Workers' Liberty Breaking the chains
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-09-12Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
the "present stage" as one in which the working class subordinates itself to middle class and other allies against apartheid.
Nothing is more urgent for the South African working class right now than to build a revolutionary working class party committed to fight for a working class revolution as the alternative to apartheid. But how can such a party emerge, how can the small number of already conscious Marxist revolutionaries built it? By way of recruiting ones and twos debates with the ANC whose political leadership of the struggle is accepted "for now" -or by way of pointing out the necessary way forward for the existing mass workers' organisations, the trade unions, politically challenging the Stalinists and nationalists and building a revolutionary movement by way of that work? The implicit answer of Callinicos is course. Nothing can be done until the "political. questions" cross-class alliance or are the black workers to build their own independent political voice?
Inspiring
Learn from the experience of history, comrade Callinicos! Look at the inspiring growth of the Workers' Party of Brazil out of the unions. Or learn from the books of the Marxist movement - for example, from the call raised by the Marxists in the USA that the new, vigorous industrial unions created in the 1930s in great industrial battles should go on immediately to form their own working class party. However limited such a party would be at the beginning by the political immaturity of the workers it would mark a giant step towards independent working class politics. The job of the Marxists was to help push the movement forward according to its own necessary class logic and dynamic.
Or if Trotsky in the '30s the movement as a whole. It is the answer of a sectarian running away from the mass working class movement.
Callinicos is passively accepting utterly defeatist conclusions that for the decisive next period the broad independent workers" movement will be dominated by the ANC.
He is accepting that politics' is the sphere of the middle class nationalists and the CP class collaborationist allies, while a non-political trade union movement is all the working class can aspire to.
All that is possible for revolutionary socialists to to build a tiny cadre organistion. In saying this, Socialist Worker are actually running in parallel to the ANC/CP who have denounced people like Joe Foster, general secretary of FOSATU, the largest union federation, for questioning the idea that the CP is the party of the working class.
There is a parallel between Socialist Workers's politics for South Africa and its politics for Britain — right down to the way politically. page 3 of the magazine: society evolves towards socialism. beginning in January 1986. WORKERS' LIBERTY Black workers and the struggle Workers' Liberty on South Africa. 75p plus p&p from: 214 Sickert Court, London N1 2SY.
243 September 12 1985 Page
Scan page 6
- Martin Barclay looks at the history of the Welsh mi A MILITANT, SOC IE South Wales coalfield's reputa- bible of a whole generation of mili- towards Marxism. Commission on the mines The com- icte of Puccin of Carmanu THE South Wales coalfield's reputatation of militancy was born in the period before World War 1. The old pattern of class collaboration organised through the Chapel and Liberal politics was being challenged. Strikers were beginning to turn to riot and to new ideas of industrial militancy, socialism and syndicalism.
The Unofficial Reform Committee emerged from the strikes of 1910-11 to produce the pamphlet "The Miners' Next Step':
It called for a reconstruction of the union — the South Wales Miners' Federation (SWMF, known as 'the Fed') — as a broad-based Industrial Union involving all miners and quarrymen. The new union was to be centralised, with rank and file control over negotiations through the ballot.
The pamphlet contains a sweeping criticism of the conciliatory leadership of the SWMF, and calls for a politically conscious workforce striving for immediate concessions - a minimum wage and a seven hour day — but also for the gradual elimination of the apitatit by direct workers" control.
The Miners' Next Step became bible of tants.
Its authors included men like Noah Ablett and Noah Rees who had picked up Marxist and syndicalist ideas when financed by the union to go to Ruskin College, Oxford.
They weren't crude syndicalists, (i.e. people seeing a new society as being achieved exclusively through trade union action) but they did lay the main emphasis on industrial action, and they saw it as separate from political action. They also underestimated the ability of the state to intervene in strikes to break them or force conciliation on the strikers.
Education Through the Plebs League they up education classes for miners drive home their ideas.
Noah Ablett, A.J. Cook and Arthur Horner were three militants from that period who later became very promiment. All three 'had religion' in their youth and were known as 'boy preachers'. From a mixture of Christianity and vague socialism they evolved towards Marxism.
Horner was called up in 1918 but he escaped to Dublin to join James Connolly's Citizen Army. He was arrested and imprisoned on his return - prison as well as chapel formed these militants.
Both Horner and Ablett opposed the First World War on the grounds that it was an imperialist war. Ablett played a large part in the anti-war activity organised by the Rhondda Socialist Society, which later became the South Wales Socialist Society (SWSS) and played a part in the negotiations to form a Communist Party in 1920. (Though Ablett himself never joined the CP).
In 1919, on a wave of industrial militancy, Ablett and Cook were elected miners' agents. Horner was elected checkweigher for the Maerdy Lodge while he was still in prison. Agitation by the Lodge plus a hunger strike by Horner got him released.
Militancy focused around demands to nationalise the mines and for a 30% wage claim. A national strike was headed off when the prime minister, Lloyd George, set up the Sankey Commission on the mines. The commission came out for the miners' claim - but Lloyd George, having escaped the strike, ignored it.
Meanwhile agitation against British intervention against Soviet Russia led to the formation of the 'Hands Off Russia' Committee and Councils of Action against intervention. There was widespread sympathy for the first workers' state and admiration for Bolshevik politics.
Urged on by the Communist International (Comintern), various political groups formed the Communist Party of Great Britain in 1920. Horner and Cook became founder members of the Party, though Cook left after only a year to rejoin the left-reformist Independent -Rounded-out The CP could, and for a period did, round out the semi-syndicalst ideas of militants like Horner into fully-formed revolutionary politics. For this progressive role of the CP, its international connections - its links with the experience of the revolutionary Marxists of Russia, of Germany, and other countries — were vital.
The tragedy was to be that the CP: in the West developed too late to pre vent the isolation of the Russian Revo lution; the isolated revolution degen erated; and the Stalin faction, rising or the basis of that degeneration, turned the international Communist move ment from an instrument of enlighte ment to one of corruption.
Labour
At the same time as the CP developed, the Labour Party also grew massively as the working class, fed with wartime promises of 'a land fit for heroes, looked around for alternatives. In the 1922 election, South Wales went Labour for the first time at the expense of the Liberals. The CP made its presence felt through individual membership of the Labour Party (its major component group, the BSP, had been affiliated to the Labour Party and Communists were not definitely banned from Labour Party membership until 1925), but it made its greatest gains through the SWMF.