The Tories said that the miners' strike was 'a threat to democracy'. From the viewpoint of most people, the real threat to democracy is the increase in police powers, weaponry and numbers. Arthur Bough discusses how Labour should
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-09-19Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
TELL THE GUARDIAN A SECRE Stop The City demo. March 1984. Photo: Andrew Moore British capitalism is sick, even sicker than the system as a whole. Over the last two decades the British labour movement has not been strong enough to replace the bourgeoisie but it has. been strong enough to repel the bosses' attacks like the Industrial Relations Act.
So the capitalist class has attacked with greater force. The Tories laid their plans (the Ridley Report), replenished their arsenal (more, better-trained and equipped police, new anti-union laws) and took on the In the wake of the miners' defeat, socialsts must take the threat to civil liberties seriously, and warl nut a aroramme for defending and extending demoWour D cratic rights.
The need for a police force seems to most people to be obvious. yet the police force has existed for only just over a century.
The working class was hostile to the new force. In North Staffordshire in 1842, for example:
"During the week the inhabitants of Lane End have been in a state of fearful apprehension and excitement from the disorderly conduct of a number of persons in the lowest ranks of society. We have been at considerable trouble to attain accurate information as to the cause of the tumult and find that the principal one is the extreme aversion and hatred entertained by the parties towards the new police force lately established in 1842).
Nevertheless, in a broad historical view there was something progressive about the establishment of police forces. The arbitrary private power of the landlords, squires, and magnates was replaced by a public power operating under publiclydecided general laws and procedures.
Public power
Now we see that public power becoming more and more a power against the public. In times of sharp class struggle it becomes clear that the police enforce the interests not of the majority, but of the ruling class. Their rigid hierarchy, their training, their separation from the rest of society, and the personal ties of their upper ranks make sure that they do that.
Society today has an alternative, more democratic way of regulating itself - patrols organised and controlled by the labour movement and local communities. Police duty should be made a part-time job of every citizen, like jury service.
To bring that about we will have to break up and dismantle the existing police force. In the meantime we must fight for more control over it.
The police force in Britain is marked by the almost complete absence of democratic control. Police Committees exist (except in London!) but a large proportion of their members are unelected magistrates and they have virtually no power.
In Merseyside it has recently been reported - though officially denied by the cops - that the police have mounted surveillance on Labour members of the Police Committee whom they find too argumentative. Who's controlling whom?
The following demands would be a start to democratising the police force in Britain.
*Chief Constables and Assistants to be elected at regular fixed periods.
*Directly-elected Police Committees to have full operational control over the police force in their area. The power to instantly dismiss Chief Constables who act contrary to their instructions, and to call fresh elections for a new Chief Constable. Access to any police station and to police files at any time for members of the Committee. *Democratic rights within the police force including the right to form trade unions. The right not to be used as scab-herders.
The recent revelations about MIS confirm that the secret service is far more concerned about surveillance of the labour movement and peace movement than
Scan page 7
acy and the state italist class has conceded wider ted, Parliament is almost entirevoting rights, it has protected ly controlled by the leadership of itself by moving real power away the government party which Every four or five years we get CVI servants, bankers and that vote that our ancestors industrialists than with any met. fought so hard for. Control of the elected MPs. Manifesto promedia - and the first-past- mises mises aportant decisignored. date. two big parties a near monopoly, taken outside Parliament.
Pickets' car attacked by riot police in Notts. Photo: John Harris of 1854, and introduced because Britain's Crimean War was being undermined by the total incompetence of the civil service.
Its growth was a major element in shifting day-to-day power from the Parliament and the monarchy to a bureaucratic machine.
Within the civil service real power lies with the 500 or so Permanent Secretaries, Deputy Secretaries, and Under Secretaries that make up the higher civil service.
Between 1948 and 1956, 78% of those recruited to the position of Assistant Principal had attended Oxford or Cambridge universities; in 1957-63 this actually increased to 85%; and in 1971 and 1972 it was still more than half.
By background, education, personal situation and connections, the top civil servants are flesh and blood of the ruling class. Many go on from the civil service to top jobs in finance and industry.
They have tremendous power and influence. Ministers move from one Department to another every two or three years, but the higher civil servants are in their posts for a lifetime.
The civil servants can use their control of information to get Ministers to adopt particular courses of action, and discard others.
Benn When the last Labour government was elected, so Tony Benn reports, the civil servants in the Department of Industry had prepared a report for the incoming Minister which was marked "For the attention of the Minister, unless Mr. Benn"
The cases of Clive Ponting and Sarah Tisdall illustrate the conservative bias of the civil service and the way it operates to keep many public affairs secret from the public.
An irresolute, unprepared reforming government can easily have its measures filtered down, delayed, and neutralised by the civil service machine. And a determined radical leftwing government would certainly face open sabotage.
The Official Secrets Act should be abolished; a Freedom of Information Act introduced; and top civil service jobs made elective.
It took a long and sometimes bloody struggle by the labour and women's movements to get our present rights to vote. But at the same time as the capfrom Parliament.
the-post electoral system — give and drive those two parties towards the "centre" ground of politics. Even the SDP-Liberal Alliance - well-connected, wealthy, favoured by the media - has had great trouble breaking through. Little surprise then that radical or revolutionary views can't get represented in Parliament.
Control
Then, once the MPs are elecwork much more closely with top And even if by some fluke a determined, cohesive majority of MPs opposed to the status quo should be elected, the other institutions of Parliament would stand in the way of change.
Between 1906 and 1910 the Liberal government had 18 Bills thrown out by the House of Lords. Things boiled over when the Lords threw out the Liberals' Budget of 1909. The Liberals called a General Election over the issue, and threatened to create 1,000 new Peers. Having won the election, the Liberals passed the 1911 Parliament Act which said that the Lords could only delay Bills, not stop them altogether. That power to delay was further reduced by the Labour government of 1948. But it is still a substantial - and firmly conservative — power.
And then, before any Bill can become law it must be given Royal Assent. Normally this is a formality: Kings and Queens have signed Bills which the Tories vehemently denounced. But what would happen if a Labour government tried to abolish the House of Lords, amidst cries by leading judges that this was unconstitutional? Let alone if a Labour government legislated directly socialist measures?
Reserve The monarchy represents an important reserve power for the ruling class in case of crisis.
For example, it is the Monarch who has the power to dissolve Parliament. She could use that power to force an election. A similar thing was done in Australia as recently as 1975. The Governor-General - the Queen's representative - sacked the reforming Labour government of Gough Whitlam.
Constitutionally, the Courts, the police, the armed forces, etc., derive their authority not from the government but from the Crown. In such a crisis the Queen could call on all these institutions to 'defend the Constitution' Over a hundred years after they were raised some of the of tha demands of the Chartists still have not been met. For example, the demand for annual elections. It is ludicrous for any government to claim that the result of an election gives them a mandate for up to five year after especially as in that time most of them renege on what they promised. Annual elections would ensure that governments were far more accountable, and that they would be less likely to renege on their promises. If Britain was to live up to even the ideals of bourgeois parliamentary democracy then the following demands would have to be *Annual elections *Voting to be by Proportional Representation, the current first past the post system svstem amounts rigging.
*Scrap the deposit, and other qualifications for candidates.
*Equal TV and Radio time for all parties except fascists.
Most bourgeois democracies have laws setting out the right to strike - though with qualifications and limits. Britain has none. All the legal rights of trade unions in Britain are 'immunities' which exempt unions from the general laws about conspiracy, breach of contract, etc. Indeed, there are no basic human rights for British citizens which Parliament cannot constitutionally take away.
A major step forward for civil liberties in Britain would therefore be to adopt a written Bill of Rights as exists in America and most other bourgeois democracies.
While the experience of the Equal Pay Act and the Sex and Race Discrimination Acts show that such legal documents are no guarantee of equality, it is better to have such documents to refer" to than not to have them.
Bringing women's, black, and lesbian/gay groups together with the trade unions and labour movement and groups like the NCCL to discuss the elements! of a Bill of Rights could be the basis of a strong campaign. The campaign for such a Bill of Rights could be conducted on the same basis that the Chartists and Suffragettes campaigned for their demands - by industrial action and civil disobedience.
The best constitution in the world cannot guarantee that the rights it provides for are met. At the end of the day only class struggle determines that. But the balance of forces in the class struggle itself depends partly on what rights are written into law at any particular time.
Rights
The question of democratic rights is therefore of great impórtance for the labour movement. The labour movement should put itself at the head of a campaign to defend and extend democratic rights in Britain.
This could undermine the Tories and set the stage for the revival and regeneration of the labour movement.
As Lenin put it:
*Even in England [i.e. not just in Tsarist Russia, or Imperial Germany we see that powerful social groups support the privileged position of that institution (the Civil Service). Why?
*Because it is in the interests of the proletariat alone to democratise it completely; the most progressive strata of the bourgeoisie defend certain prerogatives of the bureaucracy and are opposed to the election of all officials, opposed to the complete abolition of electoral qualifications, opposed to making officials directly responsible to the people, etc., because these strata realise that the proletariat will take advantage of such complete democratisation in order to use it against the bourgeoisie."
...when economic and political issues, and socialist and democratic activities, are united into one whole, into the class struggle of the proletariat, this does not weaken but strengthens the democratic movement and the political struggle, by bringing it closer to the real interests of the mass of the people, dragging political issues out of the 'stuffy studies of the intelligentsia' into the street. into the midst of the workers am
----- pull-quotes -----
that neighbourhood." (North Staffordshire Mercury, May 11,