UK top ten
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-09-12Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
According to the UK South Africa Trade Association, there are about 1,200 UK companies with investments in South Africa, worth about £5,000 million at current values. British indirect investments are estimated to be worth £6,000 million.
Between 45 and 45% of all foreign investment in South Africa is British. The UK is the third largest source of imports, The list of companies with investments there includes Rowntree Mackintosh and Beechams - and where the company names are not well known, the products often are: Ever Ready Batteries (Hanson Trust), Watney's (Grand MetropoliUKSATA comments: "British investment is more profitable than most other areas of Monday September 16 at 8.00 p.m.
Red Rose Club, 129 Seven Sisters Rd. military force. Miners struck and some miners died resisting martial law in 1981.
The Polish miners won't be represented in Arthur's new miners' international by Solidarnosc, but by the official government fake unions which have nothing in common with if the government banned trad unions and locked up trade union militants, abolishing all the rights and liberties won in Britain over the last eight centureis, at the same time taking absolute control of the mec and most other things in societ when Thatcher sent her militarised squads of police into the coalfields during the miners' strike. They should tell Arthur Scargill to stop hobnobbing with the anti-working class scab unions of the Stalinist police state. Top 10 UK Barclays Standard Chartered Bank Lonrho BTR (including Dunlop) Courtaulds Unilever (including Brool British Electric Traction General Electric Co.
Shell International BOC Group and third largest export market.
tan).
investment."
Source: Labour companies in South Africa by numbers employed 26,338 21,716 10,482 7,690 7,633 7,317 7,200 6,854 5,637 5,433 in South Africa British overseas London Socialist Organiser Public Meeting AFRICA: BLACK WORKERS THE CHAINS Speaker: Martin Thomas
Scan page 5
The third issue of Socialist Organiser magazine — which is devoted to South Africa - has been given a name of its own: 'Workers' Liberty". • Why Workers' Liberty? The name sums up our politics and spells out what distinguishes Socialist Organiser Liberty? Liberty from economic exploitation by capitalism, but also from state tyranny. The word has an archaic ring to it today. One reason for this is that the idea itself has either been downgraded or entirely excised by large sections of the socialist movement as an aspiration of socialists. The Marxism of Marx and Engels, Lenin and Trotsky stands for a working class revolution which will destroy the state and immediately abolish it in anything like the bureaucratic form it assumes in class society, and immediately replace it by a state of a new type, actively controlled and administered by the majority — not a state in the old sense but a semi-state that will then wither and die as Socialist Worker Review has attacked Socialist Organiser for proposing that the South African trades unions should organise an independent workers' party. Tom Rigby responds to Alex Callinicos.
Socialist Worker Review has launched an attack on Socialist Organiser in response to our call for an independent workers" party in South Africa. Alex Callinicos writes:
*Any such quasi-syndicalist strategy fails to confront the fact that the mass of black trade unionists are likely to look towards either the ANC or the black consciousness movement for political leadership. African nationalism can only be challenged politically"
Apart from the basic absurdity of describing a call for the formation of a political party as "syndicalist, Callinicos's article brings out more or less explicitly the bedrock of the SWP's politics.
For Socialst Worker the only way in which it is possible to challenge the leadership of the mass movement - whether the Labour Party in Britain, or South Africa's ANC — is to build an 'alternative' through lowlevel propaganda and one-by-one recruitment to a seltproclaimed revolutionary' party.
Necessary
Well, a revolutionary party is necessary. In South Africa right now a working class revolution is possible according to the classic pattern of the permanent revolution - a revolution in which the working class combines with and leads the rural poor in a joint movement against reaction in the course of which the working class fights for workers' power. For this potential development to become a practical possibility, a revolutionary working class party, like the Bolshevik Party of Lenin and Trotsky, is necessary. The tragedy is that it doesn't exist.
What exists in South Africa is a Stalinist party exerting a heavy influence on the ANC. The Stalinist party is opposed to the programme of immediate struggle for workers power in South Africa, talking instead of a revolution by stages and seeing Photo: IDAF are settled with the nationalist organisations like the ANC.
Anything other than what Socialist Worker calls "the primitive accumulation of cadres" is pointless and a diversion. The mass workers' movement must wait for the cadres to be "accumulated" before it can go on from trade unionism to politics.
This is where Socialist Worker misses the point. Socialist Organiser's call for the formation of a workers' party points to the vital next step in the development of the workers' movement in South Atrica.
Only along that road can the existing workers'. movement, with all its existing unevenness and contradictions, develop.
The level of struggle is such that the trade unions are being drawn into politics whether they like it or not. The question is will they be sucked in behind the UDF and subordinated to its Frederick Engels back in the 1890s. When the Christian Socialist ILP of Keir Hardy got going in 1893 Engels argued that serious revolutionaries should abandon the sectarian Marxist party, the Social Democratic Federation and join the ILP. This was the real trade union-based workers' movement moving itself forward. The job of Marxists was to help them, to "go through the experiences" with them and thus help the mass working class movement develop towards independent revolutionary politics.
Defeatist
Callinicos can see dimly what the problem is. He talks of a basic identification with the ANC from the mass of the workers being coupled with distrust of the ANC from a large section of the best militants. But the solution he puts forward is not an answer for the class and their politics — — parallel the right wing here.
Parallels
Socialist Worker says to the left in the Labour Party "go on, leave Labour, nothing can be done to remake the mass labour movement. We must start from scratch" and in doing this, Socialist Worker unwillingingly parallels the arguments of the Labour Party right who say get out.
On this hangs an interesting point. Supporters of Socialist Worker - indifferent alike to the recent lessons of Brazil and to the classic positions of the Marxist movement - have accused Socialist Organiser of trying to visit the sins of the British labour movement on the South African workers by way of advocating the creation of a unintentionally Labour Party there. But it is Socialist Worker who seek to transplant their own mini-scale "build-the-sect" schema into South Africa. And it is in South Africa — where nothing is more urgent than the immediate development of working class politics rooted in the mass trade union movement - that the irrelevance and futility of these politics becomes self-evident and blatant.
Irrelevance
Think about this, comrades in Socialist Worker. It is not enough for Marxists simply to build up an organisation, recruiting one by one. Such a cadre organisation can be a wasteful irrelevance, a mere sect on the sidelines of history unless ir arms itself with, and fights constantly for a revolutionary perspective for the whole mass working class movement - whether in Britain or South Africa. The prime and irreplaceable job of revolutionaries is to gear up the mass movement for battle and in the course of the battles imposed on the mass movement win people to revolutionary politics not just in ones and twos but in hundreds and thousands.
Leadership In South Africa the situation cries out for a workers' party to take the leadership of the struggle of the oppressed blacks. It cries out for a line of march for the black working class as a whole.
A revolutionary organisation that cannot map out a line of march for the class as a whole -that can show no way of challenging the existing nationalist and Stalinist leadership - such an organisation is not revolutionary at all.