Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Stalinism in the coalfields

Socialist Organiser no. 243, 12 September 1985 · scan p. 7 · about 1,151 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

HE CP made rapid gains in 1926embership rose from 6,000 to nearly 1,000 by December. But then it fell to 500 by 1928.

They made gains because of the very avious sell-out by the TUC. The CP iticised the General Council and even le lefts after the event — but still connued to promote the Anglo-Russian ommittee, set up by the General ouncil and its Russian equivalent to romote international trade union nity.

To continue this pact when the eneral Council had quite openly sold it was criminal. Criticism was effecvely emasculated at a time when the eneral Council should have been aringly exposed.

Instead Stalin's supporters in the omintern refused to pull out of the immittee, replacing revolutionary ›litics with diplomacy. In Russia, rotsky and the Left Opposition had ten arguing fiercely for a more indeendent policy by the British CP. But e dominant Stalin faction had no faith a small revolutionary party - ever ractical-minded' ' it preferred its liance with the TUC bureaucrats, en at the expense of blurring the P's politics. In the end the Russian ommunist trade unionists were ignoiniously booted out of the alliance by e TUC strike-saboteurs!

Leadership

After 1926 the CP was to concentrate • the fight for the leadership of the nion. The need for an independent olitical leadership became subordined to the election of Pers. The dwindling MMM became an electoral machine, tightly under CP control.

The MM finally collapsed with the introduction of ultra-left "Third Period" policies after 1928. Stalin, disappointed in his efforts to win bourgeois and bureaucratic allies, now said that the Labour Party and the trade unions had become 'social fascist' organisations. Any united front with them was out of the question - the tiny CP would assume sole leadership of the revolutionary masses immediately!

Blunder

The only result of this blunder was that the CP became even more isolated. In fact the MMM leaders recognised the threat to all their previous work and were reluctant to take up the new policy. Nevertheless, after the leadership was reshuffled the new line was adopted.

Horner was opposed to the policy of indiscriminate creation of separate *revolutionary' unions and in 1931 he came out against attempts to continue a strike unofficially after it had been called off by the Executive. The doctrine of 'Hornerism' (i.e. reformism) was severely criticised in the party press and the Politbureau censured this 'deviancy' in 1929.

As mass unemployment spread, anyone who kept a job could be seen as a bosses' stooge and a class traitor. Militants were easily victimised. The CP was becoming a party of the unemployed. It was only logical to turn from what they saw as the 'social Fascist' trade unions to work among the unemployed.

As crisis turned to slump in the early "30s, the valleys were devastated. With unemployment came depopulation, the run-down of social services, overcrowded housing and declining standards of health.

The eastern half of the coalfield was hit worst, with unemployment averaging 44.5%. The western anthracite area was less severely hit with 28.6%. The towns on the northern edge of the coalfield — Merthyr, Dowlais, Brynmawr, Ebbw Vale — became industrial deserts with unemployment running at 60-70%., The CP responded, through the National Unemployed Workers' Movement (NUWM), with a series of Hunger Marches demanding restoration of the cuts in dole carried out by the National Government and the abolition of the Means Test.

Faced with new, stricter, regulations for the Means Test in 1934, the SWMF organised a conference on unemployment in January 1935. From this conference, 'united front' committees on unemployment were set up.

Demonstrations

In February there were massive demonstrations against the new rules and whole communities came out on the streets - up to 100,000 in the Rhondda, 50,000 in Aberdare. They managed to postpone the new regulations, but not stop them.

After about 1935, Stalin's line changed. He called for "Popular Fronts" with bourgeois liberals. The British CP played down its politics and immersed itself in broad movements.

From 1936 the Spanish Civil War became the great issue. The CP insisted it was strictly an issue of democracy versus fascism' — which in Spain meant that they suppressed revolutionary workers and peasants going too far".

Aid In South Wales, Will Paynter promoted 'non-political' "Aid for Spain' committees which made door to door collections for food and money for Republican Spain.

Spain was a tremendously popular cause in the valleys. Solidarity with the Republicans was expressed through the lodge and combine committees and eventually endorsed by the SWMF, which set up Spanish Aid Committees' involving both Labour Party and CP supporters.

116 miners volunteered for the International Brigade, forming the largest single regional-occupational group in the British Battalion.

Will Paynter commented on the political differences in the Republican camp in Spain in a letter to Horner:

*There is a section who would promote disloyalty and disunity (i.e. the Anarchists and POUM, who wanted a socialist revolution) but they are substantilaly uninfluential and futile... This section will be crushed.."

So they were: the Stalinists assassinated POUM leader Andres Nin and many others. But the CP was able to persuade most of its volunteers to go along with this. They saw themselves as anti-fascists first and revolutionaries second. weapon, but the action sparked off a wave of pit occupations which completely defeated the SWMiU in some pits.

Following these events, in May 1936, Horner was elected presidnet of the SWMF, the first Communist te hold the position. He eventually rebuilt the membership and negotiated agreements to exclude the SWMIU from the coalfield.

But the CP was moving right, and Horner was condemned as a poacher turned gamekeeper for accepting one agreement which recognised the Fed in return for a no-strike clause lasting five years. He felt this was 'scientifically applied class struggle' as it entailed no 'undue loss of expenditure or man-power Paynter was more blunt:

"Politics take second place to the trade union job, and if and when they conflict, as they did on occasion for Horner and myself, loyalty to the trade union and its decisions came first."

In the close-knit, single-industry communities the union provided an all-round service of advice and assistance. Local leaders provided social and. political leadership - and acted as professional letter-writers. Along with this responsibility went 'respectability" and the climb upwards from 'village elder" to the local council and eventually Parliament.

Political differences? Of course these trade union worthies did wear different hats coloured various shades of pink. To resist the social pressures was a difficult job - and one which by 1936 the CP was no longer capable of doing.

And so Communists like Horner and Paynter found themselves in the same position as those respectable bureaucrats whom they had criticised in "The Miners' next Step' A generation of militants had been tamed. But the next generation can learn from the experience.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 243

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →