With the Palestinians Against Arab chauvinism
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-09-12Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
At a national Editorial Board meeting on Sunday September 8, Socialist Organiser decided to change its long-standing accessment of the Arab-Jewish conflict in Palestine and to adopt new proposals for siving that conflict. A motion advocating two states for Jew and Arabs in Palestine was carried against one calling for a single democratic state.
For many years the majority of Socialist Organiser supporters have subscribed to a version of the democratic secular state position - that the answer to the -Arab-Jewish conflict is a single democratic state in which all are equal citizens.
Following a long and wide-ranging debate - it began six years ago - Socialist Organiser has decided that the secular democratic state is an unattainable fantasy. The creation of such a state by amalgamation of the two bitterly warring peoples as equal citizens in a common territory is inconceivable.
Although the democratic secular state appears to offer reconciliation between the two peoples and therefore to point towards working class unity, in fact it does icialist Organiser 243 Septembe not and cannot do that. In reality it denies the national rights of the Jews.
The socialist revolution itself is much nearer than the merging of the national identities of the Jewish and Arab Palestinians in a common secular state. At best it is a consoling fantasy. At worst it is a propaganda weapon of Arab nationalists, the logic of whose position is the conquest and driving out of the Jews.
In reality there is a stark choice in Palestine. In broad terms only two solutions are possible. Either drive out (or massacre the Jews, thus restoring the land to the Palestinian Arabs, or divide the disputed territory. This being so, the choice for socialists must be advocacy of compromise and division or redivision of the disimmense practica dicules ne other democratic or socialist solution is conceivable. Rejection of Zionist expansion and condemnation of the Israeli treatment of the Arabs inside pre-1967 Israel and on the West Bank is common ground on the left; so should be rejection of the programme of Arab nationalism and revanchism in all its varients, including the democratic secular state, which is understood by its Arab nationalist advocates as a Palestinian Arab state with no more than religious rights for Jews on a confessional basis.
Socialist Organiser continues to support the oppressed and displaced Palestinians in their struggle for justice - but we do it from our own class standpoint and programme, not by way of endorsing Arab nationalism and revanchism wrapped up in coisoling fantasies. We support those Israelis who are fighting against the expansionism and chauvinism of the Israeli state, and for withdrawal from the West Bank.
But we insist that it is no part of a democratic or socialist programme for Palestine to call for or support the destruction of the/ Israeli Jewish nation - and this is what is implied in the slogan for the secular democratic state and is in fact its only real political content.
The discussion will continue in Socialist Organiser. self-management, welfare, mutual solidarity and direct democracy.
Independance
The kibbutzim have been strong, leading elements of the Israeli working class and the great economic enterprises created are the inalienable property of the organised working class and both a guarantee of the independence of the working class as well as a model sought by others the world over.
There is, of course, no totalitarian ideological consensus in the Israeli labour movement but a very vigorous (sometimes biter) interplay of policies, which is an expression of the innate democracy of Israel.
Much - still remains to be struggled for, and the imperfections are many, but looking at the great British labour movement, who can say of it that all has already been won? There is still much to be learned from the lessons of the nationalisation of industry and the NHS, and the experience of the Histadruthenterprise with its bank and its great workers' sick-fund, which supplies up-to-date health service for the vast majority of Israel's Jewish and Arab population, may also serve British Labour to advance to a socialist society: