What Sthe Secular State?
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-08-21Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
Socialist Organiser supporters are debating whether we should allow for the existence of a modified Israeli-Jewish state alongside a Palestinian state or a wider Arab federation. These two statements (below, from Fatah; right, from the more left-wing DFLP) summarise what the Palestinian movement meant by a "democratic secular state' when it adopted the slogan in 1969. Pre-1948 Palestine - as defined during the British mandate - is the territory to be liberated, the territory where the democratic progressive state is to be created.
The liberated Palestine will be part of the Arab homeland and will not be another alien state within it. The eventual unity of Palestine with other Arab states will make boundary problems less relevant and will end the artificiality of the present status of Israel, and possibly that of Jordan as well.
Anti-imperialist
The new country will be anti-imperialist and will join the ranks of progressive revolutionary countries. Therefore, it will have to cut the present life-line links with, and the total dependence on the United States. Therefore, integration within the area will be the foremost prerequisite.
It should be quite obvious at this stage that the new Palestine discussed here is not Israelis since June 1967. The the occupied West Bank or the Gaza Strip or both. These are areas occupied by the homeland of the Palestinians usurped and colonised in 1948 is no less dear or important than the part occupied in 1967.
Besides the very existence of the racist oppressor state of Israel, based on the expulsion and forced exile of part of its citizens, even from one tiny Palestinian village is unacceptable to the revolution. Any arrangement accommodating the aggressor settler-state is unacceptable and temporary. Only the people of Palestine its Jews, Christians and Moslems - in a country that combines them all is permanent.
All the Jews, Moslems Christians living in Palestine or forcibly exiled from it will have the right to Palestinian citizenship. This guarantees the right of all exiled Palestinians to return to their land whether they have been born in Palestine or in exile and regardless of their present nationality.
Equally, this means that all Jewish Palestinians at the present Israelis - have the same right, provided, of course, that they reject Zionist racist chauvinism and fully agree to live as Palestinians in the new Palestine.
The revolution therefore rejects the supposition that only Jews who lived in Palestine prior to 1948 or prior to 1914 and their desendants are acceptable.
After all, [Moshe Dayan [minister of defence] and [Yigail] Allon [deputy premier] were born in Palestine before 1948 and they - with many of their colleagues are diehard racist Zionists who obviously do not qualify for a Palestinian status, whereas newcomers may be anti-Zionists and work ardently for the creation of a new Palestine Welcome In the interview reterred to earlier [published in alTaleea. June 1969], Abu Iyad, one of the officials of Fateh, reasserted that not only progressive anti-Zionist Jews but even present Lionists willing to abandon their racist ideology will be welcome as Palestinian citizens.
It is the belief of the revolution that the majority of the present Israeli Jews will change their attitudes and will subscribe to the new Palestine, especially after the oligarchic state machinery, economy, and military establishment are destroyed.
The call for a nonsectarian Palestine should not be confused with a multireligious, a polyreligious or a binational state. The new Palestine is not to be built around three state religions or two nationalities. Rather, it will simply provide freedom from religious oppression of any group by another and freedom to practice religion without discrimination. No rigidification of religious lines is desired by the revolution. No hard and fast religious distribution of political offices and other important jobs is envisioned.
Furthermore, religious and ethnic lines clearly cross in Palestine so as to make the term binational and the ArabJewish dichotomy meaningless, or at best quite dubious.
The majority of Jews in Palestine today are Arab Jews euphemistically called Oriental Jews by the Zionists. Therefore, Palestine combines Jewish, Christian and Moslem Arabs as well as non-Arab Jews (Western Jews). THE struggle for a popular democratic solution for the Palestinian and Israeli questions to be based on the liquidation of the Zionist entity exemplified in all the government establishments (army, administration, police) and all the chauvinistic Zionist polltical and labour organisations.