Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Does stress make us ill?

Socialist Organiser no. 239, 7 August 1985 · scan p. 4 · about 739 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

THIS week I consider whether there is a link between Reagan's cancer of the colon and the stresses of being top terrorist.

The mechanistic approach of Western medicine tends to ignore or deny that mental state can influence physical health. Such ideas have been the preserve of practitioners of "holistic" medicine who regard the human as a being with interlinked physical and "spiritual" aspects.

Clearly, if the -Western approach is inadequate, then so IS the alternative Eastern approach, relying as it does on superstition rather than understanding, with little direct evidence to support its opinions.

But now such evidence is being produced...and from Western-style medical research into the new field of psychoimmunology. This is the study of the effect of the emotions on the immune system.

American researchers have been looking at the function of the immune system in people under mental stress, namely students facing exams.

One study concerned levels of a type of antibody thought to protect against chest infections. The levels fell at exam times, most significantly when students themselves felt they were under most stress. Greatest falls seemed to occur amongst those with fewest friends.

Another researcher studied the activity of certain white blood cells - in particular the "natural killer" cells which destroy invading germs and cancer cells. These cells were least active during final exams, most noticeably among students describing themselves as lonely.

An interesting observation for alternative medicine enthusiasts was that regularly practising relaxation seemed to improve the function of white blood cells. The more relaxed, the better the blood cells.

Psychoimmunologists therefore believe that disturbances in your life can reduce your immune function, thus increasing risk of disease and even This was demonstrated in animals five years ago by someone who put mice on a gramaphone turn-table and spun them for ten minutes in the hour for six days (how do they think of these things?). This is probably quite stressful for mice. It was found that implanted cancers grew better in the spun mice than in unspun "control" mice.

The mechanism by whịch such an effect might be achieved is not understood. It seems that immune surveillance of the body by white blood cells is reduced by stress, allowing rogue cells which would normally be eliminated to grow into cancers.

This theory seems to hark back to the ideas of Wilhelm Reich*, who thought that repression of people's natural instincts caused them to develop a "psychic armour" as a defence against human contact and emotional release. He thought this armour was detectable as a muscular tension. Like many alternative medicines, his theories spoke of a blockage in the flow of energy through the body.

Blocking it had various harmful effects, including making it more likely that cancer would be developed. Reich also thought people with such blockages were more prone to follow authoritarian ideologies such as fascism or Stalinism.

So what is the connection between Reagan's bum and stress? Probably none! I find it difficult to believe that Reagan's cancer of the colon is caused by stress. We are the ones who are being put under stress by Reagan.

His disease was probably caused by all those jellybeans he keeps eating. *Wilhelm Reich was a psychoanalyst and communist who tried to combine the two. He was also more than a little mad and the opposition he encountered from all quarters seems to have made his theories get stranger and stranger. I am aware that I have probably bowdlerised his ideas beyond belief and can only appeal for any aggrieved Reichians to have a go at setting the record straight.

Become a supporter of the Socialist Organiser Alliance - groups are estab lished in most large towns. We ask £5 a month minimum (E1 unwaged) Still worried that aid to Africa. might be sapping Britain's wealth? The City banks, which extract big debt charges from many Third World countries, should put your mind at rest.

Last year the City made £6.1 billion net profit from abroad. Britain's total aid to the Third World runs at about £1.5 to £2 billion a year. Jews — are not recognised.

Racism against black jews by white jews also plays a part. In the past Indian jews have had to make protests similar to the Ethiopians'. Crusade China's bureaucrats, diligently taking lessons from the Tories on how to privatise, have mover a long way from the days of the

----- pull-quotes -----

City profits

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 239

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →