Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Police 'ghost' evidence

Socialist Organiser no. 239, 7 August 1985 · scan pp. 3–4 · about 913 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

Above: lobby of NUM special conference by Notts strikers. Top right march thrgush Mansfield last May, Photos: lohn Harris. NOTTS •NUMA STRIKE FORCE COAL LON COA NOT STRIKE, ON Y NUF NoTTS CID officers "ghosted" the evidence of witnesses in a major trial, it was discovered recently: The revelation came from Nottinghamshire police officers during the trial of 18 men for alleged riot.

The men, from Coventry: Stoke-on-Trent, Durham and London, were among 60 arrested on May 14 last year in Mansfield. Notts after a massive rally in the town during the coal strike.

The prosecution claims hundreds of demonstrators chanted and threw missiles instead of boarding their coaches to home: the detence says march ers were regimented and cordoned off, obstructed in some cases from getting on their own coaches, and at one stage physically attacked by officers on horseback and others running with truncheons.

As well as argument about what happened on the day, there have been rows over the way that evidence has been presented to the court.

Several uniformed police witnesses have testified to somethat that they agree is "unusual": instead of writing their OWn statements, they were interviewed by Mansfield detectives who wrote their statements for them but concealed this fact.

*Had they lost the use of their hands?" asked defence barrister Peter Hall to the uniformed sergeant who first mentioned the practice. "That is the way the officer leading the investigation decided to do it.T replied Sgt. John Batchelor looks the miners' 'riot' trial Mansfield, Notts.

Robert Bean.

That officer in charge was identified by other witnesses as Detective Chief Inspector David Scott of Mansfield CID, who will give evidence later in the tenweek trial.

The interference by the CID in this way is all the more controversial because the defence complain of inconsistencies between three things - police notes taken on the day of May 14. the formal statements they made afterwards and the evidence they gave in the courtroom.

On the day, the defendants were arrested on relatively minor charges like obstruction. The decision to charge with riot was taken the day after the rally by a key group of senior officers in Notts, including its chiet constable, Mr Charles McLachlan.

It was Mr McLachian himself who held a national press conference on May 15 calling for stiff prison sentences and taking the gloves off in the cold war"

Statements taken after the decision to go for riot contain claims of various things happening - all contested by the defence - which are not to be found in police notebooks written on the day or in sintements taken before the decision from above to charge with riot.

There are also some inexplicably long delays between May 14 and the date when sume statements were written - in some cases as much as a month..

The court heard that Sergeant Bean, an officer of 14 years experience, was not allowed to make his own statement but instead was interviewed four days later on May 18 by a Det. Constable Sanderson. This came out during defence cross-examination of Sgt Bean's testimony that a local resident had walked through the middle of the alleged disturbance, been hit on the head by a rock and carried on unperturbed without looking for cover.

*It just defies believing" said defence barrister Richard Newbury; the officer could not explain the omission of the incident from both notebook and statement. Bean could not explain how the throwing of *several" missiles such as beer cans, bricks and bottles in his notebook had by the time of his statement become other items such as "lumps of concrete as well, all of which "rained down an us for half a minute"

These lumps were 8" by 8" by 2" he said. "You put your mind to some evidence that might support a charge of riot. didn't you?" asked defence barrister Kevin McDonald. 'No sir" , replied Bean.

Mansfield Police Station happens to be the county headquarters of the Nottinghamshire police force's Special Branch, which has its own protected office block within the station's CID accommodation.

Three weeks ago the head of the county force's traffic division told the court he didn't know whether the Special Branch had been involved on the day or not.

But there had been plain clothes CID officers at the rally car park acting as "spotters" gathering intelligence about the dispute, he said. There were aiso debriefing forms for uniformed inspectors or sergeants to fill in about the day's events, including a space for "titbits and rumours" from the general public.

The Big Brother style forms were made available to the court after a day of legal arguments before the jury - with a "keep mum" condition slapped on their court use. Trial judge Robert Ellis ordered that the forms should not be disclosed te any "third party - meaning the public.

*1 do not want these forms disclosed to the national press," he told the court.

He agreed with prosecutor John Milmo that police officers had a right to send confidential reports to their superiors without - looking over their shoulders to possible publication. The ruling means that the public will be prevented from discovering how much the police force overstepped its proper functions in the coal dispute - for example by exchanges of libellous tittletattle against people unable to reply. or by deploying resources towards matters not to do with crime.

tugust

Scan page 4

diverted from other parts of ti

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 239

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →