Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Can Irish people be united?

Socialist Organiser no. 244, 19 September 1985 · scan p. 10 · about 560 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

I don't know when this song was written or who wrote it, but it has all the marks of the late '60s. Those were the days when the left was in the ascendant in Northern Ireland - or seemed to be - and we thought that the war cries of Orangemen and Nationalists had lost their power to control events Of course it is politically naive and hopelessly 'economistic! For all that the song's sentiments are good ones. It goes to Stan Crooke SINN Fein's recently produced video 'Bodenstown — the legacy of Wolfe Tone' asks the question of whether Wolfe Tone's commitment is still relevant today, "to substitute for the various denominations of Protestant, Catholic and Dissenter, the common name of Irishman"

Wolfe Tone was the pioneer of Irish Republicanism and leader of the 1798 uprising of the United Irishmen, who sought to unite all Irish - Protestant, Catholic and Dissenter - in a common struggle against British interference in Irish affairs and for the democratic ideals of the French revolution.

Captured after the defeat of the uprising, Tone committed a grisly suicide. His grave in Bodenstown, in southern Ireland, is now the scene of annual Republican demonstrations.

The video answers its question by providing an outline history of Ireland and the Republican movement from Tone's time down to the present day.

Interspersed in this history are scenes of balaclava-clad and combat-jacketed Republicans marching up and down leafy country lanes, or shooting it out with 'the Brits' on the streets of Belfast against a background of lilting Irish melodies.

The video's argument is that Wolfe Tone' s goal was valid in his day, but now, in the aftermath of partition and the creation of a sectarian Northern Ireland statelet, no longer.

Tone's enemy was an alliance of the landed gentry (many of whom lived in England and only drew rents from Ireland) and the Established Church (to which everyone in Ireland to pay tithes though only a few belonged). Against this it was possible to unite Dissenter and liberal Anglican craft workers and merchants with mostly Catholic peasants.

Unviable

The 1798 uprising was an expression of the validity of Tone's ideas. But subsequent developments made the basic tenet of the United Irishmen increasingly unviable. estant and Catholic.

Irish Marxists have argued that this means that a new programme and a new social basis are needed to realise Tone's ideal — a working-class socialist programme. Sinn Fein's conclusion is essentially to maintain the same narrow nationalist programme but to base it only on the Catholic community.

The video thus provides a Songs of kind of theoretical justification for Sinn Fein's decision of the early '80s to drop the policy of a federal united Ireland after British withdrawal. Although tinged by an Irish nationalist rebellion mysticism, that policy was at least an attempt to placate Protestant fears about a united Ireland meaning Catholic domination.

Dropping the policy of a federal Ireland and the abandonment of "Tone's original formula" are two sides of the same coin: a retreat into a nat- the tune of 'The Rocks of Bawn'. ionalism based narrowly on the Catholic community, and thus. into a hopeless war of attrition against the Protestants.

Many on the British left are starry-eyed about Sinn Fein's left turn on many social

----- pull-quotes -----

HOUs NO SURRENDER CLUB

liberty and

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 244

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →