New Socialism? Ol
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-09-26Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
› The left-wing Labour Party weekly Tribune has just 're-launched' itself as the voice of born-again Kinnockism. John O'Mahony examines the 'Democratic Socialist' manifesto put forward for the re-launch. !
group of Tribune supporters in the Parliamentary Labour Party and outside, was circulated last month to generate political support for the relaunched 6 • TRIBUNE • 20 SEPTEMBER 1985 Tribune. had expressed their support for the statement.
Kevin Barron MP
Margaret Beckett MP Rodney Bickerstaffe (NUPE)
Roland Boyes MP. David Blunkett (leader Sheffield City Council)
Gordon Brown MP Richard Caborn MP Ann Clywd MP Christine Crawley MEP Robin Cook MP Ken Coates Keva Coombes (leader Merseyside County Paul Convery (secretary Labour Co-ordinating Committee)
Jack Dromey (TGWU)
Michael Elliot MEP Derek Fatchett MP Mark Fisher MP Glyn Ford MEP George Galloway Bill Gilby (chair Labour Co-ordinating Committee)
Bryan Gould MP Peter Hain Fred Hasson Harriet Harman MP Peter Heathfield (NUM)
Stuart Holland MP Bob Hughes MP Doug Hoyle MP Joan Lestor Ken Livingstone Ron Leighton MP David Martin MEP ichael Meacher MP John Maxton MP Lewis Minkin bill Mortis (TGWU)
Stan Newens MEP Stan Orme MP Martin O'Neill MP Terry Patchett MP Peter Pike MP Jo Richardson MP Clare Short MP Chris Smith Mr Clive Soley MP Gavin Strang MP aham Stringer (leader Manchester City rom Sawyer (NUPE)
Jack Taylor (NUM) Carol Tongue MEP Keith Vaz Mike Ward (deputy leader GLC)
Bob Wareing MP David Winnick MP The following statement, which was drafted by a By the time of going to press, the following For too long the Left has allowed its political opponents to caricature and distor socialism. While we have debated our own particular notions of socialism internally, the public has grown increasingly confused about what a socialist Britain would be like to live in.
There is a real need to restate, develop and argue for socialist values in a way that can build popular support and convince the electorate that socialism is relevant to the problems of modern Britain.
In this task there are two underlying themes which characterise the democratic socialism we seek to promote.
(i) DEMOCRACY Socialism is fundamentally concerned witl the extension of democracy. It must be ou purpose to extend the responsibility for decision-making in our society to the greatest possible number of people. This should be reflected in our style of politics, which should emphasise not only parliamentary activity but also political involvement at all levels in our communiti and at work. (i) OPPORTUNITY We live in a society in which class-based inequality is widespread. That tequauty shows itself in education, housing, health care and at work. Inequality is further aggravated by sexual and racial discrimination.
Socialism aims to eradicate all forms of social inequality so that every individual has the opportunity to develop his or her talents to the full.
These two themes should be central to the Labour Party's campaigning and underpin the development of our policy. Economic power: Economic power must be made publiciy accountable through an extension ut social owuerslip, planning and industrial democracy, not merely to make the economy more efficient but to restructure it so that oower and wealth are used for the public good rather than for the benefit of a few individuals.
Political power: Democratic socialism must also involve a redistribution of political power. This is why open government, the reform/of parliament and the civil service and the restoration and extension of power!
to local government must form part of any socialist project.
It is also in this context that we beliève Britain must retain the option of withdrawa from the EEC.
International power: The search for peace, a determination to disengage immediately from the nuclear arms raco and the pursuit of policies to provide self-tetermination and basic human and material rights for those in the Third World must torm the basis of our international approach.
We believe a Britain not aligned to any major power is best placed to advance thes policies.
We wish to see a Labour Party which:
• clearly puts socialism on the political • is open and outward-looking in the expression of its values • campaigns in a way which clearly links our policies with the underlying socialist policies which muet apane them • encourages the presentation of ideas anc debate in a spirit which recognises the legitimacy of minority views.
To achieve power and to use power effectively, Labour needs to campaign on broad socialist themes. We do not simply want to replace Thatcherism; we must win people's hearts and minds for a better WA •WE MUST win the ideological battle against the Marxists' , said Neil Kinnock to Tribune's newlysoftened soft-left editor Nigel Williamson, who interviewed him in last week's 'relaunched' Tribune.
Tribune was out on the battlefield ahead of him. The crowing glory of the 'relaunch' was a manifesto grandiloquently entitled 'Democratic Socialism - a Tribune Relaunch Statement' , and signed by 54 dignitaries, 33 of them MPs or Members of the European Parliament.
Signatories include black sections advocate Keith Vaz; Peter Hain; NUM general secretary Peter Heathfield; Jo Richardson; Ken Coates; and, of course, the future Lord Redken, the hero of the local government struggle who left Liverpool in the lurch. Conspicuously absent are the names of Eric Heffer, Tony Benn, Dennis Skinner, and Jeremy Corbyn.
Despite some signatures that should not be there, the statement is a sad example of the politics of the increasingly depoliticised if not a-political careerist left. An example of the political ad-man's art, rather than of the politician's - the "cynical soft-sell', as Ken Livingstone himself described it, talking about his publicity campaign for the GLC.
Echo Echoing the opening paragraphs of the Communist Manifesto of Marx and Engels, published in 1848, Tribune says: "For too long the Left has allowed its political opponents to caricature and distort socialism.. the public has grown increasingly confused about what a socialist Britain would be like to live in"
So: "It is high time that Communists should openly, in the face of the whole world, publish their views, their aims, their tendencies, and meet this nursery tale of the Spectre of Communism with a Manifest of the party itself".
That was the Communist Manifesto! Tribune is a lot less clear: "There is a real need to restate, develop and argue for socialist values in a way that can build popular support and convince the electorate that socialism is relevant to the problems of modern Britain". Not only this limp sentence, but also the whole manifesto, makes the reader wonder whether the statement's authors, are themselves "convinced"
There are, says Tribune, "two underlying themes which characterise the democratic socialism we seek to promote". These are "Democracy" and "Opportunity".
'Socialism is fundamentally concerned with the extension of democracy"
True: but, as we shall see, Tribune does not have much to say about how to do it.
On the level of political tutions, we have yet to win the battle for democracy in Britain. It's no use saying 'we have more democracy than the USSR or Chile'. That's true, but irrelevant.
We have the right to elect the central committee of the ruling class' who will govern us, once every five years. Real power is in the hands of a permanent non-elected civil service.
When a reforming Labour government is elected, it must vie for control with this permanent bureaucracy, which is linked with the ruling class and the Tory party by a thousand strings of wealth, education, family and sympathy. In fact Labour Cabinets slot into the system. Even under a Labour government basic decisions are not taken by parliament, but by the Cabinet, by the prime minister alone, or sometimes by the permanent officials without apy reference to politicians.
For example, the decision to build the British atom bomb in the late 1940s was an executive decision that was not even announced to Parliament, let alone voted on.
We need an extension of democracy, that's for sure. The programme of democracy inscribed on the banner of the first mass working-class movement, the Chartists of the 1830s and *40s, has never been realised in full.
The Chartist demand for annual parliaments would make a continuation of the present government with its present politics impossible: with the exception of the period immediately following the Falklands war, the Thatcher government would have been likely to meet defeat at the polls at most times since 1979.
If we had a proper democracy they would not have been able to hang on in office, to manoeuvre, to secure their base by beating down and demoralising the working class, and then to choose the best time for the fiveyearly poll as Thatcher did in 1983.
On the level of the economic affairs which in the final analysis govern society we have no democracy at all. The Tories waged a sustained propaganda war on the miners during their heroic strike, demanding that they have a ballot. None of the Tories or the Fleet Street editors, and not even any of the Labour Party leaders, suggested that there was anything wrong in fact that miners were not balloted on pit closures.
There is no economic democracy in Britain. On the most basic things in their workaday - or dole-a-day - lives, fifty million people in Britain have no say. We are at the mercy of an industrial and financial oligarchy, an oligarchy that doesn't even accept that workers have the right to live except on condition that they can be exploited for profit.
Yes, we democracy. Lenin summed up how to get it in a single sentence: "The workers, after winning political power, will smash the old bureaucratic apparatus, shatter it to its very foundations, and raze it to the ground; they will replace it by a new one, consisting of the very same workers and employees, against whose transformation into bureaucrats the measures will at once be taken which were specified in detail by Marx and Engels:
"(1) not only election, but also recall at any time;
(2) pay not to exceed that of a worker;
(3) immediate introduction of control and supervision by all, so that all may become. bureaucrats' for a time, and that, therefore, nobody may be able to become a 'bureaucrat'"
What does Tribune say? "It must be our purpose to extend the responsibility for decision-making in our society to - the greatest possible number of people". How? Tribune doesn't know. But it is sure that 'This should be reflected in our style [their emphasis] of politics, which should emphasise not only parliamentary activity but also political involvement at all levels in our communities and at work"
End of programme for democracy!
A serious fight by the labour movement - under Neil Kinnock' 's leadership or even under Roy Hattersley's — for an extension of democracy would be a tremendously energising and progressive development. Marxists would argue that we will not get a linear extension of democracy from now to working-class democracy as described by Lenin without a revolution; but we would support any, even limited, fight to extend democracy.
Resist
Tribune wants democracy. Good for Tribune! What does it propose we do about it? Nothing! Nothing at all!
Well, Nigel Williamson might say, we do want to do something: we want to elect a Labour government. That's the standard response to everything these So do we want to elect a Labour, government — even the one we are likely to get under a Neil Kinnock premiership.
But that is not going to change the system: it will slot into it. Socialists and democrats will have to pressure, resist, and fight against that government in defence of working class interests. We will have to do battle against the operation of the present state machine, which will not change its character by having Neil Kinnock and Roy Hattersley perched on top of it.
What about the second 'theme', 'opportunity'? "Class-based inequality is widespread ... aggravated by sexual and racial discrimination". On the other hand 'Socialism aims to eradicate all forms of social inequality so that every individual has the opportunity to develop his or her talents to the full"
Individual opportunity is not quite all there is to socialist, and it's about developing capacities for enjoyment as well as 'talents'. But leave that aside. What does Tribune propose we do to achieve equal opportunity? What is is about our society - which politically is not a tyranny, and economically rests on equal exchange - that produces, reproduces, and perpetuates inequality?
Socialists say it is the private ownership of the means of production, which enables the capitalists to exchange a pittance of wages for the worker's capacity to produce new value, and which thus lets them exploit the working class.
Clause Four of the Labour Chris Mullin, the previous edi victim Pat Wall speaking. Nov centralised witch-hunt of Mili
Scan page 7
) CAREER SM YES for nice. Thatcher Challenge Cup for the union with the highest "yes" vote in the political ion. Photo: Stefano Cagnoni (Report). Party constitution commits the party to do something about it - to take industry out of the hands of the capitalists. Tribune? Tribune has nothing to suggest except empty phrases. It merely talks about "themes" which should be "central to the Labour Party's campaigning" and "underpin the development of our policy".
"Economic power must be made publicly accountable through an extension of public ownership, planning and industrial democracy... so that power and wealth are used for the public good rather than for the benefit of a few individuals"
What does this mean? What is "an extension" of public ownership? Why less than what Clause 4 talks of? Why less than the replacement of the capitalists? Without replacing the capitalists all talk of serious planning is nothing but talk of a Labour government coordinating a capitalist economy.
Without nationalisation of the commanding heights of the economy (to use an expression appropriated by Nye Bevan from Lenin) there is no way that the economy will not be used "for the benefit of a few individuals"
Either live with the capitalists and serve them, comrades, or oppose them and overthrow them. That's been the choice for every Labour government and will be the choice for the next one. Each time the Labour government has served capitalism. Manifestos such as Tribune's are part of the preparation that will ensure that a Kinnock government will do likewise.
*Power must be made publicly accountable"? Socialism and equality, comrades, are about breaking capitalist power, not about trying to make it accountable.
Those are Tribune's proposals about "economic power" . It also proposes "a redistribution of political power... the reform of parliament and the civil service and the restoration and extension of powers to local government" . But we can't just "redistribute" power in any fundamental way: either the bosses hold the power, as on all essentials they do now, through the state machine and their control of the economy; or we do. To talk of mere "redistribution" is to talk of leaving the decisive power where it is now - with the class that Mrs Thatcher serves.
The manifesto talks not of unilateral disarmament but more vaguely of "a determination to disengage immediately from the nuclear arms race" (an arms freeze?).
On the EEC they say "Britain must retain the option of withdrawal from the EEC". That's better than the little-England chauvinism that Tribune has peddled for the last quarter of a century - except that it is not a re-think, but only a diluted version of the old line. They propose no international perspective, and probably still think that an island siege economy is the best road to socialism -only they dilute the policy in self-prostration before the new Labour Party establishment, which has no intention of upsetting the EEC arrangements.
Alert
EXCLUSIVE INTERVIEW
20 SEPTEMBER 1° PRODUCTION MANAGER American bases will go, pledges Kinnock Vote JAMIE, DETTMER AT THE SDP'S TEA PARTY IN TORQUAY page five LABOUR will set about implementing nuclear defence polics on the first day it takes Neil pledges in an exclusive interview with Tribune non- Kinnuck centre see office. this week pages:
DEMOCRATIC SOCIALISM a Tribune relaunch statement fund ballot, from Joe Marino of the bakers' uni