"Many trade unionists think that a workers' "party must emerge"
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-09-19Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
openly in a political way. They reject this - and rightly, I think. At this time it would be organisational suicide and would only lead to the arrest of their leaderships.
What are the differences between the two big alliances in the liberation movement, the United Democratic Front (UDF) and the National Forum?
Both originated about the same time in 1983.
The NF remained true to the original. idea of building a common opposition of all forces that rejected the new constitution, the so-called "New Deal'. The main organisations taking part in the NF were the Azania People's Organisation (AZAPO), the only legal national organisation of blacks, and the Cape Action League.
Both alliances are made up mainly of black workers. The workers are organised in the townships, and their organisations belong to one of the two alliances. The black petty bourgeoisie and intellectuals are also represented in both alliances.
In the UDF there are also bourgeois (mainly white) elements, liberals and business people with links to big capital. Of course the organisations of the National Forum also have white members from community organisations, student organisations, and trade unions; but not this bourgeois element.
CUSA, one of the two big black trade union federations, belongs both to the UDF and the NF.
The NF campaigned against the constitution much more seriously than the UDE, in which a right wing time and again proposed using the constitutional institutions as a platform for legal propaganda.
The basis of the NF is the 'Manifesto of the Azanian People', which is of course not a socialist programme, but in any case puts socialism on the agenda. On the other hand the UDF has not even been able to unite on the Freedom Charter, the ANC's 1955 manifesto for an anti-apartheid coalition.
We are ready for joint The hated pass books. Photo: IDAH work with the UDF, but not for a political alliance, because we reject collaboration with the liberals.
Consequently we rejected the visit of US Senator Edward Kennedy which the UDF welcomed. With that visit important capitalist circles in the US and in South Africa itself wanted to push the Botha government into reforms.
So is socialism on the in the consciousness movement's activists?
Quite definitely. Obviously most people have no scientific, disciplined conception of socialism. But since about 1980 most activists have been clear that apartheid could only be removed by socialist solutions of some sort.
The trade unions on one side, the community organisations, tenants' organisations, etc. on the other, are building an organisational foundation for a socialist movement.
It is still not a workers movement. There is still no workers' party, but the foun dation for such a party has already been established And some member organisations of the NF, like the Black Alliance of Mining and Construction Workers' Unions, have already progressed very far on the road to a socialist strategy.
As against that, the old and new left belonging to the UDF start from the idea that the movement should not go beyond national and democratic goals - though there are socialist-orientated organisations affiliated to the UDF too.
The bourgeois camp, internationally and in South Africa itself, is split in its attitude to the Botha government. Some bourgeois forces in the US call for a boycott. How do you explain this?
The strategic situation in South Africa is differently assessed.
There are capitalist politicians who consider that the Afrikaner National party and the Botha government are the only force that can carry through reforms without endangering the system itself.
Others, further to the left, INDEA-I DEKS LANONI and luluk cealik vit ampielke sebruk.)
Uk vir amıptelike cbtuik 10 g Black strikers, Durban 1973 are on the contrary convinced that such a reform can be carried through only by the cooption of the moderate leadership of the African nationalist movement. And these forces, who are aiming for a new power bloc, propose an economic boycott.
Is such a reform solution possible, and is there a social basis for it?
Even so far-reaching a concession as legal equality can no longer integrate the blacks, above all the youth.
As against the national-democratic theoreticians of the UDF it must be maintained that the revolution in South Africa has a permanent character.
The caste system indeed implies that in time many BuSNaVAE M BEDr IMA more Indians and Coloureds can be politically neutralised than blacks. The many black collaborators in the townships show, however, that fundamentally even classified Blacks can be neutralised.
On the other hand the youth of precisely these intermediate layers rejects this government and the new constitution most sharply, and takes part in the revolt. Other than repression the government has no means to solve the question of apartheid. It does not have enough time.
I believe that in the next five or ten years the capitalist powers of the West will see themselves forced to bring the moderate wing of the liberation movement to power somehow, as in Zimbabwe. But the attempt to put a limit to the movement by that means will fail.
Of course we cannot predict how the revolution will then proceed, but it is the classic situation of a permanent revolution.
Is South Africa revolution?
In the National Forum we have tried to warn against two dangers since 1983: a premature uprising and a Latin-Americanisation of the country. Both are now threatening.
It was clear that a revolt was coming. It must be in the interest of the Botha government to provoke a premature outbreak of the revolt, so as to stifle it quicker and eliminate its leadership through a wave of arrests or through the state of emergency.
The precise moment may not be favourable for the government,. because it is in a very difficult situation economically. But there can be no doubt of the government's preparedness to impose the state of emergency.
This state of emergency will not last very long, but in that time organisations will be destroyed or have their leaderships removed, and it will take some years to build them up again. The aim of the state of emergency is a breathing-space in which the so-called 'reform movement' can be extended and the black middle class neutralised.
The moderate leadership of the United Democratic Front (UDF) did not think this wave of repression was possible. It assessed not only the international situation but also the relation of forces inside the country falsely and expected that the government would be forced into negotiations. In reality we are moving towards Latin American conditions.
That means that the regime allows a limited political debate so as then to remove the leadership that shows itself openly, either legally or illegally through death-squads - as has already begun with the murder of the oppositional lawyer Victoria Mxenge.
The movement should have prepared itself for this. But it is clear that the UDF and also parts of the National Forum and even the unions were not quite prepared for this wave of repression.
The unions will probably come out of it best, because they hold back from open revolutionary activity and have only carried on general political education among their members. ( But won't the brutal state intervention lead to a further politicisation and extension of the revolt?
Politicisation, yes, but not necessarily an extension of the open revolt.
We are in a situation very similar to Northern Ireland. The government can torget, once and for all, the idea of bringing over the black youth and the black population to their side: integration is excluded.
But the workers cannot sustain an open revolt indefinitely in South Africa any more than they can anywhere else. There will continue to be sporadic revolts in the townships.
If we had an army, as in Iran in 1979, that was recruited from the 'sons of the people, then it would perhaps be possible today to talk about a successful revolution. But it will be years before we have such a situation. You can't talk about a successful revolution when you don't know how to neutralise the army and the bureaucracy. And they are still 85% white.
The government will not let the proportion of blacks in the state apparatus increase quickly, because it knows that is their own power-base Anyone who says that a successful revolution is possible in the next two or three years does. not understand the situation.
It would be different if an international war neutralised the army in South Africa and gave us the opportunity to come to power. But no neighbouring state is strong enough even to threaten South Africa.