Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Stakhanov- the Stalinist Rambo

Socialist Organiser no. 245, 26 September 1985 · scan p. 9 · about 1,270 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

What the USSR in the 1930s was really like: a famine victim Ine use or piecework pay- UVEILULIC CHOLIC ments and the development of and crisis of the economy which Stakhanovism in the Soviet it mismanages. We need the Union also led to even larger rebirth of socialist democracy in differentials than under capital- the Soviet Union and this А. Г. СТАХАНОВ • 1906 Communist Party of the Soviet Union) forcefully reminded its readers, saw the emergence of 'Stakhanovism" in the Soviet Union.

Alexei Stakhanov was a miner in the "Irmino-Central" pit in the district of Voroshilovgrad. On International Youth Day in September 1935 he achieved a coal output on his shift 14 times [sic] higher than the norm, and thus gave his name to a Soviet Union-wide movement committed to raising productivity.

At the time, Stakhanov was portrayed like an early Soviet version of Rambo. While Rambo expresses the sick ideals of American capitalism by running round shooting Vietnamese and Russians, Stakhanov expressed the ideals of a recently consolidated Stalinist bureaucracy who needed to win the war for increased productivity against the passive or covertly active resistance of the Soviet workers who by then had been deprived of all rights. "Stakhanovism" was the name given to the merciless speeding up imposed on the defeated Soviet workers by their Stalinist oppressors. Naturally, they called it "socialism".

"Stakhanovism," declared Stalin, was the "preparation of the conditions for the transition from socialism to communism" It was not an expression of the Soviet masses striving to build socialism, but a reflection of their struggle for existence in an economically backward Stalinist police-state.

Piecework In the years preceding Stakhanovism, the ruling bureaucracy employed a variety of measures to try to boost productivity and efficiency in the economy, but with little or no success: the first Five Year Plan, the encouragement of "shock brigadism" and "socialist competition" and the introduction of a form of piecework payment. -But, as Trotsky explained, the attempts at piecework payments "came to grief against the spectral character of the valuta and the heterogeneity of prices ...only the abolition of the card system, the beginning of stabilisation and the unification of prices created the conditions for the application of piecework payment."

By 1935, after years of falling living standards and rising prices, piecework payment had become a viable possibility. Workers were encouraged to achieve more technical progress, cut costs and increase productivity. Success in such goals, given the use of piecework payment, would allow workers to claw back some of their living standards which had slumped so disastrously in the early 'thirties.

Whip

Stakhanovism, therefore, was anything but the spontaneous expression of the workers' selfsacrificing love for their "socialist fatherland". It was rooted in the efforts of the bureaucracy to overcome economic backwardness and the under-use of contemporary technology, while workers were "motivated" by the whip of the struggle for survival.

Stakhanov's own recordbreaking feat was far from spontaneous. In fact it was more of a stunt than a real event. Fundamentally, it was achieved by better use of existing resources, both human and physical, to support the star performer, Stakhanov.

As Konstantin Petrov, Communist Party organiser in Stakhanov's pit in 1935, explains in an interview in "Soviet Culture"

*Several months before the record we passed around questionnaires in the pit: what should be done to raise productivity of labour of face-workers? One of the suggestions was to introduce different methods for extraction of the coal, which would leave the face-workers free from auxiliary operations. Moreover, many miners lacked trust in the new, at that time, techniques of coal-extraction".

The scene was thus set for Stakhanov's feat: "In that night Alexei worked as never before masterfully, with great inspiration. The noise of his tools, it seemed, never ceased... Stakhanov hewed the coal joyfully, enthusiastically"

Publicised

His example was followed by others at the pit: "At the first meeting of the workers (after Stakhanov's record-breaking shift) 40 volunteers enrolled, wanting to work according to the new, Stakhanovite, method" Publicised by the regime throughout the Soviet Union, Stakhanovism also spread rapidly to other branches of the Productivity certainly rose with the spread of Stakhanovism, though not as much as individual enterprises or the regime as a whole claimed. In any case, existing norms were often low, given that they were based on the inefficiencies of the early 'thirties.

Blockages

But Stakhanovism could also lead to a fall in the overall output of an enterprise, as Stakhanovite workers raised their own level of producivity out of line with the rest of the workforce and thus created blockages in the production process. Some times the non-Stakhanovite workers would also deliberately work even slower than usual to frustrate the Stakhanovites' exertions, thereby further lowering the rate of output.

Nor did Stakhanovism have anything in common with the transition from socialism to communism. Stakhanovism was inseparable from piecework payWhat the USSR in the ment, accurately described by Marx as that form of payment "most suitable to capitalistic methods of production". Apologists for the Stalinist regime invented the fiction of a "socialist" piecework payment.

But even under capitalism, piecework payment drives people to work in violation of their natural instincts and abilities, whipped on by the "stick" of the norm and attracted by the "carrot" of the bonus for exceeding the norm. In the Soviet Union of 1935, with its rigid labour discipline — administrative fines for absenteeism, expulsion from the union and thereby partial loss of social benefits, dismissal and eviction from factory housing — the use of piecework payment was a savage violation of socialist values and principles.

Crude

As Trotsky wrote: "In the struggle to achieve European and American standards, the classic method of exploitation, such as piecework payment, are applied in such naked and crude forms as would not be permitted even by reformist trade unions in bourgeois countries... As to the preparation of a "transition from socialism to communism" that will begin at exactly the opposite end - not with the introduction of piecework payment, but with its abolition as a relic of barbarism.

ism - Stakhanovite Dould pick up as manc "ordinary" workers, whilst Stakhanovite specialists could be paid even 100 times the wages of an unskilled labourer. On top of this, Stakhanovites received all manner of perks and privileges as well.

But this, of course, was of benefit to the Stalinist bureaucracy: the artificial creation of an upper stratum of the working class, enjoying many of the privileges of sections of the bureaucracy, strengthened the position of the bureaucracy in Soviet society. The ordinary Soviet workers had good reason for hating the norm-busting Stakhanovite star performers.

Rebirth

Stakhanovism was the wrong answer to the wrong question. It was not a socialist, working class solution to the economic backwardness of the Soviet Union. And it did not address itself to the real obstacle to rational planning and growth of the nationalised Soviet economy on the basis of democratic workers' control of the economy: the rule of the Stalinist bureaucracy.

Today, as the Soviet Union celebrates, by order, the fiftieth anniversary of the beginnings of the Stakhanovite movement, and a new cult around Stakhanov seems to be reemerging, that fundamental obstacle of the Stalinist regime continues to exist. What is needed is not the rebirth of Stakhanovism to help the regime Anato ma chronic craonatinm be achiewed

----- pull-quotes -----

years ago Alexei Stakhanov, a coal-miner in the USSR, achieved 14 times higher than his

put his and put his name int ke tells Crooke tells the story

Commemorative envelope cover fc Stakhanov issued USSR into histo

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 245

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →