Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Woody Allen feminist? Not quite

Socialist Organiser no. 239, 7 August 1985 · scan p. 10 · Edward Ellis · about 763 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

only release And it is turns after scene with spends an over and ov favourite n comedy, T Cairo'.

Half way mance, one Tom Baxter Edward Ellis reviews Woody Allen's new film, The Purple Rose of Cairo.

I can remember being about twieve and watching Everything you wanted to know about sex but were afraid to ask' . I thought nothing could be funnier than jokes about the sexual habits of sheep.

Bur some time ago - when I saw "Manhattan' , to be precise - Woody Allen films started to bore me; and since then, l've avoided them like the pox.

He just seemed a bit old still to be having adolescent sexual hang ups. And it seemed very unfair that he was abie to make countless films about them.

I'm sure no one would laugh ar films about mine; so how come he gets away with it?

I was with some trepidaion, therefore, that I went to see Woody Allen's latest offering, The Purple Rose of Cairo"

But there were no adolescent sexual hang-ups to be found -no male ones at least. Rather, this somewhat bizarre little fantasy is to do with the bad time women get in the hands of men, and the power of the silver screen to provide escape — and therefore disguise and cancel out, as well as soothe - the miseries of women's lives.

Fair stab

Woody Allen goes feminist? Well, not quite. But he has a fair stab at it.

In case you, like me, didn't know what the film is about and expected lavish Nile Valley scenes with plenty of sun, sand and palm trees, I will fill you in.

Mia Farrow plays a very. ordinary woman, scraping togesister explorer) - leaps out of the screen, and drags her out of the cinema declaring undying love. As you would expect, all hell thereupon breaks loose.

The film company, perplexed that their celluloid characters have developed a will of their own, send the actor responsible for the recalcitrant her off to catch him. The actor claims in the meantime also to fall in love with Mia Farrow, but is, we suspect, more concerned in fact with his own ego and his movie career.

Meanwhile the film hero himself has to cope with a world far more down-to-earth and downright seedy than that of movie imagination, whilst back on the screen the deserted with the bemused cinema audience.

The viewers of any movie are expected, as the theatre critics say. tosuspend their disbelief to accept that what they are viewing is not real", and thereby to impose new norms of 'reality' on what is being viewed.

Allen's trick is to subvert the new norms of "reality" . The movie characters insist on their own fictional status, and on the fictional status of Baxter (Mia Farrow comments wistfully on her new lover: 'He's fictional, but you can't have everything').

Yet the world behind the screen' serves to remind us that the 'real' characters to us, are also behind the screen' and so equally unreal in fact.

It's a trick that has been done before, but it's no less effective for that. It is to Allen's credit, it should be added, that he doesn't labour the point.

Dilemma What gives the film poignancy, and rescues it from being just "clever' , is how the real/ unreal dilemma partieularly affects the life of a downtrodden working class woman. For her the fantasies are vital for to the helplessness.

In the end - the only possible end under the circumstances - she goes back to watching the movies, a naive glow in her face.

You would expect that conclusion from a film about film's effects on consciousness by a film-maker.

But its message is false. There is an escape; and its source is to be found in the real world: the strength to smash the illusions.

Charm Woody Allen has made a good film, a story told with simplicity and charm. It won't have you rolling in the aisles, but it might make you think a bit. If I did not I'd have mo hey (Chorus/ O, Ilike my boss -He's a good friend of That's why I am star Out in the breadline. [Chorus / I can't buy a job For I ain't got th So I ride in a box For I'm a hobo (Chorus/ Whenever i get All the money The boss will b And to work h (Chorus?

mi earn brol mus

----- pull-quotes -----

characters moan about their pre- dicament and exchange abuse

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 239

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →