Status quo
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-07-24Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
Flict.
2. Such a unitary state would recognise and guarantee the collective rights and identities of both groups, including freedom of religion, language and education. These would be implemented by devolving powers in these areas to whichever ievei would assure the two communities best control of their own affairs without imprisoning minorities. The Palestinians would have the right to live in any part of the state (which would cover the area of pre-1948 Palestine).
3. While defending the rights of the Israeli Jews, we recognise that at present it is the Palestinians who are the oppressed nation and give them unconditional support in their struggle against the Israeli state.
4. For a single Palestinian degree of legitimacy.
In Palestine there are no borders suited to a democratic solution based on separate states for the Israeli Jews and the Palestinians. Even if the present population were to fall into two distinct territories, there is still the problem of the Palestinians currently living outside pre-1948 Palestine who wish to return.
Of the Palestinian refugees about 10% lived in the areas which became Israel in 1948 prior to that date. Of these about half remain refugees. Many of those born in the camps since 1948 identify themselves as coming from the areas where their families lived before fleeing in 1948.
It is also difficult to see how a West Bank/Gaza state would be a step towards this solution. If a West Bank/Gaza state were to succeed in the aim of reducing national tensions, it would have to become the status quo for relations between the two peoples for some considerable period of time. While the Palestinians could 'in principle force concessions" , including the right for Arabs in Israel to secede to the other state, who would be able to enforce it? Presumably the Palestinian state on the West Bank and Gaza. How would this give the breathing space for reconciliation Martin Thomas talks of?
A common state would have to be based on and guarantee the rights of both the Israeli Jews and the Palestinians to maintain their separate collective identities, unhindered by the state and with control over those aspects of political life necessary to require them to do this. This differs from the 'classic' conception of the secular democratic state as advocated by the PLO in giving collective rights to the Jews within a unitary state and offering such rights unconditionally.
Such rights would - include freedom of religion and language, control of education, the rights of free political organisation etc. They could be implemented through a form of local autonomy where communities - whether Arab, Jewish or mixed - would be able to decide what provision would be made for these issues in their area.
Local autonomy is not however the cornerstone of my arguto the furthest possible extent the rights of both communities. Some rights, however, such as the right to use either language would have to be guaranTeed by the central government. What is crucial is that the means exist for 'justice to be done within the framework of a single state.
The main argument against this has been that it ignores what is fundamentally at stake - namely, the rights of two nations rather than merely democratic rights.
It is suggested that local autonomy would lead to one or other nation wishing to secede from a united state.
However there is no way that full national rights (which include the right to a territory) can be put into effect for either nation without it oppressing the other. Lam a Jewish Canadian who has previously lived in Israel. I have been active in groups supporting Israeli-Palestinian rapprochement such as the Peace Now movement both in Israel and Canada.
I recently picked up an issue of Socialist Organiser and was encouraged to discover the debate about the merits of a two-state solution to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Although I have certain disagreements with some specific points made in the draft statement, I want to add my name to those who support a two-state solution based on Israeli withdrawal to the ceasefire lines of June 4 1967 and heartily applaud Socialist Organiser for the courage and maturity that it took to present this highly emotional issue so these people, groups like the Peace Now movement, the Israel Council for Israeli-Palestinian Peace, the Citizens' Rights Party, Mapam, etc., would simply not exist. This fact was recognised by PLO officials Said Hammami and Issam Sartawi who paid with their lives, the price of daring to establish contacts with "Zionist" Israelis.
By your advocacy of a twostate solution encompassing both a democratic Israel and a democratic Palestinian state in the West Bank and Gaza Strip, and through your reasoned analysis of modern Jewish/ Zionist sentiment in Palestine, you are able to present a principled, democratic solution to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict which takes into account the legitimate national aspirations