Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

'Left realignment

Socialist Organiser no. 238, 24 July 1985 · scan p. 6 · about 946 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 6

Six years ago the Labour left said 'never again' - never again a Labour government like Wilson's and Callaghan's, ruled by the bankers and the bosses! We set out to change the party so that future Labour governments would be held accountable to the labour movement.

Now large chunks of the left seem ready to revise their horizons - to hope for nothing better than a new Wilson-type government under the new Harold Wilson, Neil Kinnock. Left-wing Labour councillors who came to office three or four years ago promising new politics and mobilisation against the Tories are now content if they can run slick advertising campaigns, empty dustbins efficiently, and win votes. The lessons of a previous collapse by the Labour left - in 1960-1 - are important if we are to avoid or minimise the collapse now. John O Mahony tells AT ITS Scarborough conference in 1960, the Labour Party voted in favour of unilateral nuclear disarmament by Britain.

This decision had tremendous implications for British politics, for it opened a fundamental breach in Labour-Tory foreign and 'defence' policy bipartisanship, one of the pillars on which class collaboration rests and on which depends the possibility of orderly changes in party government at Westminster.

British unilateral nuclear disarmament impled the disruption of NATO and probably British withdrawal from the western military alliances, all of which relied on nuclear weapons. In 1960 Britain still had an empire of sorts, claimed a 'special relationship' with the USA, and in general still had some weight in the affairs of the world.

the story.

demoralisation and ineptness which the Tribune left displayed in the '60s and "70s can be traced to the events of 1960-61.

So can the lurch by the Marxist left away from work in the Labour Party and into "build-an-independent-revolutionary-party' sectarianism. As a result of their bitter disappointment with the outcme of the 1960-1 struggle between left and right in the Labour Party, the major Trotskyist organisation of that time - the Socialist Labour League - turned away from the Labour Party, pioneering the sort of politics today expressed by the Socialist Workers' Party.

In the second part of this article we will examine the response of the Marxists in detail.

In the late "50s a great wave of alarm at the prospect of nuclear war ran through Britain and many other coun tries. People had not got used to living in a long-term nuclear stalemate, and the idea that it could continue for two or more decades would have been considered improbable.

The eruption of the cold war into nuclear holocaust seemed an imminent threat in every conflict involving the the nation USA and the USSR, Of 443 resolutions at the 1957 Labour Party conference, no less than 127 were concerned with nuclear weapons or general disarmament. A resolution from Norwood Labour Party, inspired by Trotskyists, advocating unilateral nuclear disarmament, was defeated at the 1957 conference - but only after Aneurin Bevan, the personality around whom the Labour Left had crystallised since 195, had marked his reconcilation with the right wing with a notorious speech explaining that he, as a future British Foreign Secretary. could not "go naked into the conference chamber" denuded of British nuclear weapons.

But Bevan failed to carry the Tribune left with him. Even Jennie Lee, his close political associate and wife, explained in Tribune that she had abstained on the to accept in our movement communists, Trotskyists, and fellow-travellers"

And the demand that unilateralists draw the logical conclusions from unilateralism: he asked them if they actually wanted to leave NATO. Did they understand the implications of what they were saying?

In fact, all the leading Labour Party proponents of unilateralism wanted to stay in NATO!

The political level of the unilateralists tended to be pacifistic and utopian. Generally they did not grasp how fundamental a challenge to the ruling class their proposal and its ramifications were From opposite standpoints both the right and the Marxists in the Labour Party pointed out to them what those implications were. Labour's right wing understood what was at stake. They mobilised for a fight to the finish.

Under Hugh Gaitskell, the Labour Party was then led by a hard right-wing sect grounFoot lept 166 votes to 81 (for Harold Wilson) and seven abstentions.

The majority of the Parliamentary Labour Party would pursue Gaitskell's policy, not that of the Party.

But what would the left MPs do? Would they too mobilise and organise and beiphoto: Chris Davies, Report). implications not only for British politics but for the Labour Party too. Victory at Scarborough brought the left smack up against the unyield. ing Gaitskellites, fighting to save the Labour Party for class collaboration, entrenched in the Parliamentary Labour Party, using the Party machine against Conference decisions, and quite prepared to split the Party in order to "save it"

Before the Scarborough conference, Anthony Crosland, one of Gaitskell's lieutenants, had written in the 'New Leader' (an American publication associated with the Congress for Cultural Freedom, which was financed by the CIA) that a conference defeat for the right wing: might be to their advantage. It could give the Parliamentary Labour Party the chance to dramatically assert its independence by defying Party conference, and thus the balance of power in the Party would be shifted in favour of After Scarborough the Gaitskellites carried out thiE policy. "They hi-jacked the machinery of the party, and their mixture of intransigence and aggressive action paralys ed the Labour left.

The NEC decided to back Gaitskell and the PLP agains Party conference. (Ton Benn MP. who was not then so far as I know, a unilatera

----- pull-quotes -----

the PLP. Hi-jack

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 238

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →