The Red
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-08-07Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
between the Zionists and British Imperialism lasted until 1945.
It is factually incorrect to say that the core of the Israeli state when it was founded consisted of refugees from European antiSemitism and the Holocaust. The latter came to Israel after its founding.
Immigration
As Lenni Brenner and others have documented, the Zionists used these people as a batterino ram to anen the catac of Paletine to Jewish immigra- ug tam t upuu u gars vE tion whilst at the same time supporting immigration controls against Jewish refugees in the USA and Britain, just as today they oppose Soviet Jews settling in any other country bar Israel But what has this to do with the nature of the Israeli state? Did not the Plymouth Brethren feel oppressed when they colonised America? And the Australian settlers? And what about the pieds noirs in Algeria, amongst wnom tnere was a tar stronger Communist Party than ever existed in Palestine and some of whom had fought against Franco To check whether some of the criticisms of Militant made in Socialist Organiser and Class Fighter are fair I bought a copy of that paper.
According to Clive Bradley in Class Fighter no. 20, "whether some Militant supporters believe it or not, what they actually say is that a Labour government could - through Parliament, and peacefully — introduce socialism". And, Militnat has "no answer to the probSpain.
All that this demonstrates is how reprehensible colonialism and Zionism are, in that it creates racists out of the most progressive of people, including socialists. And weren't the Afrikaaners the first victims of (British) concentration camps?
Instead of an analysis of how Zionism created a settler working class which never fought for its own independent class interests, we are told of a "chronic national antagonism" between Israeli Jewish and Palestinian/ Arab workers. Not a hint of where this comes from nor any attempt to differentiate between the nationalism of the oppressed and oppressor.
The racism of Israeli workers derives from the settle! r colonial state they live in, it doesn't magically appear when different peoples come into cont: act. Until the Israeli state is destri oyed, the racisin ana cnauvisin ul Israen of Taunali Jewish workers will remain, indeed increase if ther e is a repartitioning, and they v vill never lem of ruling class violence othet than the vague hope that under the pressure of a 'mobilised" workers' movement the ruling class will just give up."
However in the Militant 1 bought, of April 26, a columnist writes that the British Royal Family "have enormous potential power undel the British constitution and just because it's not used at the moment doesn't mean that it won't be at some stage in the tuture. " There Palestinian youth go beyond a rudimentary economic class consciousness.
The same holds true of the South African white working class and the Loyalist working class.
Instead Israeli workers will cling to their privileges and see their main enemv as the Palestinians. It is little wonder that the Israeli working class has been unable to create its own independent trade unions, still less a Party, and instead is contained within Israel's largest employers' federation and economic empire, Histadrut.
I don't accept that a Jewish nation exists in Israel, but even if it did it would still be an oppressor nation like the Afrikaaners. It has no right to a separate portion of territory. M/hat than An have ic tha ninht to vy nat ley do nave is te nigut t seems to be an understanding here that the monarchy would be used to block any attempt to introduce socialism "legally" through Parliament.
Moreover in this Militant it is observed: "It must be made absolutely clear to the police and the courts that when the police do nothing about gangs of fascists attacking black communities then those communities will defend themselves. " Those attacked violently must be prepared to answer with violence. rights as others.
The question of "self-determination' of the Israeli Jews does not arise because they are not an oppressed group. They enjoy a high standard of living precisely because of the role that Israel plays in the Middle East, financed but not exploited by the USA.
Dynamic The comparison between Israel and the British state is thereby false. Israel is a settler colonial state and has an expansionist and racist dynamic of its own.
In contributing to this debate we hope that Socialist Organiser does not abandon the fight against Zionism and go for a muddle-headed. middle of the Is this "vague ?
Clive Bradley says futiler that Militant "is soft on world Stalinism". But in this Militant there is an article sharply critical of the role of Stalinism in Vietnam.
Of course there are differences between Socialist Organiser and Militant. But are they really so fundamental that the advantages of keeping separate organisations outweigh those of forming one tendency?
DAVID HARRIS I find it surprising that Les Hearn should be so taken in by Plaid Cymru President Dafydd Elis Thomas MP (Science Column, SO 235).
Speaking at the AGM of the Socialist Environment and Resources Association it is to be expected that he should lay great emphasis on Plaid's environmental policies.
Indeed, some of these policies represent a serious attempt to come to grips with issues like nuclear waste and acid rain which leave the Welsh Labour Party standing. However, it is precisely the combination of "Red and Green' policies which Les mentions that is crucial, and it is essential in this respect to place Plaid's Green policies firmly in the context of their overall political outlook.
Resignation
In the first place, Thomas cannot claim to speak for the whole of his party. 'Hydro', the right-wing faction in Plaid aligned to former party president Dafydd Wigley MP, has called for the resignation of the entire executive committee after the disastrous showing in the Brecon and Radnor by-election. They claim that the party's lowest ever vote in a parliamentary contest was the result of the 'left wing policies' of the committee.
With his own party so divided it is hardly honest of Thomas to talk of a coherent' Plaid attitude and to refer to the Welsh Labour Party as if it were a right wing monolith. In fact the Labour left in Wales, including the NUM leadership, is actively involved in environmental issues, particularly those involving nuclear waste and environmental pollution.
This is no light-minded moral stand, as Britain's single biggest polluter, the Pharnacite smokeless fuel plant in the Cynon Valley, is a major local employer in an area of high unemployment, as is the ROF Llanishen factory in Cardiff which produces casing components for nuclear weapons.
The difference in emphasis between Thomas, who gives the Forestry Commission as a suitable target for workers' control, and the Labour left's concentration on industrial priorities, is very revealing of Plaid's retreat to its rural heartlands.
Plaid has been in a state of constant decline since the early "seventies, when it received a large number of protest votes from Labour supporters in South Wales who were disillusioned by local government corruption and bureaucratic inactivity.
As local councils 'went Plaid" it rapidly became obvious that it was business as usual and that the nationalists could not provide a coherent socialist alternative to right-wing Labourism.
Their control was short-lived and electoral defeats were followed by defeat in the devolution referendum in 1979. The Brecon and Radnor result is the lowest point so far in this rout.
Dafydd Elis Thomas himself has responded to the by-election by proposing that Plaid should abandon any pretension win seats in the industrial South and concentrate instead on key rural seats.
Routine denunciations
Labourism continue, but he is attempting to reunite his 'socialist, decentralist and feminist' party around. the radical nationalism of rural Wales.
All of this is in contradiction to the nonsense at the SERA AGM about Plaid merging with the Labour Party if only it had a 'Welsh section' • Take away the pale pink filter and Plaid is still the party of TV producers. teachers and small farmers like Gwynfor Evans, the tomato grower who,izas the novelist Gwyn Thomas once put it, was "up to his arse in fascism and ketchup'.
In this context the link with the Communist Party might be surprising, but only until you realise that the latter has adopted a nationalist perspective wholesale in an opportunistic, and partially successful attempt to poach Plaid's intellectual members.
Plaid worked closely with the CP in the miners' strike, even to the extent of supporting the CPinspired witch-hunt of those Labour activists in Cardiff Central Labour Party who had initiated the Cardiff Miners Support Committee.
Popular Front Once again, the contradictions - in this case between the "decentralist socialism' of Plaid and the bureaucratic Stalinism of the CP, are glaringly obvious, even if conveniently forgotten in the attempt to stitch together a popular front of miners, bishops and farmers.
The most telling difference between rhetoric and reality lies in the fact that Plaid is ultimately a nationalist party. Whether it concerns ideas about workers' control or Lucas Aerospace type plans for the nuclear and defence industries, Plaid's writ only runs to Offa's Dyke and the English border.
This is highlighted by references to 'dirty' Notts coal as opposed to the 'clean' Welsh stuff, a remark that will hardly go down well with those Notts miners who have recently gone back to digging 'dirty' coal after a year on strike. Plaid claims to be able to overcome the disastrous effects of the international capitalist crisis by hiving Wales off as the nation it has never been.
Thankfully, the Welsh working class will have none of it, as demonstrated by the massive vote against devolution a few years ago and, more recently, by Plaid's forced retreat to its rural fastness.
It is no longer possible, as Liberal MPs and Lib-Lab miners leaders used to do, to play the Welsh card' and divide Welsh from English. The unity between the working class in England and Wales should be supported as a starting point, not decried as an obstacle to the development of a mythical, and mystical, Welsh nation state.
Yours MARTIN BARCLAY.
Scan page 10
Revir