Fighting foi free trade unions
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-09-12Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
Polish workers in the Lenin Shipyard, Gdansk, 1981. The board behind them carries the name (painted A footnote to John Cunningham's pamphlet "Klebanov and Nikitin — the story of two Ukrainian Miners' fight against the Soviet bureaucracy" explains that, though written in 1983, "publication was deliberately held back until the miners' strike finished, so that the criticisms...of certain NUM leaders could not be used as an attack upon the NUM during the course of the dispute".
Cunningham's pamphlet is an indictment of both the anti-working class nature of the Soviet regime and also of the British trade union bureaucracy's willingness to turn a blind eye towards it.
Controlling
As the pamphlet explains, there are no genuine trade unions in the Soviet Union or in the USSR's Eastern European satellites, save the underground Solidarnosc in Poland. The so-called trade unions are merely an extension of the state apparatus: "The Soviet trade unions play the role of a Ministry of Labour. Their primary functions are organising labour resources, increasing productivity, and controlling the workforce"
Elementary norms of democracy and accountability are absent from these "trade unions". Insofar as elections out) of the official unions. occur at all, they are an empty ritual with the results a foregone conclusion: the top posts in the "unions" are occupied by appointees of the regime. The nature of Soviet "trade unions" was neatly expressed in the early 1980s by the transference of Shelpin from his post as head of the political police, the KGB, to the big boss of the Soviet "trade unions"'!
Prison
The "unions" are a political and industrial prison camp for the workers trapped in them. The story of Klebanov and Nikitin outlined in John Cunningham's pamphlet is the story of their attempts to break out of that prison camp, and the Stan Crooke reviews "Klebanov and Nikitin.the story of two Ukrainian miners' fight against the Soviet bureaucracy. written and published by John Cunningham.
penalty they were made to by the regime for doing so.
Agitation
In the 1950s Klebanov worked in the Makeyeuka mine, near Donetsck in the Ukraine, where he led agitation for better working conditions and against management malpractices. In 1964 he was sacked and briefly held in the Kashchenko Psychiatric Hospital, where he was diagnosed as having a "paranoid development of the personality"
There is a long history in the Soviet Union of dissidents being branded as "insane" or "mentally unbalance" by the authorities. Just as the British state attempts to deny the political STOCK nature of the Republican struggle in Ireland by labelling the Republican prisoners common criminals rather than political prisoners, so too the Soviet Union attempts to discredit its opponents by labelling them insane.
Arrested After three years of unemployment and then a brief spell of work again at the Makeyeuka mine, Klebanov was arrested again in 1968 after a series of protests at the mine about working conditions there.
From then until 1973 Klebanov was moved around a succession of prisons and psychiatric institutions.
Released in 1973, Klebanov once again began to petition the authorities in Moscow for his job back. Klebanov's struggle against his own victimisation brought him into contact with others who had suffered the same fate. From 1977 onwards they began to try to act collectively.
In 1977 they produced two *Open Letters to International Opinion" and the following year an "Appeal to the International Labour Organistion and the Trade Unions in the West" signed by members of the newly formed "Free Trade Union Association of Working People in the Soviet Union" (FTUA).
The FTUA was to be based on rank and file control over officials and be open to manual and non-manual workers whose rights had been flouted by the regime. The KGB stamped on it straight away, and once again arrested and imprisoned Klebanov in a psychiatric hospital, forcibly administering large doses of behaviour-modification drugs. His whereabouts are now unknown.
Nikitin' s story is one of terrible persecution for the crime of organising workers to defend themselves. A foreman at the Butouka mine in Donetsk in the sixties, he likewise led protests against bad working conditions and management malpractices. He was sacked in 1970.
In early 1972 he was arrested and locked up in Depropetrousk Psychiatric Hospital and then, until 1976, the Donetsk Regional Hospital. After a brief spell 'out' he was re-arrested by the KGB and returned to Dnepropetrousk. Released, then re-arrested again, he too was treated with heavy doses of drugs. In the Donetsck Ordinary Psychiatric Hospital early in 1984, Vasilievich Nikitin died.
Though never a member of the FTUA, Nikitin was certainly supportive of its goals. As he wrote in a letter of 1980 to the British TUC: " ...we seek aid and assistance from the trade union associations of Great Britain for an action group working to organise free trade unions in the USSR" . But it was precious little "aid and assistance" that the British labour movement gave Nikitin and his comrades.
Trade unionists suffering repression in Western capitalist countries have generally been able to successfully appeal for at least some degree of support from their brothers and sisters in other trade union organisations. But, as the pamphlet complains and documents, the imprisonment of Klebanov, take KGB attempts to win support for the struggle of Klebanov and Nikitin from leading British trade unionists generally fell on deaf ears.
This was particuarly the case with leaders of the NUM, who could legitimately have been expected to be to the fore in opposing repression of miners in other countries. But the key leaders of Britain's miners think that what exists in the Soviet Union is socialism. They support the regime there, not those workers fighting for basic trade union rights against it.
Response
In response to a letter from John Cunningham, Arthur Scargill replied: "I only wish that the people who constantly inundate this office with letters about the above two people (Klebanov and Nikitin) do not appear to show any concern or very little about the tragedy in El Salvador and Nicaragua where more people are dying in a day than have been killed in the Soviet Union in the last ten years".
Though Arthur Scargill has been critical of the official Soviet version of the events surrounding Klebanov and Nikitin, Scargill's attitude has been tempered by his sympathetic attitude to the Soviet regime. The pamphlet quotes from a speech he made in the Soviet Union in 1983, in which Arthur Scargill declared that he was "not prepared to be a party to attacks on the Soviet Union, which had established a socialist system and wants to improve the quality of life of its people.
But NUM right-wingers who are often keen to whip up some Cold War propaganda were equally indifferent to the fate of Klebanov and Nikitin. Joe Gormley, the then NUM President, washed his hands of the affair after a brief meeting with the President of the Soviet Coalminers' "Union". He declared: "As a trade union we from his flat in 1977 by the have exhausted all channels influence"
Gormley was backed up by Lancashire NUM leader Syd Vincnet.
The overall picture presented by John Cunningham's pamphlet is a frightening one of vicious repression of basic trade union rights in the Soviet Union, and of indifference towards this by left and right alike in the British trade union movement.
The pamphlet has appeared at a time when Arthur Scargill is pressing ahead with his plans to form an international federation of miners unions, basically consisting of the NUM and Eastern European fake miners' police state "unions" - including the Polish miners' "union" which - unlike Solidarnosc -did not challenge increased Polish coal exports to Britain during the miners' strike.
Inspiration
John Cunningham's timely pamphlet should be an inspiration to all trade unionists to step up support for the struggle for trade union rights in the USSR and Eastern Europe. Socialist miners who read it will see why they should take up a fight in the NUM to prevent their union being dragged into an alliance with those Eastern European anti-working class organisations which falsely masquerade as trade unions, but which scab on their members every day of the week just as the Polish police state 'unions' scabbed on the British miners' during their heroic year-long strike.
As John Cunningham writes in the conclusion to his pamphlt: "Klebanov and Nikitin made their stand and despite all the trials, tribulations and torture they suffered at the hands of the KGB, MVD and the quack "psychiatrists" of the Soviet mental prisons, they carried on. Their courage and devotion to their ideals should be an inspiration to workers the world over.
----- pull-quotes -----
KLEBANOV AND NIKITIN i story of two Ukranian mine
DADA AKE DOWA