Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

The political fund ballot!

Socialist Organiser no. 244, 19 September 1985 · scan p. 5 · about 1,189 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 5

Tories, such as that over the NGA at Warrington, led to GCHQ and the confrontation with the miners, which in its turn has produced the attack on the NUR and the employers' offensive in print.

Thatcher's success has had its limitations. The year-long struggle against the NUM was rendered victorious S. only at an appalling cost both tinancial and political. It has singularly failed to usher in the same defeatism over the whole front as after 1926. While a certain balkanisation of unions has been achieved, and the span of wage settlements extended, real wages remain surprisingly buoyant given the unions' loss of about three million members since 1979.

Disquiet

Above all, an expanding economy looks as far away as ever after six years of sacrifice. The electoral scenario for 1986 or "7 is increasingly disquieting for the Tories.

Nonetheless, Thatcher has scored successes against the unions. A framework of legislation against militant trade unionism, of an extent and sophistication unparalleled in Britain, has been moved into position, and is being increasingly complied with. The traditionally strongest unions have been battered into grudging submission. The strike rate has been decimated.

Forced Workers have been forced to accept detailed blueprints for speed-up and flexibility of labour. Productivity gains have been registered in key industries. Employers have successfully pushed into the area of short-term contracts with minimal fringe benefits. These are used for increasing numbers of 'peripheral' workers employed on worse conditions than the core' full-time employee.

In crucial sectors like print, the curtain of union protection against the introduction of new technology on unfavourable terms has been pierced, and the unions turned in on themselves. Established entrepreneurs like Maxwell and Murdoch emulate the audacity of the Thatcherite Eddie Shah.

The politics and practice of the unions have been shifted towards the right, and the TUC towards disintegration.

There were three strategies THE SUCCESS of the ballots on the maintenance of union political funds has been a triumph for the trade union leadership. -Every single union whichhas balloted has voted overwhelmingly to maintain the political levy. The margins have been resounding, the turnouts relatively massive. -In ASLEF the majority was 93% on an 80% turnout. The electricians voted by 84% to keep the fund. In the GMBU there was a 3:1 majority. Even in a right-wing white-collar union like APEX 39,500 of the unions 90,000 members were for continued political involvement, and 14,000 against, in a 60% poll. The left can only welcome these results. In one sense they illustrate the fundamental loyalty of the union rank and file to the Labour Party, for in essence the ballots are about whether or not the unions should maintain links with the Party.

They also illustrate the fun damental loyalty the ranks give to their union organisation and its existing leadership.

But the union leaders did on offer at Blackpool earlier this month.

The EETPU have grasped the Thatcher project of business unionism with both hands, at the industrial level. They see this as a means of guaranteeing organisational security for themselves and stimulating a friendly response from the government at the political level.

Contrary to some analysis, the AUEW/EETPU hard right's much preferred option is a Kinnock government in 1986-7. They see their collaborationist approach as the best means of ensuring this. But they also want to keep their options open in relation to a further Thatcher administration, and to keep limited relations with the SDP-Liberal Alliance as a possible power broker.

The TUC majority wants to over a hundred cases members of unions - left, right and campaign. Had operations of this dimension been mounted in struggles such as the miners' strike, who knows what the results might have been?

Put in a wider perspective the results are far less heartening. As a whole the campaigns were carefully controlled. The Labour Party link was usually (though not always) played down. Politicians were kept out of the picture. Initiatives promised by the left to use the occasion to go on the offensive and raise the question of why we need the Labour Party, of the present politics of Labour, of closer links between unions and party, an of more democratic links between unions and Labour, never materialised.

The campaigns have been conservative and defensive. They have illustrated the limits of how far Thatcher can push unions to the right despite the victories under he belt. They also showed once more the inability of the left to do more than hold an unsatisfactory line. A rebuff for the government but hardly a blow for socialism in the unions. hold the line formally. They bitterly oppose the attempts of the hard right to drop formal positions of defying the Tories. But they also wish to restrain struggle now - because they think it is a barrier to their crock of gold, a Kinnock rerun of the Wilson/Callaghan social contract.

Balanced

So at Blackpool TUC general secretary Norman Willis took up a 'balanced' position on the crucial question of anti-union law. "We're not departing from Wembley — that would be a signal that we're giving up our policy of opposition. But nor are we being daft and embarking on a collision course which will result in desperate losses"

In the aftermath of the miners' defeat, the third tendency at Blackpool was much weaker than the other two. It was represented by Arthur Scargill, arguing for a strategy of class struggle which starts with the minority in the unions who see the necessity of combining the struggle in the factories and plants with the struggle for a government which will implement socialist policies, rather than a re-run of the disastrous social contract by whatever name.

The hard right made the running at Blackpool. Confident and defiant, the EETPU and the AUEW brought the majority to heel. Paralysed by the threat of a major split over the issue of taking government money for ballots, the TUC centre and left drew back from confrontation. Such a split would be immediately exploited by Thatcher and could seriously undermine the TUC General Council's ability to act as a broker for a new social contract with Labour.

Yet the problem is only postponed. The EETPU and the AUEW would prefer to live without the anti-union laws. Those laws limit the manoeuvres of Mark Salmon. even such pliant bureaucracies. But they also wish to drop defiance now and to wait for a solution from a Labour government.

Not only the Airline Pilots and the Power Engineers, but also the building union UCATT and the white-collar union ASTMS are also embracing this conclusion.

The compromise arranged by the TUC was that AUEW members would vote again on the issue of taking government money for union ballots. If this recher will readmit the union leaders to talks on economic and social policy. Lord Young's offer to talk to the TUC is as yet far from that. If some variant of 'Mondism' (the 'social contract' of the 1920s, under a Tory government) does not develop, then we will be in for further sharp conflict between government and unions.

And that can opportunity.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 244

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →