Political argument or clan loyalty?
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-08-07Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 2
In the middle of Thursday nightFriday morning a gang of comrades from Merseyside, egged on by more experienced comrades from the West Midlands and Wales, set upon the tent of two young non-Militant women.
Pretending to be the security patrol, and waving heavy sticks, the lads entered the tent and demanded to know if our comrades condemned violence in the labour movement! - For Reb and Roxanne it was a toss-up whether they would be raped or beaten up.
The tent was slashed and poles oroken. The tent was ruined.
Class Fighter comrades.were sole to take the sticks away from at moone was hurt.
The following morning Andy am - Labour Party youth rganiser and a Militant supporte came dowm to the Class Fighte LICLE Ashworth the camp was entirely wrong. He said that political debate - 'as sharp as you like" - is fine, but that everybody must remember that Socialist Organiser is another socialist tendency, and not the YS's enemy. The meeting then passed a motion condemning the attack, It was also said that the guilty comrades' YS branches would be asked to ensure that they would not hold an officer's position.
The comrades responsible were sent home.
However, there was more to it than that.
Many more experienced and older Militant people in the LPYS treat the minority in the YS like muck. We are lied about or ignored and never asked to explain our politics. And often.
her ryout@penave In 310 fire, and geherally the meeting. But the more experienced Militant people there refused to quieten them in fact they held them up as a good example of raw working-class school During the Tuesday of summer camp, Liverpool comrades were called to an emergency meeting to hear the council's side of the story about the Black Caucus's attack on a public meeting called by Liverpool City Council. The YS members were told that the Black Caucus had stolen an address book and therefore everyone was under physical threat. How should they respond? They were told that supporters of the Black Caucus were at camp, and everyone should "remember that" when Socialist Organiser supporters spoke.
Of course Socialist Organiser supporters didn't yet know detai if the Liverpool mee ting, and so the way for the Thursday night.
The blame doesn't end with the youths from Merseyside. A movement which treats other socialists as intruders in 'their" YS, which refuses to debate and instead relies on apolitical clan loyalty will find itself constantly disgraced by brutish behaviour.
The YS has seen this before, in the mid-'60s. Gerry Healy's SLL (now the WRP), had a perioa of rapid growth and took off on a sectarian binge. It built up loyalty among youth new to politics by self-proclamation and by presenting everyone else in politics (including other left groups: Healy called them 'the revisionists', Militant says 'the sects") as a conspiracy against itself The result then was that the Labour Party leadership got a chance and an excuse to purge the LPYS. For Militant to continue with their present arrogance is not only wrong in principle, but reckess: they will create another hance and excuse for witti uniting tant supporters al ner camp could see that. shope they tar convince comrades
Scan page 3
tts national!
Campaign Paul Whetton (Bevercotes NUM) comments in his weekly column The campaign against the breakaway union is building up quite well. We understand that Lynk is in serious trouble. We haven't been in a position to do very much over the past fortnight, but as the holiday period draws to a close the campaign will build up.
There is no way Lynk will get ene deton of support he first We are putting out issues of the 'Notts Miner', of the nation"Miner' leaflets. The women's groups are actively involved.
There will be a series of meetings in the local communities with national speakers, and while each branch is making its own decision, we have the full cooperation of the national UTTOn.
We have no intention of letting MacGregor butcher our industry, and I don't think he's aware of the implications of what he is saying. A substantial reduction of that size will affect not just the pits but also the private sector that provides the pits with equipment.
There may be an effort to phase him out. But when MacGregor has gone there won't necessarily be any alteration to the objective behind its thinking, which is the privatisation of the coal mining industry. It will be resisted most strongly and most fiercely by the NUM.
We got quite considerable international assistance during our strike and we had ethnic minority groups all over the country recognising the importance of our struggle. So I don't doubt that any action taken by South African miners now will receive the full backing of British mineworkers.
At Labour Party conterence we should be backing to the hilt all those resolutions calling for an amnesty and reinstatement for sacked and jailed miners. We must put pressure on Kinnock and Willis.
They may want to hedge their bets but the Labour Party rank and file must demonstrate that it won't stand for people involved in industrial disputes being thrown on the scrapheap bv employers and thrown into jau. E would urge all Labour Party members to mandate their delegales to support those resolutons.
Under no circumstances must Kinnock and Willis force onto us another Social Contrick. It led to the downfall of the last Labour government and we won't stand for that sort of thing.
There's gor to be more consultation - not with TUC chiefs but with the rank and file of the TUC and the Labour Party.
I would rather see an open commitment by the Labour Party leadership to more socialist policies. If they attempt to foist another Contrick onto us I'm sure it will get kicked into the wastepaper basket where it belongs.
*2022 May I as a Kent coal miner who has worked at Snowdown Colliery for the past 48 years make this impassioned plea to encourage you to stay in the NUM.
I was born in Notts and my own father was driven out of his own Notts coalfield into the Kent coalfield because he would not join the infamous Spencer Union.
Many more Notts miners were driven from their homes and jobs because they would not join this breakaway union, going to the far corners of the British coalfield in search of jobs. Uprooting their homes and their families.
Today, jobs even in the mining industry are rare, there is nowhere to run to.The Kent coalfield has been cut to the bone. The rest of the British coalfield is also threatened with drastic cuts I make this appeal to you Notts miners not to make thi same mistakes as your forefathers did.
We Kent miners look to you to make history rather than repeat it.
By doing so you will have redressed the balance somewhat. To fragment our union would be suicidal to you Notts miners.
Spencerism can only bring isolation, as it certainly will to the present generation.
Let us therefore remember the old maxim of United We Stand, Divided We Fall.
Yours fraternally.
Richard W. Richardson
----- pull-quotes -----
the gang, and fortunately enough people were woken up to ensure
om a miner