Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

[For what it's worth, I would recognise the…]

Socialist Organiser no. 238, 24 July 1985 · scan p. 9 · about 574 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

For what it's worth, I would recognise the Israeli Jews as a nation. However we should remain aware of some of the peculiarities of both national groups.

Firstly, the national consciousness of the Israeli Jews has until now been based on the Zionist ideology of the right to an exclusive Jewish state Palestine, a state which has been based on settlement of the territory previously occupied by the Palestinians. Whether the Israelis feel themselves to be political Zionists in the full sense is irrelevant. Quite what form a Jewish national consciousness would take if the exclusivist, chauvinist and, usually, racist elements based on this ideology were to disappear (or even begin to break down) is highly problematic.

Secondly, the rights of the peoples of the area and whether they form nations or not cannot be asserted simply by reeling off a set of characteristics (language, culture, economy, territory) a la Stalin of 1912 and seeing how well they fit. On this basis, one would have to reject the Palestinians' claim to be a nation on the grounds that they do not have - and never have had — a distinct national economy or historically well-defined national territory.

It is precisely the fact that the Palestinian question is not a straightforward issue of the rights of nations or national minorities which makes it so instractable. Any programme we put forward must deal with three aspects of Palestinian oppression as well as the rights of the Jews. Firstly, they lack any territory in which to live. Secondly, in the West Bank and Gaza Strip they face a military occupation. Thirdly, within Israel the Arabs are treated as second-class citizens. responsibly. For too long many groups and individuals on the left remained consciously or unconsciously insensitive to Jewish concerns and collective aspirations with regards to Israel and Zionism. This is not meant•to imply that a critique of Zionist ideology is necessarily antisemitic, but the "anti-Zionist" pronouncements of some left wing activists serve to alienate many progressive Jews who are concerned about the continued existence of Jews in Israel. These pronouncements tend to drive many Jews both in Israel and abroad towards an ultranationalistic "Greater Israel" stance and away from supporting a democratic solution to the conflict.

As well, it should be understood that the vast majority of activists and supporters of the Israeli peace movement both in Israel and among Jewish communities abroad, define themselves as Zionists. Without of both peoples.

Furthermore, I agree that a guarantee of the rights of the Arab minority in Israel is far preferable to allowing the Galilee and the Little Triangle areas to become part of the Palestinian state.

The majority of Palestinians with Israeli citizenship feel themselves'to be "Israeli" and there is no reason why Israel should be 100% Jewish any more than the Palestinian state to be created should be 100% Arab. Consequently, if a Jewish minority were to exist in the Palestinian state (and I see no reason why theoretically it could not), I would argue on their behalf for full minority rights but against the right to secede to Israel the areas where they, in turn, might possibly constitute a majority.

I welcome the opportunity to participate in a dialogue of this calibre and look forward to a response MARK KLEIN Become a supporter of the Socialist Organiser Alliance - groups are estab lished in most large towns. We ask E5 a month minimum (£1 unwaged)

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 238

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →