Afghanistan and Stalinism
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-08-07Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
organiser FORK *Socialist FORUM 50p Number 2 March/April 1985 The Labour Left and the break Communist Party Organiser ther a bare existence in the American depression, whose pig of a husband doesn't love her any more and beats her un. Her is the movies. to the movies she a particularly bad the husband. She evening watching, er again, her latest novie, a romantic he Purple Rose of through the perforof the characters -(Adventurer, poet, Number 1 February THE BRITISH TO Organiser, August 7, 1985 Page When the Russian army went into Afghanistan at the end of 1979, most would-be revolutionary Marxists supported it - or at least argued against calling for its withdrawal. Socialist Organiser, (and Workers' Action, one of the groups that launched SO) were pretty isolated in stating firmly that the troops should get out.
Now most Trotskyists have changed their minds. The facts the USSR's brutal 'mini-Vietna war' have forced them to.
Editorial: Dialogue yes. Militant's record on freiano. and ours US Clive Bradley reviews 'Forum' no. 3.
But in Europe, and in Britain the labour movement is riddled with all sorts of pro-Stalinist idea which make people excuse or minimise what Russia is doing.
And the biggest would-be Trotskyist group in Britain, Militant, still argues against Soviet withdrawal.
Militan colonis analy Sovialist forum no. 1 on British Road to Socialism no. 2 on Ireland, no. 3 on Afghanistan - 50p each. Socialist Organiser specials on the miners' strike 75p: on Local government, 60p.
All available from SO, 2 kert Court, London NI Y: add 20p for postage Socialist Forum no. 3 is devoted to a long article by SO editor John O'Mahony on Afghanistan. It tells the history: it examines Militant's theoretica justifications for their positions, and it spells out the Marxist atti tude to the USSR's occupation.
The only real alternative to Soviet withdrawal is full-scale genocidal conquest.
Militant's position is based on the idea that the USSR will drag Afghanistan into the 20th century. It is cruel, perhaps, but progressive.
Militant present this as hard-headed, unsentimental Marxism. Yet in truth it has more in common with the attitude of some socialists in the early years of this century who supported the British Empire because, after all, it would bring railways, schools and law-courts to the "lesser breeds'.
The argument is not just about Afghanistan: for Militant has an entire theory that sees the rise of brutally anti-working class Stalinist states as the only and the inevitable way forward for most of the world.
Nationalised economy is the way forward, says Militant; given the poverty in the Third World and the pressure of the USSR, no workers' democracy is possible there; therefore nationalised econ omies will be created, like it or not, by Stalinist-type bureaucracies arising from the middle class.
It isn't pretty, but it's progress so we should support it.
This means supporting a 'next stage' for most of the world which, by Militant's own account, puts the working class under totalitarian oppression.
Socialist Forum no. 3 Is important both for the general case it puts against Soviet occupa tion of Afghanistan, and for the detailed critique of a central part of Militant's theoretical armoury It should provoke discussion on the left as a whole, and in the LPYS in particular her very survival, even when the fantasies themselves merely add to her day-to-day misery. And though being so vital, the romantic fantasies serve to keep her helpless: she resigns herself Hallelujah, I'm A Bum!
(Tune: Revive Us Again) Hobo parody of the last century, adapted by Spokane WW winter of 1908 for use on song card of that year preceding songbooks), O, why don't you work Like other men do?
How in hell can I work When there's no work ti [Chorus!
Hallelujah, I'm a bum! Hallelujah, bum again! Hallelujah, give us a hana To revive us again.
don't you save All the money you earn?
----- pull-quotes -----
NOWHERE STARVE T BATTERED, DEFIANT. INAGNIFICENT HINERS THE 1984-6 STRIKE
Ireland 69-85 Why Militant and
For a federal united Ireland Al Socialist 40 PAGES SPECIAL ISSUE
Organiser 60° Illusions of POWER
Socialist FORUM Number July 1985 50p 'ŞR troops out!
Songs of liberty and rebellion