Money not for need but for the 'deserving' poor
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-08-07Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 7
tion. ment and to a campaign of Local groups should affili- Parliamentary obstruction at paign Against Social Security Fowler groups should ties should back anti-Fowler drop its sectarian stance towith no strings attached. The And the demand for TUC • Priority should be given to Reviews must also be linked paigning between local anti- mation of unemployed branches; Labour-controlled of political campaigning.
line (e.g. NUT and EIS] call- Reviews should not be impleof funds of claimants' organ- demand could be taken up to isations, trades councils and add weight to the general ence. ment and claimants organis. The Parliamentary Labour ations, coupled with camEight million people in Britain - one in seven — now depend on supplementary benefit. Another 1.4 million are entitled to it but do not claim it.
The Reviews propose that supplementary benefit be ate to the National CamCuts, 43 Broughton St., Edinburgh EH1 3JU, phone 031-557 0213. Affiliation is €5 per calendar year.
Labour controlled authoricampaigning by providing both finance and facilities GLc is providing E7 million.
preparing for the Week of Action, in particular strike activity on the Friday. This should include: joint camFowler groups and CPSA local authorities pledging full support for employees who strike on that day; unions with pay claims in the pipeing for strike action; TUC and regional TUCs calling strike action as well.
Especially given the lack other labour movement bodies should be providing tion. and subsidising transport for the demonstrations during the Week of Action and on October 27, and the LPYS should be backing the marches to Tory Party conferParty must be committed to campaigning against the Reviews outside of Parliarenamed Income Support and claimants be categorised into four different "client groups': unemployed; single parents; sick and disabled; aged over 60 years old.
The unemployed will Westminster. Local antidemand this of local Labour MPs, and the demand should be taken up by the Labour Party nationally.
The TUC must be forced to wards national campaigns against social security cuts.
action against the Fowler up with renewed campaigning for unions to accept the unemployed as full members and for the transforworkers centres into centres The "Action for Benefits" campaign, set up by civil service trade unions, has raised the demand that the Fowler mented until the Tories have stood in a General Election on a manifesto containing the proposed cuts. This demand for a general elecMost important of all, a genuine alternative to both the existing social security system and the Fowler Reviews needs to be developed by the labour novepaigning for its implementation by the next Labour government. the Income Support basic personal allowance (except that those under 25 will be paid at a lower rate on the grounds that they are not fully independent). The three other categories will receive the basic personal allowance plus a special premium.
Meanwhile, all extra payments will be abolished.
62% of claimants receive an AR ("additional requirements" payment for, e.g., heating, diet, laundry, etc., of some kind In December 1982, 87,000 claimants received ARs of £7 or more per week. Some disabled claimants receive ARs of up to £30 or £40 per week. 90% of pensioners receive ARs.
ARs will be completely scrapped.
The number of SPs - one-off "single payments" for such things as bedding, furniture, removal expenses, etc. - has grown from 0.8 million in 1981 to three millions in 1984. In 1983, nearly two million SPs were made, at an average amount of £75.64. These give the supplementary benefit system some limited flexibility to respond to need. Under Fowler's scheme, need won't count.
SPs will be replaced by loans from a new "Social Fund", administered on a discretionary basis by the local DHSS office management.
Those most in need will suffer the most: they are the most dependent on AR and SP, and will therefore suffer the largest drop in living standards as a result of their abolition.
All claimants will ' have to meet (at least) 20% of their rates bill out of the Income Support, instead of having it covered in full by their monthly Housing Benefit giro as at present. There will be no compensating increase in basic benefit rates. Claimants will also have to pay water rates and residual housing costs.
Present arrangements for help with claimants mortgage
Fowler. Photo:
interest payments will be scrapped over a period of time. As the Green Paper puts it, the Tories are wanting an arrangement "whereby less of the burden — particularly for people on benefit for a short time - falls immediately on the social security system.
Capital There will be a new Capital Limit (i.e. the amount of savings a claimant can possess before s/he is denied benefits) of £6,000. Now it is £3000. But weekly benefits will be cut by 40p for every £100 of savings between £3,000 and £6,000.
The earnings disregard (i.e. the 'amount a claimant can earn each week before it is deducted from his/her benefits) is also to be increased from f4 to £5, with certain categories of claimants being entitled to an earnings disregard of E15.
A racist new length-ofresidence list will be introduced: "the claimant will need to have been present in the country for a set period to qualify for Income Support.
The Social Fund will be the only element of flexibility in response to need — to cope with *the exceptional circumstances and emergencies faced by a minority (!) of claimants. " It will be administered by the local DHSS office. Payments out of the fund will be on a discretionary basis, and most payments will be in the form of recoverable loans. The Social Fund will have a fixed, cash-limited annual budget.
Discretion'
The idea of any entitlement to extra money is to be scrapped, almost entirely, in tavour of "discretion"* In practice, this will mean more means-testing, and a lower take-up rate. (Only 50% of those entitled to means-tested Family Income Supplement, tor example, actually receive it. About t1 billion of benefits goes upclaimed each year).
There will be no appeal beyond the local office where the original decision was taken. One of the objections contained in the Green Paper to the current method of making single payments is that the rate of appeal is too high. (In fact, it is now 21%, as against 45% in 1976).
But the Institute of Directors argued in their "evidence" to the Fowler Reviews": "some think these low take-up rates a weakness of the present system; we think them a strength. First, a low take-up saves large amounts of government spending. Second, it is in substantial measure the result of selt-selection among the potential users of the welfare system.
"Some people are reluctant to accept such payments for reasons of self-respect. We see nothing wrong in this sentiment, and many would consider it admirable.
Kitty