Why the no vote?
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-09-12Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 11
pendea, unul the ok recal peak in the early part or uls are te malwrkers dl g conference agrees to comply year. This propaganda went and Llanelli who, despite sacklational Union of Railwaymen WF "OTLAN" TTRICK NCIL THE result of the guards' ballot on Driver Only Operation (DOO) is a serious blow to railworkers. In an 84% turnout, guards voted 4815 to 4360 not to take industrial action.
Why did the vote go against industrial action?
NUR general secretary, Jimmy Knapp, syas that guards were intimidated by the fact of four million people on the dole and softened up with the pro-1 mise that there would be compulsory redundancy for guards.
And no doubt the defeat of the miners' strike played a part in discouraging guards from starting another full-scale fight.
Strengthened by the guards" vote, BR is now blackmailing the NUR. BR has let it be known that 139 men sacked at Glasgow Central, the 44 at Margam, the 38 at Llanelli, and the 32 at Immingham will remain sacked, and the 55 at Kings Cross sus1:1 dha~ ATTID unnnll Guards' day of action against DOO. District Council secretary (in personal capacity). with DOO.
As Jimmy Knapp has said, British Rail is using the sacked and suspended railworkers as hostages against the union.
But Knapp himself has shown indecent haste in meeting BR to negotiate a compromise on DOO. There has been an attempt to present the union as now in an impasse - caught between a policy of total opposition to DOO and a body of guards who won't fight. Thus we are meant to conclude: drop the policy.
The NUR conference is being told to do precisely that.
The real picture, however, is not at all so bad. Railwayworkers can be persuaded to fight. The vote was lost by only 455 votes.
Kallworkers have suttered years of relentless management Photo: unchallenged by the union until a few weeks before the ballot.
The result had been apathy from guards who feared for their jobs but saw little lead given by the union. Weighell had fought his own executive to bring in DOO on the BedfordSt. Pancras line and Knapp has made no secret of his opinion that total opposition to DOO is wrong.
An intense propaganda campaign and intimidation was conducted on the Eastern Region whose general manager called all sectional council representatives together for his annual talk in arch and informed them that he would impose DOO on 76 trains on the Eastern Region by the autumn, "no matter what the union thought"
Knapp is right that BR intimidation played a part in the ballot result — and the one meeting held in the Eastern Region with Knapp present was insutticient to counter the pressure.
The heroes of this fight so far ings, stood solid for five weeks against DOO. When they decided to give in two members of the executive were able to get the decisions overturned before they were made effective. As one of the guards said, it was the first time they had seen "the union" and it made them feel they were not on their own.
Nonetheless, we lost it by however narrow a result and the special general meeting on September 12 has to make the most of a bad situation. The recommendation from the executıve, however, doesn't allow it to do that. It simply calls "that this executive committee recommends, following the result of the guards' ballot, that our national executive is instructed to enter into negotiations with the BRB on Driver Only Operation - passenger and freight - within the Machinery of Negotiation"
But BR want a surrender, as a letter from the Director of Personnel to the NUR states. British Rail require "an undertaking that the NUR are prepared to discuss and negotiate freely on future productivity proposals made by the Board.
The SGM cannot simply go along with this. The first priority is to get the sacked guards reinstated to their former grade and If they remain sacked the theat hangs over every oner Tanworker ngnung to keep jobs and conditions.
No negotiations should take place on any issue until this reinstatement.
Many branches have made this call, including strike action by other grades to achieve it.
The SGM should go further: It should set a date for reinstatement, and set in motion a campaign leading up to that date.
Second, any negotiations on DOO after this reinstatement shold seek to ensure that all the union's fears on safety are met; that no further destaffing takes place; that no jobs are lost; that average earnings, not just basic, are protected and that the savings should be used to cut hours.
Third, it should be made clear that only DOO is up for negotiation, nothing else.
----- pull-quotes -----
propaganda for DOO, reaching a Rick Matthews, IFL