Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Will the TUC split?

Socialist Organiser no. 239, 7 August 1985 · scan p. 11 · Martin Thomas · about 1,672 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 11

Subscribe! Will the AUEW and the EETPU be expelled from the TUC? Will Roy Lynk's breakaway from the NUM be the pioneer of a whole breakaway TUC?

Is "Mainstream' - the rightwing group with the EETPU and Lynk affiliated, and AUEW president Terry Duffy chairing it in his personal capacity - the core of that 'alternative TUC'?

Will Liberal leader David Steel's hopes be fulfilled for the TUC to split into two groups — *an open-minded progressive group ready to talk to the alliance and the Government as well as Labour" , as he put it, "and an old-fashioned Socialist group which revolves around Labour politics'"?

Probably not — yet.

On July 24 the TUC General Council voted by 34 to 5 to begin disciplinary proceedings against the AUEW because it has taken Tory government money for its postal ballots, in violation of the April 1982 Wembley TUC decisions.

EETPU general secretary Eric Hammond was defiant, saying that the AUEW and the EETPU together "could raise a very attractive banner for a lot of other unions"

There are three reasons why a fudge or compromise is more likely, in the short term, than a sharp break between the right wing unions and the TUC.

First: several other unions have effectively ditched the Wembley decisions.

The position of the AUEW and the EETPU is rather like that of the pioneer Revisionist, Eduard Bernstein, in the German socialist movement in the early years of this century. Bernstein openly advocated reformism and class collaboration, and socialist congress after congress passed thundering votes of censure against him.

Bernstein

Mearwhile many trade union leaders practised exactly what Bernstein preached. One of them, Auer, wrote sorrowfully to him: 'My dear Ede: One does these things. One doesn't say them".

The EETPU and the AUEW do flamboyantly and defiantly what other union leaders do discreetly and hypocritcally.

The Colliery Managers and other small managerial/supervisory unions also intend to take Tory ballot moneyThe NUR - probably the union whose leaders did best in terms of solidarity with the miners - has decided at its AGM to obey the Tory law on strike ballots.

Lots of unions have been involved - usually in shame-faced fashion — in ballots over closed shops.

David Basnett of the GMBU and Clive Jenkins of ASTMS came out for a revision of the Get SOCIALIST ORGANISER each door by post.

RATES: £8.50 ir 6 months. E16 for Name :

Address Please se nd me... months' sub. I enclose E.

To: Soci alist Organiser, 214 Sickert Court, Lonc Wembley policy of non-compliance with Tory laws late last year, and in February the TUC's employment committee, mumbling about "flexibility" decided to ask unions how they thought the policy should be revised.

The EETPU has drawn a lot of flak for its 'no-strike' deals, like the one it has just agreed with Eddie Shah for his new paper. 'The electricians' union, comments the Economist magazine, "prefers to call such agreements no-strike deals, because employers like them better that way Other unions... even the leftled Transport and General Workers Union, have agreed similar deals but say they are not no-strike agreements at all".

Second: the TUC did exclude the NGA and the Bakers' Union for registering under the Industrial Relations Act 1971. But that was a temporary move covering unions with well-defined industrial patches.

A decisive break by the AUEW or EETPU from the TUC would leave those two unions — organised across a wide range of industries in which other unions are also active - wide open to membership raids by the TUC.

The AUEW and EETPU have right-wing leaders, but many left-wing activists who would much sooner join a TUC competitor than help build up a rival pro-employer trade union centre. The right wing breakaway would be liable to decimation.

Hammond declared that if excluded from the TUC he would seek links "in self-defence" with the anti-strike groups that have developed in recent years, such as the Professional Association of Teachers and the Professional Association of Railwaymen. That sums up his problem. The PAT is the high-flyer of that lot. It has only 30,000 members. And there are many more anti-strike teachers than there are electricians. The big majorities in the trade union ballots over political funds show that - Professor Hobsbawm notwithstanding Labour and trade union loyalties are far from dead in the rank and file.

Third: ties to the Labour Party are important to trade union leaders for a lot of reasons which have nothing to do with working class principles.

Seats in the House of Lords, places on official committees, jobs on nationalised industry boards, political careers for those so minded, are all at stake. The SDP-Liberal Alliance, with its tiny handful of MPs, cannot offer the same gravy. It won't be iths sub. I 214 Sicker able to until its steady electoral support rises much higher.

Altogether the AUEW execurive had very good reasons to rebuff Hammond and reject any notion of an alternative TUC.

Behind the whole affair stands a problem common to all the trade union leaders - dwindling membership.

Mainly because of the rapid decline of traditionally well-organised industries, TUC affiliated membership has dropped from 12.2 million in 1979 to 9.9 million now.

APEX membership has dropped 37%; TGWU membership, 29%; EETPU, 15%. The AUEW has lost well over 20% though the figures are complicated by the merging of the engineering, foundry and con"'s Terry Duffy Bruntsfield Hospital in Edinburgh was reprieved from closure last month after an 18 month campaign. But now, the battle has begun afresh. The Lothian Health Board has just announced that it intends to keep the hospital open, but close all the beds, making it into a clinic. struction sections.

The only unions that_have grown are the Banking, Insurance and Financial Union; Nalgo; and some that have profited from mergers, like NGA, SOGAT, and TASS.

Closed shops have declined from 5.2 million workers in 1978 to about 4 million today.

Rather than any bold new organising drives, the unions' main response has been to scramble cap-in-hand after employers setting up new plant. Eddie Shah's paper is one example. No union talks of boycotting it; instead SOGAl 1S begging for crumbs left after the EETPU has got the bulk of the franchise. SOGAT - by no means a maverick right-wing union — is also trying to deal and Gavid Laird. (Photo: John Harris).

extension opened.

The contidence of the unions in the Bruntsfield Hospital has increased with the victory to keep it open. That confidence and ours must be strengthened and built on. Help save your local hospital. It can be done! More information from Beth Cumming, 13 Drumdryan St., Edinburgh. with Murdoch over his new wapping plant, it necessary despite and against the other print union, the NGA.

In the wake of the miners' strike - which some, like the NUR, helped inadequately, and other union leaders didn't help at all - defeatism reigns throughout the top ranks of the trade unions. That is why right-wingers like Hammond and the AUEW's Gavin Laird are able to set the tone and dominate debate.

Let that defeatism continue that defeatism continue and grow, and time Hammond and his SDP friends (like John Grant, EETPU press officer and leading SDPer) will have the forces to create an "alternative TUC"

A shorter-term objective six months imprisonment and recommended for deportation.

Yazdan was arrested earlier this year in mysterious circumstances and held virtually incommunicado in Winchester Prison.

He was eventually tried on a minor charge. The sentence is not only harshly punitive but carries strong political and racist overtones. Yazdan is an Iranian. Just weeks prior to his arrest he had sought political asylum in the UK. Did the Iranian Embassy exert pressure on the Home Office?

The extent of official collusion is not certain but Iranian, students and labour movement supporters are facing harassment by CID cops apparently trying to sabotage the defence campaign.

Messages of support/help with the defence campaign, c/o Flat 3, 118 Gordon Avenue, Portswood, Southampton SO2 1DA, them would be to get the EETPU disaffiliated from the Labour Party and to organise the non-Labour-affiliated unions in the TUC - which include some sizeable ones like NALGO, BIFU, and CPSA — into an SDP-Liberal-oriented bloc., At present these non-affiliated unions trail politically behind the Labour unions, and their leading figures, like the CPSA's Alistair Graham. are individual Labour Party members. In 1983 (for the first time) the whole TUC officially called for a Labour vote at the election.

Success for Hammond and the SDP is still a fair way off. But the markers that they're putting down should be a warning to us all. when NOPE officials withdrew recognition from the Barking picket line, which has been going on for 16 months. On July 8 the strikers received letters delivered by courier to their homes, instructing them to withdraw their picket from the hospital within 24 hours.

They continued picketing nonetheless, and a mass picket on July 17 drew 400 people. Five GMBU members on strike have been instructed by their union to continue picketing, and NUPE officials have now been put in a position of once again having to support their members on the picket line. The strikers are meeting NUPE officials again on August 6. * NUPE general secretary Rodney Bickerstaffe has described Barking as the NHS's Cortonwood. Bickerstaffe and his officials are certainly not the NHS's Scargills.

Contact: Barking strike committee, 01-592 5038; or Sylvia Burton, Addenbrookes Strike Committee, c/o 31 Thorleys Rd.. Cambridge.

THE nine week strike of NUJ members at BRMB radio in Birmingham has ended.

After having consistently refused all offers of compromise from the NUJ, BRMB last week agreed to replace two of the jobs with freelance NUJ members while the dispute goes to non-binding arbitration. The situation will be reviewed when the mediators report in three months time.

The journalists believe the deal is the best they could have achieved in the circumstances. Socialist Organiser, August 1985

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 239

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →