SON THE The waiting game
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-08-21Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
Most of what you say about Grant and Militant (SO 238) is valid and valuable, but at one point where you quote an ex-RCP member there is a dangerous - though unstated implication which is totally erroneous.
"Ted's always been the same. Since 1945 he has been predicting a slump".
He has indeed, but whereas Healy constantly predicted one in the immediate future, for Grant it was always some time off.
I first came to know Ted in 1956. Ted at that time predicted a slump in 1964. Whereas Healy's "cataclysm tomorrow" analysis led to intense activism, Grant's insistence that it was eight years off produced a strategy of the waiting game I-ough several other members of the RSL, lost contact with Grant after '57. By '62 I heard that Ted had redone his sums and that "68 was the date to expect the slump.
The fundamental theory, that there would be a slump of 1930s dimensions; that the pattern of the Thirties, when even Ernie Bevin and Herbert Morrison were calling for Councils of Action, would be repeated; that a sizeable centrist movement would arise in the Labour Party and that that would present the revolutionaries with their opportunity; remained constant.
Though for the wrong economic reasons, Ted was at least right in predicting a radical upsurge in '68 (if one bears in mind the Paris events, the Prague Spring and reaction to these :68 he had However, by again redone his economic sums, and his group was predicting slump in the early to mid-70s. Once again the prospect of slump deferred made for inactivity in the present and Militant supporters explained their role in the LPYS, their non-involvement in anti-Vietnam War activities (or rather only partial involvement) and their coolness towards Paris and Prague events, on the grounds that the working class had yet to be roused by slump and premature involvement would build a barrier between Militant and the working class.
By 1970 the slump date was postponed to the late '70s; and no doubt by then they felt their predictions were fulfilled. However since the coming of the slump coincided with a down-turn of socialist activity (the miners" strike last year would have provided an admirable occasion for Labour rightists to call for councils of action under Ted's analysis, but instead it saw Labour Leftists deprecating action) I don't know how Ted's theories are being borne out.
That Militant has blossomed at the time of the slump seems to be despite, rather than because of, Ted's success this time in predicting a slump. Given the SLL boom in the mid '60s and the IS one in the mid "70s, there is no real reason to assume that Militant's present strength will hold for more than a few Fraternally, Laurens Otter