control.
The NUM leaders have now started to campaign. They got to a court order forcing Lynk to hold a ballot — a justifiable move, since the principle forbidding the use of the capitalist the labour movement cannot apply to attempts to form a bosses' 'union' outside the labour movement:
Now Arthur Scargill is meeting, regularly with Notts proNUM miners to coordinate a campaign at rank and file level.
A lot still needs to be done. When the South Wales Miners' Federation was campaigning against Spencerism, it sent three officials to work fulltime round a single pit, Bedwas. The same scale of effort is needed now. Miners' support committees should offer their assistance to the NUM.
Activists everywhere in the labour movement should also campaign for a prompt and clear declaration by the TUC and the Labour Party that they will not recognise Lynk's organisation. TUC leaders are talking about "mediation' and Neil Kinnock, on TV on July 16, refused to commit himself.
Such weasling strengthens Lynk; and it also means that TUC and Labour Party leaders will be using the whole affair to put pressure on the NUM. After 1926 the TUC did not recognise Spencer; but 'in return' it got A.J. Cook, the left-wing leader of the Miners' Federation, not to oppose: Mondism', Every trade union and Labour Party branch should send in resolutions calling for immediate and clear declarations o non-recognition.