Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

The Orange and the Green

Socialist Organiser no. 244, 19 September 1985 · scan p. 10 · about 578 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

Come all you frish workers and listen unto me While you're fighting with each other, your country can't be fi Your foes are in the North and South, they're cunning and the To keep you separated by the Orange and the Green.

They have sold the land from under you to the Yankee and the From Dublin town to Galway and from Cork to Donegal They work each day in Stormont and in Leinster House are Passing cruel laws to keep the Orange and the Green.

Your bosses are united as you work hard every day Their profits keep on rising but they never raise your pay The landlords and the bankers keep their hands so neat and clea The colour that they love is Gold, not the Orange or the Green. What is it that you want to keep? How much do you have now? As you work in street or factory or else behind a plough Which one do you want robbing you, a president or a queen? Does hunger have a colour? Is it Orange, is is Green? Do you get double wages from your kindly Orange boss? Does your Catholic employer ever, ever make a loss? Do they share the profits with you? Or have you ever seen A landlord who says 'Rents are free' to Orange or to Green?

So follow any God you wish, let each man choose his faith But God won't lift the pick for you, it's you must turn the lathe Unite and fight together, against them turn your spleen Then we'll have a workers' country with no Orange and no Green. Les 1985 Page 10 The emergence of the Orange Order - a sectarian Protestant organisation - in the late 18th century, the industrialisation of North-East Ireland, the growing discrimination against Catholics in the emerging industry, and, above all, the partition of Ireland and the institutionalisation of sectarianism in the North, destroyed the basis for the realisation of Tone's ideal.

Thus the Sinn Fein video concludes "today there is little or no hope of using Tone's original formula of uniting Protestant, Catholic and Dissenter into a force against the British"

It is true that the social conditions of Tone's time no longer exist. The landlords were bought out by the British government in the late 19th and early 20th century, and the process was completed by the Southern government in the 1930s. The Church was disestablished in 1870. Partition has hardened the divisions and created a sort of 'Ulster nationalism' among the Protestants.

For sure, simple opposition to Britain is no. longer a programme capable of uniting Protand economic questions, and will doubtless find much in the video about which to become even more starry-eyed. Within mean limits, that left turn is real enough. And there is no reason to doubt the video's sincerity in stressing the need for Republicans to be both non-sectarian and anti-sectarian.

But Sinn Fein make their sincerely-proclaimed aims of socialist and non-sectarian Republicanism an empty gesture when they dismiss the basic tenet of the pioneer of Irish Republicanism as no longer applicable, and they dismiss any attempt to placate Protestant fears as a 'sop to loyalism' The Republicans are waging a justified struggle against British oppression, and should be supported by socialists in Britain and elsewhere. But this video is a reminder - albeit an unintentional one - that such support cannot be at the price of socialists, abandoning their political independence.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 244

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →