Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

How the lads misspend their youth

Socialist Organiser no. 238, 24 July 1985 · scan p. 8 · Bruce Robinson · about 1,202 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

IT always puzzled me why proficiency at snooker was proverbially the sign of misspent youth, since it was practised in Temperance Halls and the slate bed held infinitely greater attraction than any other. Us girls never got within ogling distance of the tables. It took them a long time to cotton on that for the majority snooker was perforce a spectator sport and therefore eminently televisual.

I deplore the introduction of coke and edited highlights into the game, as wholly unethical and contrary to the spirit of snooker. Its essence is in the ennui, the slow unrolling drama — not frenetic potting by callow millionaires off their tiny boxes. It's not the Stock Exchange! And besides, one ball rolling down a hole looks much like another.

It is preeminently a game for adolescents pretending manhood and grown men clinging to their adolescence and beer guts. Which makes it the ideal vehicle for the saga of Bad Boys versus the rest of the world. The Boys face tough opposition from the Girls (who want to tie them down with rent, mortgages, babies, responsibility, i.e. make them act like grown-ups) and the Men (who are real villains and will batter them shitless given half the chance). Their only weapons in this unequal struggle are their arcane skills and lumpen audacity. The penalties for losing are harsh — marriage, broken bones and being ripped off.

But they have each other. While soppy girls slurp up slushy romance, the Boys have an altogether more sizzling relationship. Sparks fly, sex is sublimated into sparring - both verbal and physical — but at the end of the day the True Love of Pals Conquers All.

Self-parody

This motif worked very well in "Minder' but it always teetered on the edge of self-parody, threatening to degenerate into bald comedy or mere macho Goodies versus Baddies. And the relationship was a little too unequal. I know Terry was a boxer and therefore braindamaged, but did he have to be quite such a soft touch for exploitation? His dimness got to be so predictable that it drew the string from Arfur's witiness.

It got so you just felt sorry for the poor sod, instead of wondering at the wicked ways of the "Give Us a Break", the tale of Mo the innocent snooker-whizz and Mickie his manager, has the edge because Mo isn't daft, despite the bobble hat. He's a quick learner and soon initiated into aforementioned wicked ways.

They inhabit a curious halfworld with its own magic money and secret language. For the girls, money is earned by honest back-breaking toil in demeaning jobs and spent on the dull necessities of life: for the men, it is acquired through bank jobs where real bodies get broken, and spent on flashy cars and those big signet rings that are the hallmark of the criminal classes. The boys ponce the girls' hard-earned bread. It then undergoes a miraculous inflation via various scams (quasi-criminal enterprises where no-one actually gets hurt) whence it also evaporates just as quickly. You can see why the rest of the world doesn't love them. Idle, irresponsible, amoral and charming - which we would all dearly love to be. So every Friday night we vicariously don their predidament.

"Leave it out" — they appropriate the Men's language -like dressing up in the grown- ups clothes - and of course must be punished for their presumption. But only mildly -just a slap not a good hiding. After all, it's harmless: they're only trying to create a bit of individual space in a hard world. There's only two of them. They won't change the world.

Contrasts

Times and mores do change even in TV-land. If you compare "Give Us a Break" with "Budgie" made in the early *70s, treating similar themes, there are some striking contrasts in the way of racism and sexism. Adam Faith as Budgie could get away with the most extraordinarily racist tirades. It's not that present-day naughty heroes aren't portrayed as racist (Mickey refers to blacks as "Lucozades" - spades, ha! ha!) but now the scriptwriters would feel compelled to distance themselves from the character and counterpoint the expressed racism of the character with something in the story which puts an opposing point of view. There's an episode of Minder where Arfur rants on about "'Gypos" but is forced to concede by the logic of the story that his views are purely prejudice and not based on anytning in the Gypsies' behaviour. In Budgie, the illegal immigrants conform totally to the stereotypes.

Similarly, with the treatment of women. In Budgie the prostitutes could have been taken straight off a dirty postcard and the mother of his illegitimate child is presented as naive, adoring and totally characterless. Their predicaments are merely fuel for a few cheap laughs. Now, even though women are still marginal, there is some suggestion that they have an existence and personality independent of the lads.

I suppose it's progress of a sort. Not that it's anything to crow about. Still, they'll grow up. But not too soon. John O'Mahony refers sarcastically to our old position having an "alleged ability to do justice to everyone concerned", contrasting it to his approach, which starts from the real divisions that exist. Our approach, however, should be precisely that of what Lenin described as "consistent democracy"

Our job is not that of acting as diplomatic advisors to the Palestinians or arguing about which policy is most likely be acceptable to the Israeli working class at present given their present consciousness and attitude to the Palestinians. We are only interested in the national question from the viewpoint of finding a programme that represents a real solution to the national oppression and thus removes it as an obstacle to class unity.

Lenin poured scorn on Rosa Luxemburg (who was opposed to Polish independence from Russia because. as a Polish socialist she was frightened it would strengthen Polish nationalism) for emphasising that what was required was a "practical" solution to the national question.

*The whole task of the proletariat in the national question is 'unpractical' from the standpoint of the nationalist bourgeoisie of every nation, because proletarians, opposed as they are to nationalism of every kind, demand 'abstract' equality: they demand, as a matter of principle, that there should be no privileges, however slight. Failing to grasp this, Rosa Luxemburg, by her misguided eulogy of practicality, has opened the door wide for the opportunists, and especially for opportunist concessions to Great Russian nationalism"

John O'Mahony's position is similar to Rosa Luxemburg's, in that out of fears about the effects of the nationalism of the oppressed - the Palestinians -on the rights of the Israeli Jews. he looks for a 'practical' solution which avoids challenging the privileges of the oppressor nation. It is an attempt to find a short cut to a solution without any fundamental changes in the relationships between the Palestinians and the Israelis.

His position amounts to saying that a solution will be achieved on the basis of the Palestinians giving up their unrealistic demands, so as to avoid having to face the thorny problem of how it is possible to break the Israeli workers from

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 238

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →