OR AGAINST THEM? Who makes Labour policy? (From page 1)
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-10-03Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 3
Continued from page 1 the Gaitskell/Wilson/Callaghan BOCe. 'red rabble: facing down the at Labour Party conference and putting them in their place as election foot-soldiers for the parliamentarians.
Thus even before a Kinnock government takes office - and when it is not at all to be taken for granted that Labour will win the next election - the issue is once again posed sharply before the Labour Party: who decides what a Labour government does? Party conference or an entrenched, autocratic, officeobsessed leadership?
Kinnock and his supporters base themselves on two arguments: that the electorate would not vote for a party committed to the miners; and that reimbursing the NUM would be interference with the integrity of the courts and would damage very fabric of democracy.| How do they know what electorate would vote for?
A campaigning Labour Party could win the electorate for socialist policies, just as a campaigning militant TUC could have helped the miners win their strike.
The second argument is more serious. Law courts that are impervious to political pressure and protected from arbitrary interference are indeed worth preserving and defending.
But is that what happened in the court cases which imposed crippling fines on the NUM? When the High Court appointed a Tory solicitor to declare *I am the NUM'. was that the law above politics?
The NUM was fined and penalised - and the miners now in jail were put there - fundamentally because in a bitter class war their opponents had the State and the law on their side. The miners are the victims of class justice.
For the labour movement to make a god of the decisions of the law courts that backed up the scab-herding, strike-breaking police sent by Margaret Thatcher against the miners, would be to accept our own paralysis in our future struggle.
The miners were picked on and fought back despite unfavourable conditions. The idea that the decisions of the courts under such circumstances are sacrosanct is the idea that the labour movement should lie down and let the ruling class walk all over us whenever they decide on a serious offensive.
The labour movement in office should undo what the police and the courts did. Such retrospective lifting of penalties has happened before under governments both Tory and Labour: Kinnock rejects it now not because he has been studying the theory of abstract justice, but because he wants to demonstrate his acceptability to the bosses and bankers.
It is not that socialists should lack respect for the ideal of impartial justice and courts "impervious to praise or blame'. It is that we do not have such colts, or such a legal system. Or at any rate the miners didn't have the benefit of such law courts and such a system.
The jailed miners and their almost-pauperised union present the labour movement with a basic test case. Anybody who does not side with the miners now will never be any good for anything the working class needs to achieve.