Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

From lock out to general strike

Socialist Organiser no. 243, 12 September 1985 · scan pp. 6–7 · about 1,460 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 6

South i Wales suffered from the general dislocation of the British economy after the War, and as the biggest exporting coalfield it suffered doubly because of competition with cheaper European coal. In 1921 the miners were defeated in a national lockout. This meant a return of the mines to the private owners from wartime government control, and a return to the old district wage agreements.

South Wales wage rates, the highest in Britain before the lockout. became the lowest afterwards.

The SWMF conference passed a resolution calling for affiliation to the Red International of Labour Unions (RILU) set up by the Comintern. It was the only British union to do so (though the affiliation was conditional on a ballot of the workforce which was never carried out by the Executive).

As the workforce was cut in the slump after 1921, so the membership of 'the Fed' fell. The CP and the trade union lefts launched 'back to the union' campaigns and set up the Miners' Minority Movement' in 1924, with Nat Watkins from South Wales as its secretary.

Its immediate demands were for reform of the Fed along the lines of 'The Miners' Next Step'; affiliation to RILU; a weekly wage equivalent to the 1914 real wage; and a six hour shift.

The MMM, with its largest base in South Wales, became the largest section of the national Minority Movement (MM) formed in August 1924.

The CP was the main moving force, but it aimed to create a rank and file movement which could draw in a broader current of left-wingers in the The MMM scored its first major success soon after its formation when the post of General Secretary of the Miners' Federation of Great Britain (MFGB) became vacant. A meeting of the MMM in Cardiff nominated Cook for the post. (Ablett was the other possible choice, but by now he was an alcoholic, a fate which befell many trade union leaders). Cook was elected and the SWMF endorsed the full programme of the MMM.

The move to the left within the unions reached a peak in 1924. On a national level, support for the MMM had grown - by 1925 200 local groups had been set up and 16 lodges had affiliated. At the TUC in 1924 the MMM, via the SWMF, had introduced a scheme to amalgamate existing unions into industrial unions. Another scheme to bolster the powers of the General of the TUC was passed.

Neither of these schemes had any definite proposals as to how to achieve their aim — which allowed the General Council to drop them later.

The left was making progress - bur this progress was to prove shaky because the CP, under Stalin's influence, had come to believe that the TUC leadership could be trusted after the election of Cook, Alonzo Swales and other left-wingers on to the General Council and the departure of rightwingers like Jimmy Thomas into the Labour government.

In 1925 when a Tory government was forced to intervene when the coalowners attempted to bring back an eight hour day in July. On 'Red Friday" - faced with a national strike - the months.

This was victory — but it only provided a breathing space before the main struggle in 1926.

From January 1926 the MM prepared a plan of campaign for when the coal subsidy ran out in May. At a National Conference of Action in March — less than two months from the inevitable confrontation - the details were hammered out.

The main point was to extend the Triple Alliance (miners, rail, transport) and to call for the General Council to take over the leadership of the Alliance *on behalf of the whole working class movement". it also called for the formation of local Councils of Action and Workers Defence Corps as a separate initiative from the TUC.

If the General Council moved to the head of the Industrial Alliance, then the CP thought they would be able to subject them to rank and file control. If they failed, then the MM would step in and exercise control.

In fact the General Council did not start preparations until three days before the General Strike - and meantime the MM had failed to take an independent leading role. During the strike the MM leaders dispersed from London. With the CP leadership dispersed or arrested, the only national leadership was provided by the TUC.

Despite the feeble leadership the strike was strong. The more isolated mining villages in South Wales, like Maerdy or Bedlinog, were dominated by the Councils of Action and the strike was 100%.

In the larger commercial valley towns. like Pontypridd, the Councils were much weaker and the police were able to arrest the leading Communists in safety.

In Maerdy the police merely blocked off the roads leading to the village and left the strikers to their own devices. The Council of Action gradually took on the functions of a soviet (workers' council), but because of the isolation of Maerdy and places like it, the soviet virus failed to spread. The general strike didn't last long enough for anything but a very iocalised challenge to the state to emerge.

| ragically, because of the Stalinist influence, the lefts in the MM failed to present an alternative perspective. Cook, for example, had tremendous popular support, but he was politically indecisive and theoretically woolly, and the CP went along with him.

While the TUC lefts dithered, the right wingers offered tradition, experience and routine - and were of course backed up by bourgeois society.

The CP was very reluctant to criticise the General Council, let alone the lefts. It was very confused about the nature of the strike. Norner says in his autobiography ('Incorrigeable Rebel') "We could have won if the General Strike had been seriously fought by the TUC General Counci."

This shows not only faith in the ability of the TUC to win such a battle, but also that he saw the struggle as an industrial strike writ large. He would probably have agreed with the General Council when they said they weren't challenging the constitution!

After the General Strike the miners stayed out through the summer, only to be starved back in November. Horner put forward a policy of intensifying the strike. This was taken up by the SWMF and then the MFGB, but the miners couldn't do what they General Strike had failed to do and it only served to delay the end of the strike.

The defeat was driven home with a 14% reduction in wages, an eight hour day, an unofficial blacklist that was to keep militants out of a job until the Second World War, and the formation of a rival company union centred in Notts but with a base in one or two pits in South Wales.

The mining communities, weighed down by accumulated debts, were faced with pit closures and life on the dole. Poverty gripped the mining villages in the1920s

Scan page 7

Saa sel Miners from Mountain Ash Meanwhile, the Fed was _under pressure. By 1928 its membership was less than half the workforce, and the company union (SWMIU) was growing.

Established after the General Strike funded by the coalowners who deliberately engineered lockouts to allow it to gain a foothold in certain pits. The Fed realised that if it was to meet this challenge and get the men back into the union it would have to organise the unemployed.

In 1934 the union was reorganised — the districts were made more representative, the rank and file executive excluded the district agents, and unemployed miners were allowed up to 25% representation on lodge committees. As the Executive was more in touch with rank and file feeling, it became more militant and for a while the hopes of 'The Miners' Next Step' seemed realised.

Horner was drafted in from the anthracite area, where he had been elected agent, to deal with the company union in its strongest base -the Taff Merthyr pit.

Build

Loudspeaker vans, leaflets and private conversations were used to build up the Federation membership to two-thirds of the workforce. Eventually the coalowner forced a strike and scab labour was brought in.

Women played the biggest part on the picket lines. First they abused and jeered at the scabs. After a while they let the scab procession pass in complete silence and carried wreaths — morally these were dead men.

The company union was eventually driven out by the 'stay-down' strikes. In October 1935, copying a Hungarian strike, 78 men in the Nine Mile Point colliery stayed down at the end of their shift.

At first the Fed ignored this new

----- pull-quotes -----

government extended the subsidy the industry was receiving for another nine

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 243

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →