[CPSA demonst Birmingham. Photo: John Harris. IFL. SOCIETY…]
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-08-21Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 11
CPSA demonst Birmingham. Photo: John Harris. IFL. SOCIETY "PUBICSERVANTS NOTHIP secretary, CPSA British Library London branch, in personal capacity)
EVER since the ban on union membership at GCHQ was announced in January 1984, the leaders of the Civil Service unions have been intent on keeping tight control of the campaign for a restoration of members' rights. But their "campaign' of legal actions, public relations and humble petition has been a dismal failure in achieving its supposed aim.
The campaign has had three stages. The first was between the announcement of the ban and its imposition on March 1 1984 — the date by which GCHQ staff were required to sign one of the two "options" - to give up their union, or to seek a transfer to another Civil Service post.
During that time, the General Secretaries of the major unions involve (CPSA, CSU and SCPS), led by Alistair Graham of the CPSA and with Len Murray's involvement, were offering the government a "no disruption" deal at GCHQ. When the Tories kicked them in the teeth, Graham and Murray crawled off the fence to support - at three days notice — mass industrial action on February 28.
In spite of the chaos caused by the leaders confused and contradictory positions in the weeks leading up to that day, the day of action itself was extremely successful, mobilising workers ban unions at all the unsurprisingly made no headway whatsoever.
The third stage, the one we are now in, arose somewhat accidentally as far as the union leaders were concerned. After the High Court's ruling that the ban had been illegally imposed, the unions recruited re-recruited a number of members at GCHQ.
Some have again resigned, following the later court judgements, but the remainder — the 90 or so staff who in 1984 signed "Option A" to give up their rights and have since changed their minds - form the group now under threat of disciplinary action. It is widely expected that such action will involve sackings.
The union bureaucracy s response to this development has been, once again, to seek a deal. It appears, indeed, that a possible deal was discussed in secret talks between the General Secretaries and Robert Armstrong (the head of the Civil Service) as long ago as May, What was proposed was that a "ring fence' be erected around the existing union members at GCHQ: in return for the Tores not taking action against these individuals, the unions would promise not to try and recruit other staff. In other words, apart from continuing with their tiny minority of members there, the unions would accept the ban at GCHQ.
Now the government has apparently again rejected the union leaders' advances to them. Eighteen months after the original ban, it may be difficult to get an effective response from the labour movement to any sackings - but on the other hand, such a move might revitalise the campaign in a way that the bureaucracy would find hard to control. It is presumably on these calculations that the government's next move depends.
If there are sackings trade unionists be organise immediate strike action. But on their performance to date, we shouldn't anticipate a bold, clear lead from Alistair Graham and his fellow "New Realists"*