Will 'two states' divide?
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-07-24Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
ORGANISED! I am particularly interested in the Palestine debate which I think is fascinating and on precisely the right terrain. I have been entirely supportive of the efforts of John O'Mahony and others to break from the common left position with its blanket endorsement of third world nationalism and its hints/ strains of anti-semitism. I am less enthusiastic about the proposed two-state solution, but 1 withold judgement. One aspect which disturbs me is what it entails for those consigned to live within the Israeli state. I think that we should recognise that Israel is not racist in an ordinary way. The idea of a Jewish state is not an ordinary nationalism. There has never been an adequate separation of church and state, for all the secularism of the Zionist movements, and this lack of separation has become much more pronounced. The exclusion of non-Jews from full citizenship rights is not an ordinary racism.
Obviously we oppose these things whether there is one state or two, but it seems to me that the latter option does not help. We have to consider in my opinion what a Jewish state means not in abstract but as a present reality.
It is racist in an extraordinary way and undemocratic in an extraordinary way. Surely there is a potential among Jews fed up with the influence of religious orthodoxy, with militarism, with Jewish particularism, with siege mentality, etc., to tie their dissent to the dissent of Palestinians and othgrs who bear the brunt of state and para-state repression?
Does not advocacy of two states cut across this unifying potential? Does it not, from the Jewish point of view, assume a static fixation with a Jewish state that for many is becoming more of a weight than a means of emancipation?
Are we not underestimating the effects of the gulf between the idea of Zionism and the reality of today's Israel on the consciousness of ordinary Israelis?
My own knowledge and experience of Israel - where most of my family lives — is well out of date now. I have not visited for many years and I have not studied developments in any detail beyond the Guardian and the Jewish Chronicle. But my strong impression - from friends, family and even the Jewish Chronicle — is that we would be foolish to underestimate the growing disillusion with the particularism represented by Israel.
FINE Get Send 214:
N12 contribution from supporters. I want to become a Socialist Organiser supporter/l want mi information.
Name.
Address Send to: Socialist Organiser, nise 214 Sickert Court, London don
Scan page 10
IF Michael Crick's book "Militant" is meant to be a serious political analysis of the Labour Party tendency of the same name, then Private Eye' must be rated among the world's leading magazines of political theory — though peppered with ail kinds of spicy anecdotes, the book is lacking in amy substantial political content.
The reader discovers, for example that "the eccentric Ted Grant" the leading figure in Militant, is "obsessed with keeping fit and healthy, cating health foods and doing exercises every morning" that he likes table tennis.
Beethoven and Bach, that "once during a television interview, he took his handkerchief out and energetically wiped his nose" , and that 'his only known vices are jelly babies and gobstoppers.
Peter Taaffe, on the other hand, nominally the editor of Militant, is apparently not an eccentric. He "mixes well. He gets on with working people and understands them; he will have a drink with the lads, talk about television or football and his favourite team, Everton.
But Taaffe has his vices too. He frequently plays football with the staff at Militant's London offices. But this is a hierarchical tendency: Taaffe, savs Crick, is "always allowed to pick the best side". . However when Taaffe plays Grant at table tennis, Taaffe always loses, *much to his annoyance But is it real or feigned annoyance? Does Taaffe really lose to Grant, 30 years his senior, or does he "throw" the game in deference to the same principies which secure for himself the right to pick the best Football team? These and other fascinating questions are only hinted at. It is not known how - or if - Taaffe wipes his nose, on television or otherwise.
And it is not merely about current Militant supporters themselves that Crick serves up his gossiping anecdotes.
Did you know that the current Labour MP for Ealing Southall, Syd Bidwell, chaired a meeting of Grant's organisation in 1941? That the present Labour Party Information Officer Frank Ward was a member of Grant's organisation in the 1940s? Or that Grant unsuccessfully attempted to recruit Frank Chapple after the latter left the Communist Party in 1956, (though Chapple did write a number of articles for Grant's publications of that time)?
frey is traped ly are not. Rot atal subsitute serious they interspersed integrated analysis of Militant's politics — they are strewn across a history of Militant as an organised tendency, and strewn across what is in the final analysis an attack on Militant supporters for having organised themselves into a tendency to fight for their ideas.
The opening chapters of Crick's book are fairly accurate on the outlines of post-war Trotskyism in this country. Crick traces the origins of Militant back to the Workers International League. In the 1930s the Militant Labour League was recognised as the British section of Trotsky's Fourth International in opposition to the WIL, but the two groups fused in 1944 to form the Revolutionary Communist Party.
Grant and his followers had left the Labour Party in 1941 and remained hostile to rejoining it: "Under the given conditions, the best tactic for the convinced us that in the present situation entry (into the Labour Party) would constitute a superior tactic," wrote Grant in 1949. But the RCP declined, and finally was disbanded in 1950. The Grantites followed the bulk of the RCP's ex-members into the Labour Party.
Clashes Despite the clashes between the Left and the Party ledership in the '50s and "60s, "Grant and his colleagues survived this period virtually unscathed" , writes Crick, attributing this to the fact that "for a long period they were by far the least significant of the three factions."
*By 1963, after 13 years of little success, Grant had done far worse than either of his rivals from RCP days. Gerry Healy and Tony Cliff, who both had strong groups if only within the youth section of the Labour Party (forerunners of today's WRP and SWP). The Grant group was still small. Its magazines were irregular and badly produced."
The following year the Militant newspaper was launched. Initially it was something in the nature of a broad paper, with non-Grantites both writing for it and helping produce it. But in Stan Crooke less than a year they had lost the fight to maintain the paper's openness — the Militant had become the exclusive property of the Grantites and has remained so ever since.
In the mid and late '60s, the Grantites faction competitors in the the Labour Party and the LPYS (the present WRP and SWP) pulled out of the Labour Party or drifted out of it. Though still small, the Militant group thereby found itself the only organised force in a stagnating LPYS.
Majority In 1963, 365 delegates attended the LPYS national conference; in 1967 216; in 1969 150; and in 1970 when Militant won a majority on the LPYS National Committee for the first time, there were just 126 delegates.
As class struggles mushroomed under the Heath government in the early "70s, "Militant's style of politics -concentrating on industrial and economic issues - began to have more appeal," writes Crick. By 1974, the size of the tendency had increased five-fold. After this initial "take-off Militant has continued to grow in size and influence ever since.
Potted
But wnat Crick's potted history of the Militant in the '50s and '60s fails to do is to explain Militant's politics, explain why it failed to grow, unlike the Healyites, and explain why Militant avoided any conflict with the Labour Party bureaucracy.
Militant failed to grow because of its own political perspectives. Certainly, as Crick points out, "after the war Ted Grant faithfully carried on believing that capitalism's collapse was near, even during the post-war boom". One of Grant's fellow-members of the RCP is quoted as saying: "Ted's always been the same. Since 1945 he has been predicting a slump," and reference is made by Crick to articles written by Grant in these years in which he talks of "the upheavals and convulsions of tomorrow" (February 1952)
But the point was that the "upheavais and convulsions" in which "the British masses will find the way to a Marxist policy" were always scheduled for "tomorrow" . In the meantime, there was nothing for the Grantites to do — they had arrived before their time and had to wait for the inevitable next step of the historical process.
Such a perspective ruled out any serious attempt on their part to build themselves into a combat tendency, as the Healyates, for all their political faults, were doing. And it is also this factor, not their numerical insignificance, which explains why they were "virtually unscathed" by the political conflicts of the period. reviews Michael Crick's book "Militant".
If the "British masses" were going to find their own road to *a Marxist policy" in the "upheavals and convulsions of tomorrow" . then the tasks of Marxists today was reduced to being the guardians of the Marxist programme, integrating themselves into the labour movement and its routinism, and waiting for "tomorrow".
And this is what the Grantites did. Hence the decision of Grant himself to abstain in a vote in his Labour Party on the expulsion of two Healyites.
Hence the decision of Sinna Mani, the first business manager of Militant newspaper to move the expulsion of three Healyites from his LPYS branch in 1965.
But Crick fails to relate the Grantites' lack of growth in the "50s and '60s or incidents such as Grant's abstention on the expulsion of the Healyites, to their Instead, he attributes the Grantites' failure to defend the Healyites from the witch-hunters to the bitterness of the relationships between the two groups. This was, undoubtedly, a factor. The Grantites' politics led to political accommodation with the Labour bureaucracy which manifested itself in their failure to fight the witch-hunt of the Healyites.
Crick's book is not a political work but a piece of bourgeois sociology. As the Italian revolutionary Antonio Gramsci once wrote: "Bourgeois sociology describes: but it explains nothing. It could serve as a verdict, 60 years ahead of its time, on Crick's book - it describes the history and organisation of Militant, often in great detail, but fails to probe below the surface to offer a political explanation of Militant's existence.
Balance?
In his preface Crick declares that the book "is not intended to be a hatchet job" . If the book is Crick's idea of a balanced approach, then I would not like to see him trying to ride a bike.
Just 15 out of the book's 200 pages are about Militant's politics. Crick merely picks out certain aspects of Militant's politics in order to dismiss them from a "common sense" point of view.
For example, Militant refused to call for the withdrawal of the Red Army from Afghanistan on the basis that it would mean a return to feudalism and the restoration of American influence.
Crick wrongly claims that "Militant has been fiercely criticised by other Trotskyist groups for its attitude to the Soviet occupation of Afghanistan" (in fact most other would-be Trotskyist groups shared Militant's position) and, more importantly, he fails to draw out the implications of Militant's position on Afghanistan for its overall concept of socialism.
Militant's line on the Falklands was, as Crick says, "very unusual". It called for a general election in Britain and a socialist federation of Britain, Argentina and the Falklands. Crick does not even attempt to explain the logic which led Militant to this position.
And Militant, writes Crick, 'has taken an odd position on many of the other major issues for the new left", citing its line on Ireland and the Middle East as examples. But, again, he fails to relate this back to Militant's overall view of politics — a view of History as a sort of automatic machine, producing class unity and socialism as the inevitable outcome.
Attitudes
Crick also mentions Militant's attitude to feminism, sexuality and soft drugs: the feminist movement is "petty-bourgeois dominated" and subject to "hysteria" , homosexuality is a "problem" which will disappear under socialism, and smoking dope is a "petty bourgeois deviation" which "numbs the consciousness" of the working class.
Instead of reasoned discussion, Crick responds with further anecdotes: that Militant supporters "were seen eagerly quizzing" some East Europeans at a British Youth Council meeting about their country's electric shock treatment for gays, or that three Militant supporters in Edinburgh were once thrown out of the tendency for smoking cannabis.
The nearest Crick gets to any rounded analysis of Militant's politics is his treatment of Militant's basic economic demands. But here he goes seriously wrong. "Militant's programme is simply a list of modern day 'transitional demands' ...Peter Taffe's 1981 pamphlet (Militant: What We Stand For) can be seen as a new version of Trotsky's Transitional Programme," he writes, just after quoting Trotsky's own definition of transitional demands as ones "stemming from today's consciousness of wide layers of the working class and unalterably leading to one final conclusion: the conquest of power by the proletariat"
But Militant's demands are not "transitional" in any meaningful sense of the word. Usually they are abstract demands, counterposed to the logic of the class struggle, or at least irrelevant in terms of "unalterably leading to one final conclusion" • In other cases, they are an accommodation to reformism.
Militant's well-known demand for the nationalisation of the top 200 monopolies is an example of the former; its demand for workers' management of nationalised industry on the basis of one-third for trade unionists, one-third for the TUC and one-third for the government, of the latter.
Crick, however, misrepresents Militant's demands by claiming that they are all part of an elaborate conspiracy: their demands are described as "a reasonable bait to make Militant attractive to workers or left-wing trade unionists" but once the new 'contact member' has been drawn into the tendency, all will be revealed to him or her.
So what does Militant really stand for? It seems that no-one knows! Little of Militant's revolutionary plan is stated explicitly by the tendency, even in its secret internal documents, but it is exactly in line with the teachings of Marx, Engels, Lenin and Trotsky, writes Crick.
But if nobody, not even Militant's own supporters, know Militant's 'real" politics, then there is no point in discussing with Militant supporters. And that is exactly the conclusion which Crick wants his readers to draw: "Militant's public programme disguises the tendency's fundamental beliets. People on the lett frequently assert that Militant should be countered by political argument, but it is not as simple as that." Any attempt to argue with Militant's "public programme" is therefore "a fairly pointless exercise.
Hence it is that Crick takes Tory Benn to task for his defence of Militant: *Tony Benn has defended Militant by arguing that Marxism has always been a legitimate strand of thought within the Labour Party. He misses the point. Militant is not just Marxist, but also Leninist and Trotskyist".
Now, if those opposed to Militant's politics (whatever they are) are wasting their time when they argue, then the only other way to combat Militant is organisationally. And, as Crick must know very well, an organisational attack on Militant, or any other left wing tendency in the Labour Party means a witch-hunt.
Crick claims that Militant *has a style of secretive and disciplined politics that is wholly alien to the democratic traditions of the Labour arty" and, just ram the point home, repeats it in the conclusion to the book: "Militant's Leninist style of organisation, with iron discipline and complete secrecy is wholly alien to the democratic and open traditions of the *Those Labour Party members who defend Militant fail to recognise that few of them would last five minutes in the unlikely event of the Labour Party being taken over by Militant".
For Crick, the nature of Militant's politics is of secondary importance to the alleged nature of Militant's organisation. One could go even further and say that Crick defines Militant not as a political programme but as a form of organisation. And that would certainiy explain the gross imbalance in the book's contents: only a fraction of it is given over to discussion of Militant's politics; the bulk of it probes into Militant's "inner organisation - and looks into the various attempts by the Party bureaucracy to clamp down on Militant on organistional grounds.
Thus, the middle section of Crick's book consists of a chapter given over solely to Militant's structure: "It is the organisation of a political party — and one operating he concludes, a chapter iven over to an analysis of Militant's inances. chapter on "The Militant Life" ("the similarities between Militant and a religion are obvious from the lifestyle of the members, claims Crick) and a chapter on Militant Mersyside which basically says that Militant rebuilt the Labour Party in Liverpool after it had been virtuall wrecked by a Catholic mafia in the '30s and '40s and the Braddock party machine in the postwar years).
The three closing chapters of the book, nearly a quarter of its entire contents, look at the escalating witch-hunt against Militant which has taken place during the 1980s. They also make it increasingly clear where the author's sympathies lie.
His book adds nothing to an understanding of Militant's politics, which Crick scarcely touches upon anyway.
And Crick's endless tittle-tattle about Ted Grant's taste for jelly babies and gobstoppers and so on will, given the lack of any overall political analysis, oniy encourage others to substitute such anecdotes for coherent political arug ments against those of Militant. This in turn will only help continue to leave Militant free from any political challenge.
His book is not one for those interested in analysing Militant's politics, but one for those on the look-out for a bit of "dirt" with which to smear Milifant.
----- pull-quotes -----
party is the maintenance of the inde- pendent party. The discussion has not