Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

The heart o the beast

Socialist Organiser no. 240, 14 August 1985 · scan p. 10 · about 947 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

I read both your criticisms of the Socialist Workers Party in Socialist Organiser no. 235 and your special issue on the councils with great interest. I reckon your publications are open enough to include a contribution from the point of view of the SWP.

I don't have enough space to deal with all the points you raise - though I've got to say that you're the only people in the country who noticed a failure on our part to "argue for the necessary class-wide solidarity action during the miners' strike." Did you listen to or read anything we said?

Ill stick to your criticism of the SWP:

"For revolutionary Marxism - that is, Bolshevism -politics comes first. For the SWP on the other hand, organisational questions come first, and politics second."

It's you who's making this distinction between "politics" and "organisation" , and it's a very dangerous one. As revolutionary Marxists, we're agreed on the basic aims the overthrow of capitalism and the creation of workers' states based on workers' councils. But as Ken Livingstone says in your special issue: "no one can say at the moment we're in a pre-revolutionary situation"

So the big question must be: where and how can we most effectively put across our analysis to the largest numbers of workers and students? This is an organisational question in your terms.

Pure

You say that according to the SWP's analysis there shouldn't be any good socialists in the Labour Party for us to send open letters to; "why have they not had their brains rotted?"

The point is this: it's possible to have a dazzingly pure political line in theory, in your head, but what you're actually saying or doing depends on where you are and who you are talking to.

As a tiny minority in the working class, revolutionaries cannot set the agenda. We can only intervene in debates or struggles. Your pamphlet "Illusions of Power" proves this beyond any reasonable doubt.

It documents the debates you and other socialists have had over the last six years about how to run the Labour councils. You claim you want to organise a "Marxist left in the Labour Party" which can "keep faith with its revolutionary principles" But judging by this pamphlet the real arguments you've been having for the last six years have been over rate increases and the implementation of cuts.

Here are a few quotes:

"If a council feels incapable of fighting both cuts and rate rises, that position (raising rates) should not be opposed" and "better to have a Labour council in Lambeth next year, even if it has to raise rates, than to have commissioners sent in by the Tories."

"Even a revolutionary group of councillors might have no alternative than to comply to some degree, with no.240 August Page the policies of a central government which it could scarcely hope to overthrow with its own efforts.

The last quote says it all -you're working in organisations where cuts and rate rises are on the agenda and where it's virtually impossible to organise an effective fightback against the Tories.

Again and again your contributors realise that what socialists in the council can or can't do is 100% dependent on the actions of organised workers in the workplace -as you say, "it is a question mobilising the working class as a whole politically against the Tories.

Vague demands

But as you're working in the councils, you end up making compromise after demands for mass action. As half-built and isolated campaigns in Hackney, Islington, Sheffield, etc., collapse around your ears you continue to predict a "decisive confrontation between Edinburgh and Liverpool and the Tories". You call us unrealistic!

When workers' own organisations are on the defensive demoralised by Labour's social contract, mass unemployment and Tory attacks, how do you expect to make the councils "bastions of opposition"? As Bill Bowring notes in "Illusions of Power" *Labour councillors are not shop stewards, touting for the best deals they can get, they're people who manage the local state"

The "Labour movement" is not one cohesive unit as you assume. The purpose of local councils, the purpose of the Labour Party is to run capitalism — in organisational terms that is what they do The purpose, the job of unions on the other hand is to defend workers' living standards and conditions.

That is why the SWP concentrate on working in unions and not in the Labour Party or councils. Unions exist where workers have power, where they experience exploitation, where they confront the bosses. Sometimes, even union bureaucracies are forced to lead a fight against a section of the boss class.

The Labour Party orientates towards a talking shop. where there are hardly any workers anyway.

In Parliament, talk about socialism has pretty much dried up. In the councils you spend years talking about raising rates. It's. only in the unions, in the workplace, that the Marxist ideas of mass mobilisation and solidarity will actually make sense and can be acted on; it's only there that the boss class can be taken on.

Organisational questions are political. Where and how you organise determines whether you spend your time helplessly dithering about rates and cuts or whether you are operating as revolutionaries, putting your theory into practice and striking at the heart of the beast.

Fraternally.

NINEHAM socialism Max Beer, A History of British Socialism. New edition by Spokesman, £11.95.

According to Beer the word "socialist' was first used in 1827. This book - actually volume 1 of a two-volume work written just before World War 1 - ends in

----- pull-quotes -----

compromise over administra- tive issues while making vague

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 240

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →