Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Compromise for co-existance

Socialist Organiser no. 243, 12 September 1985 · scan p. 8 · about 1,268 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

Crowd in Tel-Aviv on November 29, 1947 celebrating the United Nations decision on a partition plan. Letter an Israeli Si Greenstein's Organiser.

The discussion in Socialist Organiser has shown a welcome and helpful realisation that the problem of the Palestinians and Israel can be solved only by an awareness of the rights and needs of both contenders. Indeed, only if British socialists maintain an even-handed attitude can they play a constructive role in helping the sides to come together.

It is all the more sad therefore to see in your pages also the oftrehearsed outpourings of Tony Greenstein calling for the destruction of Israel with the complete denial of Jewish national rights (Socialist Organiser, 7 August).

None are as blind as those who will not see, but for the genuinely-concerned, some points are worth restating.

In complete contradiction to what Tony Greenstein writes, MAPAM's position in regard to the Palestinian question has its roots in the long-held view that the historic Land of Israel is the common homeland of two peoples — the Jewish people returning and the Palestinian Arabs living there.

Cooperation

As socialists, in the '30s the hope was cherished that there might be cooperation with the Arab working class over the heads of their feudal rulers, but of course national solidarity always prevailed. Today, MAPA fully recognises the rights of the Palestinians to political, national sovereignty and in the wake of a peace agreement with Jordan and the Palestinians, the Palestinians themselves should decide whether they want an independent state, federation with Jordan, a theocracy, monarchy imroni UK cialist Zion article in representative of MAPAM, st party, replies to Tony recent issue of or what-have-you.

For Tony Greenstein to advocate a concrete solution on their behalf smacks of arrogance.

National liberation movements are, by definition, concerned about solving the problems of their own peoples in a given historical context. As the national liberation movement of the Jewish people, the Zionist movement is concerned with the Jewish problem, and Israel was not chosen arbitrarily by spinning a globe and blindly sticking in a pin.

Antagonism

Similarly, the national liberation movement of the Palestinians is not, primarily, worried about the needs of the Eskimos, Red Indians or Corsicans. This implies neither indifference nor opposition and has nothing whatsoever to do with racism.

The antagonism of the Jews and Palestinians is rooted in the fact that for close on a century they have been competing for the same plot of land with both sides having been oppressor and oppressed. On this it is worth quoting the Jewish philosopher Martin Buber, who said that when two just causes meet there are two possible outcomes — tragedy or compromise.

In order to lessen the great tension which has accumulated, we need to separate; not 'it's all mine' ' not one instead of the othre, but two peoples living side by side. As the dynamic of national conflict has brought increasing violence and hate, so we may hope that a dynamic of peace will slowly but surely engender co-operation and a feeling of security for all.

One of the proposals glibly propounded is that of a *democratic secular Palestine' where Jews would also 'enjoy all the same religious, cultural and individual rights as others'. Is the experience of South Lebanon, where the PLO ruled for years over Shi'ites and others, to serve as an example? Where in the Arab world might we see such an example?

In fact this is a code which hides more than it reveals. Other codes like 'free trade' sound good because anything 'free' sounds attractive. In the case of the democratic secular state, the talk is of Christians, Muslims and Jews; the context makes it clear that here the Jews are considered, like the others, only a religious, not a secular, group.

In other words, it is a cover for another national Arab state instead of the only national Jewish state in the world.

In utterly absurd contradiction of the situation, Tony Greenstein writes that "the Israeli working class has been unable to create its own trade unions, still less a Party". Similarly, to call the Histadruth "the largest employers' federation" is completely ridiculous, it being nothing of the kind.

The Socialist-Zionist movement, as part of the broadly-based Zionist movement, has made great gains in giving the whole movement a socially positive content. New forms of social organisation have been evolved, with great measures of equality, Talia LT 20 ITO I would like to take up Bob Fine on two historical points in his article on Nelson Mandela in a recent issue.

When you mention that Mandela and others voted for the expulsion of the Communist Party from the African National Congress you forget to give the reasons. The South African CP supported the Afrikaner Nationalists, not only during the Hitler-Stalin Pact period, but also again in the immediate prelude to Dr Malan's accession to power.

Though by the time that Mandela voted for the expulsion, the CP and the ANC were, as you say, both supporting the Smuts government's war efforts, the ANC did so with considerably less enthusiasm and without making the same wholesale compromises. It is easy to understand that the ANC would have been bitter at Stalinist policy in the immediately preyou You also don't metion that preceding period.

many members of the South African CP resigned from the party over the issue. Indeed it has been claimed that a majority of members did. The ANC expulsions were in a sense part of a split in the SACP.

There were several accounts of this written in the '50s. Offhand the only person I can recall as being one of the Communists who resigned and then sided with the ANC is Fr. Michael Scott, who later founded the Africa Bureau (the same Fr. Michael Scott who was a cosponsor of the Committee of 100).

I am fairly certain that all the then black members of the SACP were among those who left.

When you talk about the divorce between the early ANC and trade unionism you seem forget three points:

There were trade unions founded in the '20s, and though the founders were members of the ANC, they were not leading members.

There was an attempt, in which the ANC was an active sponsor, to unite the unions, the ANC and other organisations in an African Convention. The fact that it broke down was by no means exclusively the fault of the ANC.

Right up until the war, indeed in the mines until this day, the majority of black workers were/ are hired on a six months contract system. In the '20s this system was run with chiefs sending a son or sub-chief and a party of tribesman, under contract, to the employer.

The temporary nature of contract employment would militate against trade unionism and the fact that such gangs were led by representatives of tribal chiefs would mean that only if socialists were prepared to take the class struggle into the tribe themselves and in so doing break down the only organs of black power there were, was a class based trade unionism possible.

I have never heard of any socialists in the '20s who were prepared to present such a direct challenge to tribalism. After the '20s the tribes were under assault from the white establishment and quisling tribal chiefs were being appointed (which is why trade unionism started then) and why the ANC had links to the old tribal structure, then began, albeit as a side issue, to approve of and sponsor trade unions.

Fraternally, LAURENS OTTER

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 243

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →