Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Auschwitz remembered

Socialist Organiser no. 243, 12 September 1985 · scan p. 10 · Michelle Carlisle · about 567 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

Socialist Organiser no. 243 September 12 1985 Page 10 Michelle Carlisle reviews "A Painful Reminder' ', shown on TV last Sunday.

Auschwitz was the concentration camp where four million people were murdered to achieve Hitler's "Final Solution" of the "Jewish Problem". Today the name of Auschwitz symbolises all the horror and inhumanity of the Nazis.

In 1945, immediately following the liberation of the concentration camps, the British government commissioned a film crew to record the scarcely believable horros which the Nazis had inflicted on the inmates of the camp. Last Sunday, Granada TV's "A Painful Reminder" showed extensive footage of this 1945 propaganda film, originally intended for German audiences.

Dignitaries

Film shots of local scenery and of local German dignitaries from the surrounding towns watching as SS soldiers buried the thousands they had killed served two purposes; they proved that the Holocaust had happened and that it had happened with the knowledge of many German people. The Germans who were filmed fainting at the sight of the mass graves were often the same people who had used the slave labour that the camps had provided.

The film was stamped as war propaganda by its failure adequately to distinguish between Germans and Nazis. After all, Hitler's atrocities at Auschwitz and similar camps were only possible after he'd smashed the German labour movement — whose militants were the first victims in the first Nazi concentration camps after 1933.

The film showed the faces of the dead. Desperate, pained faces on emaciated bodies that were piled dozens high in deep and wide graves, marked only with the | number of occupants. The German people were Pencil drawing from Auschwitz Nazi and Child by W Nowakowski 1943 to be made aware of what had been carried out in its name by the Hitler government.

However, while the film showed the visual reality of the camps, the narrative was a subtle attempt to rewrite the Holocaust, completely underplaying the anti-semitic nature of the Nazi ideology.

The film individualised the experience of the Holocaust victims by emphasising the similarites in the experience of individual Jews, Lutherans, Catholics, rather than exposing what was special and unique about it - the systematic attempt to exterminate the Jewish people in its entirety.

Ignored

The film also ignored or played down the role that Britain played during the war with regard to the Jews. Many Jews in Britain had been interned as aliens, others were. refused entry. Jewish requests that Auschwitz be bombed by the allies were turned down on flimsy excuses, whilst factories in the surrounding areas were being bombed the film did point this out).

The government often dismissed reports about the extent of the genocide against the Jews as 'exaggerated' - members of the Foreign Office refused to help Jews to escape from Europe on the grounds that "One notable tendency in Jewish reports is to exaggerate the numbers of deportations and deaths"

Post-war propaganda in Britain focused not on Auschwitz, the scene of the largest scale extermination of the Jews, but on Belsen, in a deliberate attempt to play down that particular aspect of Nazi ideology. In post-war Germany, Britain wanted to get the German peopie capitkinst economy, and Dule it was feared that a film focusing on the evils of the Nazis would hindon thic The LILO process. projected film was shelved and remained unshown for 40 years. Ugh!

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 243

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →