Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

[Before the vote at Scarborough, Hugh Gaitskell boldly…]

Socialist Organiser no. 238, 24 July 1985 · scan pp. 6–7 · about 667 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 6

Before the vote at Scarborough, Hugh Gaitskell boldly told the delegates what the right would do if they lost. The Parliamentary Labour Party would, he said, not be bound by a decision it did not agree with.

The MPs supported the asked, "do you expect them NEC policy. "So what" to do? Go back on the pledges they gave to the people who elected them from their constituencies?..Do you think that we can become overnight the pacifists, unilateralists and fellow-travellers that other people are?"

Even if they lost the vote, they would "fight, fight and fight again to save the Party we love"

He told conference in the same speech that the leadership of the Labour Part The place to decide the leadership is not here but in the Parliamentary Party"

On November 3, the majority of the Parliamentary Labour Party endorsed Gaitskell's revolt against Labour Party conference when it reelected him as Party leader by have like people engaged in a serious political struggle? That was the key question.

Immediately the right began to organise its supporters. The Campaign for Democratic Socialism was set up as a semi-secret right-wing combat organisation which sent circulars marked 'Private and Confidential' to key activists, coordinating their fight -LO reverse the Scarborough decision. Its secretary was William Rodgers, later an MP and a founder of the SDP:

Gaitskell's campaign benefited from the unanimous backing of the bourgeois press. It was adequately supplied with funds whose origins were, understandably, the subject of many rumours.

The Labour Party machine swung squarely behind GaitSkell and against the party ings for Calkel and his sepings for Gaitskell and his supporters. Polite left-wing 'requests that these meetings should also feature supporters of official Labour Party policy were turned down.

Naturally some of these meetings became rowdy and were accompanied by demonstrations against Gaitskell.

Thus unilateralism was shown to have wide and deep

Scan page 7

the last time round appointed one Roy Shaw te review its membership book to see if any known Trotsky. ists had joined.

By contrast with the right, the official left dawdled and looked for a way to avoid a full-scale clash.

To consolidate its Scarborough victory the left needed to face up to the implications of unilateralism, and to Tribune, the organ of the 'official left' , at that time still had some serious influence on the rank and file. The organisdiscussion by Tribune. The executive of Victory for Socjalism rejected out of hand a proposal by Hugh Jenkins that they should advocate the selection of new candidates where Labour MPs refused to abide by conference decisions. (So Jenkins told a VFS meeting in 1961, as reported in The Newsletter on June 3 1961).

Rejecting such action, Tribune had nothing else to do but surrender to the unyielding PLP.

Tribune's leaders thought approving in principle the government's plan accepting Polaris... " If only Gaitskell had been Wilson!

In the following weeks Tribune and the left leaders like Foot shifted their ground decisively. While they remained nominally unilateralist. their specific focus became a eriticism of NATO (within which they wished Britain to remain) for being too reliant on nuclear weapons.

Their 'proposal' changed to the demand for a British declaration never to use nucTory government's mates.

Konni Zilliacus, a prominent left-winger, was suspended from the Labour Party for publishing an article in an international Stalinist magazine. In these ways the Gaitskellites gave notice of their willingness to split the party if they didn't get their way. They kept up the pressure on Foot and company to 'compromise away their victory at Scarborough. ce policy | which npels NATO forces to rely these weapons in the field".

Tribune jumped at the chance to advocate the 'Crossman compromise'. Thus it undercut and in effect abandoned the official Labour Party unilateralist position. Foot wrote that it would be a major step forward if the Crossman document (or a less cynical variant on similar lines worked out by Frank Cousins) could "secure the general backing of

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 238

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →