Handouts to the bosses?
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-09-26Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
and Labour Eric Heffer MP told Socialist Organiser:
As far as Labour Party conference is concerned, I want to see a very clear reiteration of the basic policy of the party which has been developed over the past two years, and I want to see very clear support for the miners.
I want to see clear support for the Liverpool councillors and the workers who are involved in that struggle.
And I want to see the party really exposing the Liberals and the SDP as the other side of the Tory coin, and demonstrating to the country that we are prepared to go out as a united force on our basic socialist policies.
On Liverpool, I want to see the Party executive reiterate the resolution it passed in June, and I want to see the conference go on record in support. I want see financial aid developed, and trade unionists giving whatever support is possible.
Tony Benn:
I HOPE that the 1985 Labour Party conference is clear on its support for the miners' resolution; endorses the womHANDOUTS to the bosses.
that's the new socialism, Neil Kinnock style.
The central economic policy statement to be presented to this year's Labour Party conference is entitled Investing in Britain' It proposes a National Investment Bank.
Pension funds and other financial institutions would be compelled to limit their overseas holdings, and to put some of their money into the NIB, on pain of losing tax concessions.
The money thus gathered together would then be doled out to industrial capitalists.
The statement also proposes increased public investmentbuilding houses, sewers, roads, hospitals, etc. It says that the double boost to investment, both private and public, will create new, useful jobs (though it avoids any promises about reducing unemployment by definite amounts in any definite timescale).
Nationalisation is no part of this strategy. The whole statement is hinged round a policy of pushing and nudging British capitalism into expansion by judicious (and, as the document repeatedly insists, "prudent") use of state money.
As a socialist policy this is nonsense. Its theoretical assum ption is that British capitalist investment in Britain is socialist; foreign capitalist investment in Britain is dubious (the statement makes no reference to it; its general attitude to investment being a Good Thing apparently breaks down when the investment is foreign; and British capitalist investment abroad is positively evil!
*The Conservatives are the anti-investment party" , it says. But investment, under the present system, is another name for increasing capital. What Labour's NEC is trying to tell us is that the Tories are the anticapitalist party, and that Labour can expand capitalism better.
How does the statement stand up as a capitalist policy? Not very well.
Martin ferent proposition from the capitalist state as attendant to senile enterprise.
The NIB will help some enterprises. That does not mean that will increase the overall number of useful jobs. If profit remains the regulator of the economy, and if profit levels in Britain remain low, then the only effect of the NIB will be to shift investment from one area to another.
It could well end up like the last Labour government's National Enterprise Board, as an agency which does little more than help declining enterprises to chop and purge their workforce in a more gradual, efficient manner.
The capitalist economists who advocate state-organised investment schemes are clear that an essential condition for their success is control over wages to allow a rise in profits. The NIB scheme is either hot air, or part of a package with incomes policy. And even together with incomes policy, and even in capitalist terms, it may not work.
A socialist policy would have to start from the principle of breaking the rule of profit, rather than manipulating it; from common ownership, rather than coaxing the bosses with handouts; and from internationalism, rather than the statement's narrow nationalism.
The NEC's main complaint against Britain's capitalists is that "Because of their overseas interests, they often fail to put Britain's needs first" . As if workers have, or should have, no "overseas interests'"! As if the issue is "overseas" versus 'Britain", not bosses versus workers.
The NEC is also presenting to conference a statement on the Third World - much shorter and more perfunctory one on investment.
The statement condemns the Tories roundly, but its own proposals are utterly inadequate.
In this context the NEC is able to see something wrong with the notion that if resources go outside Britain they are therefore "wasted". It does propose increased aid to the poorest countries and use of the resources of British industry to help those countries develop suitable technologies.
It is all on a miserable scale, though. The statement promises that the next Labour government will increase aid from 0.33% of Britain's nationa income to 0.7% over five years.
Cutting military spending by half and putting those resources into saving lives rather than accumulating the means to kill people would put four or five times as much into aid — nearly 3% of national income. Putting the four million unemployed to work and dedicating half the extra production to aid would put in maybe twice as much again — six per cent or so.
So far Labour has done practically nothing to campaign about the terrible famine in Africa - a result of international capitalism which makes Britain's decay and dole queues seem like tlea-bites in comparison. The statement promises no change.
The best it does is "call on the government to promote joint international action to reschedule and where possible write off the debts of the poorest countries. No commitment to cance the debt burden which cripples many famine-stricken countries.
The economic policy proposed by Neil Kinnock and Roy Hattersley is nationalist, capitalistoriented, and at best a recipe for a re-run of the 1964-70 and 1974-9 governments. It should be rejected.
• any breaka If such a re has been ho onal Union acceot ing expelled from the TUC could very well retain their Labour Party links.
Weaseling Such weaseling helps Lynk to confuse and corral doubtful The Party nationally should stop helping the scab-herders. Neil Kinnock should come out publicly with the policy stated in Larry Whitty's letter. Veil Kinnock. Photo: John Harris