More Marxists in the councils
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-08-21Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
themselves in a strange situation. Not only there, expects you to know something are they occupying a position in the labour about what's going on. Part of the point of movement, they are also part of an admini- being a councillor is the ability to get stration whose job is to administer part of information that will be of use to people the capitalist system. Added to that is the outside the council chamber. Tell them huge amount of work that councillors are that all you're going to do is make revoluMilitant leaders (from left) Tony Mulhearn, Peter Taaffe. y Saunois, Ted Grant and Pat Wa Tony Saunois, Ted Grant and Pat Wall, with Les Huckfield (third from The the issue of Socialist Organiser devoted to local government left is a timely one.
Coming at a time when the fight against this year's round of cuts has, with one exception, collapsed, it details quite clearly the politics that lies behind that collapse -the politics that at the end of the day accepts that no real challenge can be made to the demands of the capitalist system for working class sacrifice.
Doubly
The local government left stand doubly condemned - not just because they threw in the towel before any serious fight but also because they managed to create the illusion that this time they really intended to do something.
The cynicism that this will breed in the labour movement among serious militants, especially among council workers, will make any fight next year that much harder to John O'Mahony also correctly argues that far from drawing conclusions about the futility of being in the Labour Party, Marxists should redouble their efforts to build a powerful tendency that can prevent the retreats from happening. As revolutionary socialists we should not be surprised that reformists act in a reformist way. If, in doing so, they derail the movement, then that is because we aren't strong enough to stop them. The onus is on us to become stronger, not on our reformist leopards (or should it be tame pussies) to change their spots. Of course, some will change under pressure, but it would be very foolish to base our strategy on it.
| sould, however, go further. Not only is it necessary for Marxists to be in the Labour Party, it is also necessary for them to be in the council chambers.
In the next period the main challenge to the Tories is going to come from local government if the leadership is there to provide it. Local councils also have the resources and the links, both with the trade unions and the wider movement to launch mass campaigns.
Just as it is illogical to leave the Labour Party to the right and soft left, it would be equally illogical to leave the local government field to the likes of Livingstone and Blunkett.
In arguing for Marxists to be in the council chambers, though, it is vital to make sure that they don't end up acting like the reformists they are setting out to challenge. John states that the local government left behave the way they do because they are not part of a Marxist organisation. This is undoubtedly true, but it doesn't explain why several people who would claim to be Marxists have gone the same way.
Strande Militants who are elected to councils find expected to do which cult to do anything else.
Council work can easily become a way of life. Apart from the demands made on you by the people you represent, councillors are deluged in a torrent of paper work about the day-to day running of a council -everything from re-grading claims to tenders for fish.
Danger Ending up accepting political responsibility for the administration is a real danger for Marxists on the council, especially if they are in an isolated position. Unless there is a forum where these councillors can regularly discuss the issues that arise and get guidance on them then there will always be the tendency to adapt to the surroundings that they find themselves in, Less easy to deal with is the problem of the workload. It isn't something that you can just ignore or have nothing to do with.
Trotsky imagined that as foreign minister in the Bolshevik government he would publish the secret treaties, make a few speeches and then shut up shop. The reality of the situation proved quite different, and so it is with being on the council The labour movement, having put you tionary speeches and that council papers are part of a plot to pull you off the straight and narrow, and you'll impress no-one.
Yet the sheer volume of the work can have an effect just as damaging as adapting politically to the situation. Council work can and does take up all the time available for political activity, and it is very difficult to lift yourself above the immediate tasks ahead. The tendency is to just get your head down and keep ploughing on.
In discussing the failure of the local government left to mount an effective challenge to the Tories and in mounting a challenge to the policies of that left, Socialist Organiser will need to do more than just criticise and put forward generally correct alternative policies. We will need to draw around us and sustain a sizeable group of councillors who will, in practice, provide an alternative to the reformism currently dominant in local government.
Confused Only when we begin to show that we are serious about doing this will we begin to attract the serious militants who are confused and disillusioned about the present retreats but who see no alternative.
If an issue is worth publishing a 40-page magazine about, then it's worth doing something about it. The discussion on the politics of the local government left is important. The discussion on what we are going to do about it is more important still.
PETE KEENLYSIDE FCHI with Les Huckfield lefty