Childhood revisited
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-08-14Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
THE BANKS OF MARBL Edward Ellis reviews the film 'Return to Oz', now on general release The Emerald City in ruins; its people all turned to stone; the Yellow Brick Road all broken up: this is the Land of Oz as Dorothy finds it - half a century or so on.
Oz has indeed changed. Now ruled by the Gnome King - who is basically the alive inside of a mountain -it is in a very bad state. The ruins of the City are patrolled by rather nasty creatures called Wheelers, whose boss is particularly unpleasant witch with a large number of spare heads.
Tin Woodsman and Cowardly Lion, like everyone else, have been turned to stone. Only Scarecrow has survived, and he's trapped in the Gnome King's mountain.
On her return trip Dorothy makes some new friends with which to confront the powers of evil. Tick Tock is a somewhat squat clockwork soldier, who unpredictably 'runs down' at inconvenient moments. Jack Pumpkin Head is just like he sounds he would be. And Dorothy takes with her, instead of Toto the dog, a talking hen (who saves the day in the end!.
Dead moose
But by far the best character is this bizarre creature created and brought to life by Dorothy using magic powder stolen from the Wicked Witch. Its body is a settee, its wings are large fern leaves and its head is an old dead mooselike mounted trophy.
"Last thing I knew I was wandering around in the forest, when I heard a loud bang. Next thing I'm flying through the air" moans the beast - which they appeared to be calling a Gump.
And later, when being sent into the bowels of the earth by the Gnome King, it mutters: "I should have quit while I was a head". Geddit?
This is all jolly good stuff. It is, it should be said, quite different from the Judy Garland original: no singing, no dancing, no munchkins, etc. This is to i the good. An attempt to repeat the style of the Wizard of Oz' (can you imagine a 1985 version of 'Over the Rainbow"?) would have been doomed to failure and a very high cringe factor rating.
Instead, the film establishes its own style. Oz here is more like Narnia or Middle Earth dramatic scenery. gothic demons - and less like a picture postcard Fairy Land.
And the film is, in parts, pretty scary. When Dorothy goes to steal the Powder of Life from the Wicked Witch - and has to take it from a room full of her various heads ready to scream out the alarm — you have to grip your arm rest. And the living, rippling rock that moulds itself into different facial expressions of the Gnome King or his henchmen, is not the sort of thing which I would wish to be confronted with, when out walking over the hills.
My only complaint is Ozma, the good fairy princess, who is too 'nice' for words and a pain in the neck. Apart from her, a good evenng out. You travel round this country From shore to shining shore And I never cease to wonder The things I've heard, the things Chorus:
Yet those banks are made of marble With a guard on every door And the vaults are filled with That the workers sweated for.
I've seen the weary miner Scrub coal dust from his back And I've heard the miner's children Cry for coal to heat the shack Chorus: 1834.
The timespan covered is not quite as narrow as that, but three quarters of the book is indeed focused around 1825-34, the most productive decade of origin al thought among Socialist and Labour writers and leaders in Britain" and the immediate run-up to it.
The rest of it covers early communists like John Ball (a leader of the Peasants' Revolt of 1381), Thomas More, and Gerrar Winstanley ("the fiery soul of the Digger Movement" during th English Revolution of the 17th century).
The early 19th century in Britain was the time and place when the impact of the French Revolution - by far the greates popular revolution of all histor up to 1917 - was felt in the world's first industrial working class.
Beer tells us about Robert Owen, the pioneer of socialism through cooperatives; the beginnings of Chartism, the world's first labour movement; and the working class economists whom Marx hailed as "the proletarian opponents of Ricardo"
Beer, a socialist but hardly a Marxist, rejects the labour theory of value which David Ricardo developed scientifically from a bourgeois point of view; which early socialists turned against the bourgeoisie to claim "the full product of labour"; and which Marx transformed to lay the basis for his critique of capitalism. But he tells the story clearly and carefully:
I wouldn't buy the book: the illustrations, though profuse, are often small, murky, and not very interesting; and the pages fall out But order it through your library, I've seen the weary sailor Standing idly by the shore And I've heard the masters say There's no work here any more Chorus:
Let us rise and take our own Take what's owing, take our land Yes it's time we got together And together made our stand.
Then we blow up those banks o We'll shoot the guard on every do And we'll share out those vauits o That the workers sweated. for.
----- pull-quotes -----
Songs of liberty and: rebel lion